LogFAQs > #980850169

MacArrowny posted...

Could you be more specific? I'm not really understanding.

I can't speak for kev, but my worry is that, by treating both endings as potentially canon, they'll end up losing everything that should make those endings special. Max would go down a completely different path in life in one ending vs the other. The people in her life should be radically different, and not in small ways that'll be easy to write or program.

If they "respect" both endings by, for example, maybe at one point Max gets a phone call from Chloe or a phone call from Warren instead, then to me that trivializes the entirety of LiS. It doesn't matter what ending you pick if Max ends up here no matter what.

Ideally the two timelines actually would be radically different to account for each ending, but I don't for a second think they'll put the effort into doing that. It'll be like the True Colors DLC, Wavelengths, where it asks you which ending you got in LiS and the only thing it changes are a few offhand comments. And that's fine for Steph, she wasn't even in Arcadia Bay at the time. It just wouldn't work for Max imo