LogFAQs > #978779347

Tenlaar posted...

You are waffling back and forth between saying you dont have a problem with somebody choosing a setting and then having an ethnically accurate cast of characters for that setting and saying that Beauty and the Beast isnt specifically about the setting of a small town in 18th century France so that isnt a reason to have an ethnically accurate cast. If the first is true then the second doesnt matter.

No, my position is quite clear. You just refuse to read.

Don't whine to me about accuracy when the story itself is not accurate nor is the story about France. You would actually have a point about accuracy if the story was actually about France, and specifically the French. You would have a point if Disney was actually telling a non fictional story about real history. Instead we have grown men crying an already inaccurate story about a country its not actually about, with magical talking furniture and people talking in American English, and real furries..... is inaccurate the moment they see non white people.

If the story is not specifically about France (as the story could be set literally anywhere), and accuracy went out the window the moment furniture started singing, and a town broke into song in American accents, among other inaccuracies..., then it does not matter who they cast. The story isnt even about a real event in real history. The people crying about so called accuracy don't actually care about accuracy.