I'm more counting in-ring product than "total package," although part of that is the charismatic ability to manipulate the crowd through wrestling. I'm not really counting pure "promo ability" though, per se.
Bryan is probably the most TALENTED wrestler in the world, they just don't give him a chance to show it off much.
Aries is out there stealing the show every other week for the last 10 months. TNA has given him the opportunity that WWE hasn't given Bryan, despite having been World Champion.
Jericho still has to re-prove himself after his comeback. He's clearly still VERY GOOD, I just want more evidence that he's still ELITE.
I still like Generico better than Steen. Generico would be my (not 100% educated) choice for Best on the Indies right now.
--
Thank you, Eddie Guerrero.
http://www.wwe.com/f/styles/photo_large/public/photo/image/2012/04/WM28_Photo_255.jpg