Tom
Gandalf
Scar
Yoshi
The Dread Pirate Roberts Wesley
Professor Oak
Batman
Roger Rabbit
Genie
George Castanza
Donatello
*Captain Malcolm 'Mal' Reynolds
Pikachu
J.D. Dorian
Goofy
Tie Breaker (1st to 5 votes!)
Carlton Banks
--
"Coinflip is sacred."