Ok heres a list of 10 I am considering
Portal 2 (Since portal 1 got a 3)
Final Fantasy 4 (due to 6 getting a 3)
Super Metroid (you gave Prime 0's but I thought I remembered you were in some Metroid topic on the board recently)
Silent Hill 2 (just a hunch plus you liked Bioshock)
Some different Warioware game (This could be tricky - maybe you only like the first, or there may be too many others you dont like)
Batman (NES) (Who didn't like this game)
Mega Man X (You liked MMBN... no one guessed any other MM games... a possibility? Maybe a NES Mega Man?)
Earthbound (Who knows if you played it, but based on giving some SNES games a 3 and RPGs, I feel like itd get a 3 if you played it)
WWF No Mercy (I... think I thought you liked wrestling? If so, I feel like this would be a great guess)
Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga or Bowser's Inside Story (If you like SMRPG and PM this could be a solid choice too)
So yeah... these will probably be what I pick from.
Will think!
--
~Wigs~
New York FOOTBALL Giants: SUPER BOWL XLVI CHAMPIONS