I definitely feel safe saying Tamina wins that match. And that's nothing against Kelly Kelly in kayfabe, it's just that Tamina's been on a role (by which I mean she has had a lot of matches with Natalya), and I'd totally, kayfabe-wise, expect that to translate into a win against anyone who's not Beth.
Now if K2 got to squash Nattie before their #1 Contender's Match, I'd say it could go either way. But I mean the only thing Kelly has done in the past month was lose to the Bellas in a tag match, and then beat the Bellas in a tag match via interference by the guest announcer. Tamina's really been the only girl to face Natalya lately, so she just kind of stands above the rest by default.
--
Ace Detective in Sir Chris' Police
http://i54.tinypic.com/2a5gdux.gif