I guess this is different for everyone because the shape is terrible for me
it definitely is going to change depending on your hand shape, to me it fits like a glove though. I'd rank them GCN > 360 > whatever sony calls its controller now, the grips on sony controllers are terrible IMO
But the worst part is the sticks. The main stick is so flimsy and the plastic spiky top is not comfortable
it wears down with use pretty badly, it's actually tighter than the dual shock in new condition as I recall, but can become very loose where I haven't had that kind of breakdown with sony or MS' controllers, or with the wiichuk
But the worst part for me really is the shoulder buttons. The triggers are SO terrible squeeze in. It's like an entire centimeter you need to squeeze to get it completely in
I think the 360 pad has the best triggers, really don't like the bumpers though, even worse than the Z button in their inconvenience IMO
Face buttons are fine, but that's it. They aren't even analog. Honestly I don't know why this isn't a standard already. Maybe Sony patented it or something?
I don't think so since MS also uses analog buttons, but who knows