uh smurf is the one who has been and will always continue to ignore any legitimate criticism that is directed his way, that is why all of his lists have always been and will always continue to be trash
Ignoring a couple of WTF-choices like omegaman, I'm very lenient on a list like this, because, like yo said, there's always going to be bias and there simply isn't a superuser on the board who's been here since '02 and has extensive knowledge of all the subgroups that have ever been here. From what I've seen the "legitimate criticism" is basically a bunch of users saying "this isn't how I would've done this list," and their opinions aren't more valid than Smurf's. Just because half the board thinks HM should be in the top 5 doesn't mean they're more objectively right than Smurf is.
--
Full rap metal jacket ~ Method Man