I am the master of Superstars.
Don't be too down on the Diva's over that match. Post-show matches suffer a big penalty because the workers aren't into it and are getting ready to go home. I didn't know that until about a month ago. So overall, that was actually a decent match they put on!
If you hire, like, Trish, and job her to your current Divas, they'll get hugely over. Or just stick them in Sex Appeal angles that are at least four minutes. It's actually not too difficult to get the Divas over, and since WWE is a popularity over performance fed, they'll get great ratings and can really bolster your midcard.
--
Ace Detective in Sir Chris' Police
I assure you, my dear, all Ace Detectives are perfect gentlemen!