I've watched every season since Season 1 (except the last one because goddamn... 3 Russel seasons in a row, are you kidding me Probst?), but I haven't actually rewatched any so I don't remember them well enough to rank them.
Wasn't Micronesia the one where Parvati had the whole Black Widow thing going on and James was such a lovable idiot? I loved that season. >_> Not my favorite, but it was genuinely interesting.
--
Come one, come all! Come vote in the Save My Harry Potter Character FINALS - http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/61288944