Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 is getting pretty close to most overrated, especially on b8
Others off the top of my head
-Original LoZ. Adventure of Link was a much better NES zelda
-Halo. PC gaming had been doing FPSs much better, much earlier
-Another this gen choice: Uncharted
-On B8? MGS3 is very overrated. MGS3 is a top 50 game of all time, but MGS1 and MGS2 are much better games. And they get a bit less attention (especially MGS2)
-Oblivion. Morrowind and Daggerfall blow it out of the ****ing water. Oblivion is absurdly dumbed down and has little reason to get lost in the world and explore
--
(2:50:41 AM) Andrew Gripshover: and i've kind of accepted that pittsburgh is superior to my city