A. Vote: Game A
B. Vote: Game B
This is fine.
C. I've played Game A, but not Game B.
D. I've played Game B, but not Game A.
Honestly, I'd like to still vote for a favorite game of mine even if it was going against a game I had never played. Unfortunately, with this system, my favorite games would be victims I'd think.
E. I haven't played either of them.
This is a useless option almost. If people have never played the games then they'll probably not bother to vote at all and just skip posting int he topic.
--
People do not care how much you know until they know how much you care.