My approach ended up working in a good way (despite the time it took). Each anime got a coin flip. Heads win, tails loss. Each round determined the order of each show. Stuff like Boys Be and Rozen Maiden were things I really wanted to see, so they got free passes. Say a show got through one round of flips. That means they would be watched sooner than ones that didn't. I think I ended up getting all the way to +8 and +9 with these.
Boys Be
B Gata H Kei (the description scares me...but I can't help it)
Deadman Wonderland (Greg Ayres personally recommended this to me)
Moonlight Mile
Rozen Maiden
Between 70 handpicked shows and Netflix's other supply, I won't be hurting for stuff to watch.
--
Random Encounters Suck