Lurker > 5tarscream

Process of discrimination. Or POD.

So whats your read Lopen? Ben is lying and both pez and death are town? Tom is scum? Or are all 3 town. Which would leave who?

SBell, hb(confirmed Harry Potter), puns, Lea, yourself, Corrik, Lolo, Ulti (confirmed gardener).

You think SBell, Ben, Lea and who? Cam?

I also think death because the Mary Shelley claim is easier to lie about given the expected evil flavour on a scan.

If we dont believe him and hes lynched then his guilty scans look less guilty.
If we do believe him and he has two town players as guilty then he trades 1 for 1 at best.
If we do believe him and he gives us a scum then he can use the extra time to clear more scum or frame more town.

So Im guessing either pez or death are scum but not likely both.

##Unvote:

So more thoughts on Ben;

Hes telling the truth and has two guilty scans. Reasons why this is unlikely. He kept two guilty scans to himself with 2 scum dead because he wanted more scans and assumed hed be safe. Horrible reasoning and a terrible risk.
He also allowed claimed bg to go to a tie with MZero because he was ok with MZero or Sbell dying. I think that was the reason right? Then after MZero flipped he scanned Tom not SBell.
When Cam voted pez he got excited and voted pez too, only to hop off later with a lame I tried. Except hes literally claiming cop with a guilty scab on pez. How did you try when you held that information back?

Option 2) hes lying town and really really suspects pez. So much so that hes willing to gamble this big even after being given an out by pez himself to back off.
Unlikely because hed surely have backed off and tried to get pez later instead of potentially suiciding.

Option 3) hes lying scum. This is a ploy to try and get the protection off the confirmed scanner so they can either kill the scanner or one of the protection.

I think 3 is the most likely because 1 is a multitude of horrible decisions that just dont make sense. 2 is an unnecessary risk after being given an out. Now, I think if it is option 3 that Ben would give us at least 1 scum.

Lea whats your claim?

Same with Sam I am. Who hates everything right.

Sorry been busy at work and then went to watch Spider-Man. Just caught up. So for the purpose of preventing flavour scans Id say mary shelley is the weakest claim.
If the role is Frankenstein or Frankensteins creature then the flavour would likely be negative and the player hides behind oh no Im the author not the actual character.

Ben.
Can you tell me why when you had 2 guilty scans yesterday you didn't mention anything and let us mislynch town instead of absolute nailed on scum?
Like we had a vote tie (I think) between MZero and potential BG and you just let that roll on? You didn't think the potential of lynching BG was a big risk?
If you don't believe Lolo is bg then why on earth did you scan Tom last night and not Lolo?
If you think Lolo IS town then why did you let it get so close when you had 2 confirmed scum in your back pocket?

Lolo, Corrik. Are your roles clear or do they have an unusual name?

Town cop? That doesnt really match with my role. My role doesnt say flavour cop. It says book reader or something. I can read one person every night. Why would mine say book reader but yours be so clear?

As stated in your pm

Ben can you tell me what your role is. Not your flavour but youre actual role.

Of the three I say Cam. His confusion in his miller flavour, his frustration at not being listened too. His saving of lolo. All three suggest town to me.
Im a little annoyed at his reluctance to full claim at this point but it is what it is.

I dont want to lynch Cam let me be clear.
I think if he was scum hed have left lolo to die.
Hb is Harry Potter which most likely makes him town.
Ulti is gardener which most likely makes him town.
I am flavour cop. Town.
We assume corrik is town chronomancer
Lolo is bg.

I think Leas claim is bs. I think her bite hopping is bs. I think her driving MZero literally everyday is bs. Zero wasnt playing well but SBell and Lea where on that every single day. Barely even looking elsewhere in SBells case.

Id be down to lynch either of them. Im suspicious of Ben too.

##Vote: Lea

I wish Id trusted my instinct on the scan last night. I felt like it was a waste of time scanning hb but on the bright side. I can confirm he is Harry Potter.

I think Ulti has made a truly terrible start to the day and saying MZero popped up last second to vote is ridiculous.

Of course he voted Lolo. That was the other lynch option. It was vote Lolo or die himself. Cams switch was really poor. I dunno what he was trying to do with the pez thing either.

So who IS the best player on B8?

Im waiting to get the next book in WoT. Ive read the first three but getting hold of the others in China is difficult.

Hermione Granger
Vivi

Scott Pilgrim
Room

Practically the whole Scott Pilgrim movie is quotable.

I think outside of OBJECTION!! PW isn't that quotable but it is really popular. Everything is a popularity contest. EVERYTHING. *narrows eyes*

Clown fiesta I have lessons

Obellisk posted...

Lolo was the lily Potter bg claim right?

Are you even bothering to read the game? It's not like this was a minor moment.
Tell me why we should keep you around?

Also I think Cam said he doesn't want to claim his role. Lolo claimed BG.
Three HP characters and 2 of them are power?

hb's worst moments where when he got played by Lopen about the not reading thing. Then on top of that his defense was poor at best. I remember not liking Ben and SBell because they were doing more to defend hb than he was himself.

This is about the most active I've seen hb and all he's doing is saying maybe SBell but maybe MZero but maybe SBell.

His pushing of MZero over SBell makes me want to do the opposite.

I might be the only one that still wants to vote hb

Bed time. Night Tom.

Can I give town points for making me laugh at vanillager

This is a quality rant. Please use this opportunity to also rage about other things you hate.

Less people need to play PW and more need to watch KP.

Its is losing. Making it the victor.
Tiger tiger tiger tiger

I mean he was a non factor with regards to suspicion last game so I have nothing to judge it against. He claimed miller early then the scanners outed themselves d2 so there was no need to go after him from either side.
Like I said before this is maybe my 4th or 5th game ever so I dont have the backlog of reads and comparisons. I feel like neither of these two clowns has done much but I guess I like MZeros work more.
I honestly have no feeling about MZeros confidence though, I guess if anything he should have been more confident last game when he was basically never getting lunched or scum killed. So if I had to have a lean Id say its a negative but its next to nothing from me I dont know his gameplay enough.

I think I buy MZerod reaction to the votes more than SBell and they are both refusing to claim I believe. I voted Zero today to get more activity I think hes been a little more active but maybe Im just looking for it more.
However hes still lacking content for me. Like I couldnt tell you anything hes done except vote SBell and defend his lack of activity.
I feel like SBell has had more interactions and will provide more info as such. I feel like MZero is a wasted lynch I just wish hed do something.

Why wouldnt they poison Chris n1?

Thats more what I was asking pez yeah.

So here comes my favourite question. Can you tell me 1 person whose read would be changed by both a town flip lolo and a scum flip lolo
This isnt just pez feel free to join in everyone

Ok as devils advocate.
If we lynch Lolo and he flips town. First we done goofed but on a much more serious note where would the next step be. Especially if hb is scum godfather and has the opposite flavour to cam

Simpsons
Kung Pow

I think hes basically saying its so broken it shouldnt because theyd be invincible as a final 2 and cant lose. He protects lolo. Lolo protects him they cant die. I think is his theory

I mean if I was making that role. Lily would have died on her first protection, which Id presume was Chris N1. How is Lolo still alive?
Lolo can you answer any of this? Who did you protect?

Should send him to China for sentencing. Sure itd be a fair and just sentence

So who would you lynch today?

I didnt like Ben or SBell originally for defending hb. Now youre suggesting lolo is protecting him too. I buy Harry Potter scum godfather as the opposition to Voldemort Miller. Why else would so many scum suspects be defending hb? Even if he scans Harry Potter Id be more inclined to think hes godfather.

I think Lolos Claim is not dissimilar to reds in that its too perfect and it requires a wait and see and itll be obvious that buys potential scum more time.
If I was to use lily as protection it would be a one shot protection though. They wouldnt be living again every night because well she didnt. Its more of a sacrifice role Id say. Like a kill absorb sort of thing.

Also they had redirector and a backup. So basically we killed back to back redirectors. Go team.

Interesting

Hook
How did we get here?
Deadpool's 4th wall breaks.

hopefully not much later.

turbopuns3 posted...

It was based on my claim making more sense if I'm town than scum, and assisted by me not being a player who is described by his initial PoE steps which he just listed (including Chris's read)

Your claim that you have since completely rescinded?

Corrik did you say which poem you are?

Pez I think death is town. His play seems pretty similar to last game and I know there's been a few posts and opinions I've been impressed by though I can't remember the exact posts.