Lurker > htaeD

Okay Peaf you get to explain that then, dont be lazy now.

Tho yes I didnt even notice the miller claim. (I also dont even remember who immediately suspected me last game. Because why would I keep track of that anyway?)

Well that BCT should answer

It was
BCT did explain what he meant with that (claiming a console that has to fit hammerer maybe not being on the safelist), though I dont think he thought that through.

I can see that you might see it that way in one case. (since I should have stated my opinion on Red VS dumey more clearly)
But I think I am pretty clearly taking BCTs side in the other case.
Thats me wanting to douse the fire.

UnderUrMattress posted...

The vibe of his post there feels like pitting red/dumey and bct/peaf against each other rather than truthfully trying to sort them.

What?
They already pit themselves against each other.

Oh yeah Edumey's other argument in post # 69 did catch my eye, but I dont like it either since I feel this exact argument was used against that 'dies in 3 days role' that was in Xenoblade 3 Mafia.
(which turned out to be true)

Also a scumhammerer role I once saw (In Dr Hammer Mafia)
Just gained powers if they hammered a player at the end of day
Reds role here sounds subtantially different.

red13n posted...

Would you like to elaborate which part of Dumey's post causes me to lose my truthfulness? He brings up illogical scenarios but doesn't actually address my claim in its individuality in the slightest.

So nothing on your thoughts should change here.

Thus, I accuse you of bullshitting your post. I think you should die.

you are right that Edumey has a lot of weird scenarios overall. But I think the part about you making this claim if you are a scumhammerer seems like a valid scenario to me.
At worst(best?) this just reduced your claim from '100 % town action' to less than that. I dont think Dumey is right to say you being a scumhammerer somehow has a higher chance of being true either.

Immediate thoughts
I believed Reds claim at first, but EDumey does bring up some decent counter points.
Wouldnt want to test his power right away, though I feel nobody was serious about that anyway.
But I do want to ask Red for some clarification.
Do you need to hammer every day? Or just today?

Peaf calling BCTs flavor demand post bad is confusing to me. Wanting Red to claim his flavor is a reasonable request. And I dont know how it would hurt town or help scum if he did claim his console considering that scum probably has a safelist.
Peaf bringing up the counter argument later is a bit more understandable, but BCT explained that part at least in a way that I believe he would think that way (even if his logic is not really applicable here)

Less a fan of EDumey already spending a lot of words on consequences of 'Lopen=scum' when we arent even at step one of that theory yet.

I would like for Lopen to explain his Mzero vote tho

Oh hi