Of course.You really believe he would have actually murdered Ben based on the information in the movie?
He didn't. It's just the detractors trying to misrepresent that scene.Exactly. I just wanted to make a poll to see how many people are still misunderstanding the scene. I've found that it helps if people put more than thirty seconds of thought into it.
it's been a while since I've seen it, but I think it was more of a knee jerk kind of thing, and that he wouldn't have gone through with it.
but he himself knew how tempting it was to go to the Dark Side, and his dad was one of the most infamous Sith, so I could be wrong.
That is the worst thing out of the new trilogy . People whine about other shit but it's really thatWhat, the fact that people misunderstood the scene? It's definitely one of the most cited things that people hate about it, but even in this poll six years later, 32% of respondents straight up didn't get what actually happened.
What, the fact that people misunderstood the scene? It's definitely one of the most cited things that people hate about it, but even in this poll six years later, 32% of respondents straight up didn't get what actually happened.That Luke even considered it is stupid
That Luke even considered it is stupid
That Luke even considered it is stupidAs stupid as him losing his shit and hammering Vader on the ground while he was already down?
Is this like when you posted that article the other day without reading it first but it's posting about a movie you haven't watched?I have seen every star wars movie
I have seen every star wars movieBut did you pay close attention and try to empathize with the characters, or are you thinking only logically? Emotions are crazy sometimes.
But did you pay close attention and try to empathize with the characters, or are you thinking only logically? Emotions are crazy sometimes.I'm basing it on how he refused to kill his father years earlier
I'm basing it on how he refused to kill his father years earlierHe was seconds away from killing him, though. Actively attacking him so hard, with so much rage, that he took a hand off him. The only thing that really snapped him out of it was Palpatine's gloating.
I mean, when Rey confronts him on it in the film he admits exactly what happened.This answer is correct
He saw that Snoke had already poisoned Ben against him and that Ben would destroy everything and kill everyone he loved and in a moment of weakness he considered killing him to prevent that, but he immediately changed his mind and felt ashamed for even considering it.
He considered killing him briefly, but never actually tried to.
He was seconds away from killing him, though. Actively attacking him so hard, with so much rage, that he took a hand off him. The only thing that really snapped him out of it was Palpatine's gloating.
It's actually well within his character
People who complain about this don't want a character, they want a hero.
Which is ironic, because the literal point of the movie is that Luke the person and Luke the idolized war hero are two different people.Yeah, people didn't like that. They wanted ultra Jedi master Luke Skywalker from the EU, not impulsive barely-trained, flawed Luke Skywalker from the actual movie trilogy. He was never a stoic Jedi, he was only pretending to be.
Yeah, people didn't like that. They wanted ultra Jedi master Luke Skywalker from the EU, not impulsive barely-trained, flawed Luke Skywalker from the actual movie trilogy. He was never a stoic Jedi, he was only pretending to be.How dare fans of Star Wars not want their childhood hero to be heroic!
Nah better he be a complete failure that the galaxy would of been better off if he had never been born.Bruh I swear TLJ haters have no idea who Luke actually was, or what he actually said and did during the movies he appeared in.
Bruh I swear TLJ haters have no idea who Luke actually was, or what he actually said and did during the movies he appeared in.Almost like they expected him to grow into a Jedi Master and restore the order.
Bruh I swear TLJ haters have no idea who Luke actually was, or what he actually said and did during the movies he appeared in.It's so insane. I feel like Star Wars is the number one property where "fans" think they know everything and are 100 percent correct, that their interpretation is the ONLY valid one, even when it is demonstrably wrong!
It's so insane. I feel like Star Wars is the number one property where "fans" think they know everything and are 100 percent correct, that their interpretation is the ONLY valid one, even when it is demonstrably wrong!Fans are not a hivemind. Some may think that some don't.
He saw that Snoke had already poisoned Ben against him
He saw that Snoke had already poisoned Ben against him and that Ben would destroy everything and kill everyone he loved and in a moment of weakness he considered killing him to prevent that, but he immediately changed his mind and felt ashamed for even considering it.Honestly, I think the directors were trying to make this sound more profound than the fans took it.
He considered killing him briefly, but never actually tried to.
How dare fans of Star Wars not want their childhood hero to be heroic!Thank god Rian Johnson direct the movie and prevented you from getting some lameass fanservice from JJ Abrams.
Nah better he be a complete failure that the galaxy would of been better off if he had never been born.
Thank god Rian Johnson direct the movie and prevented you from getting some lameness fanservice from JJ Abrams.
It sucks that RJ didn't direct the third film, or the entire trilogy
is it ever explained who the fuck Snoke was?
how he managed to get to power?
Yes he did try to killI like how you just came in and made a confidently incorrect statement like this.