Have you ever eaten a frozen Pop-Tart?

Current Events

Current Events » Have you ever eaten a frozen Pop-Tart?
DipDipDiver
10/05/2022
11:35 AM
#1
I recently noticed that the box recommends this as one of the "3 WAYS TO ENJOY!" so I thought what the hell.

It's actually pretty good. I think the box says put it in like 15-30 minutes before eating, but honestly it's best if you go 45-60. The filling becomes almost gummy. I've started eating them as a late night snack
Umbreon
10/05/2022
11:35 AM
#2
Frozen pop tarts are surprising good.
Black Lives Matter. ~ DYL ~ (On mobile)
12-18-19 and 01-13-21: Times Donald Trump has officially been impeached.
Cocytus
10/05/2022
11:36 AM
#3
Frozen? No, sir, I have not.
SrRd_RacinG
10/05/2022
11:38 AM
#4
Unfrosted are my fav
https://media.giphy.com/media/l3vRn3I4UyDoKyWLC/giphy.gif
Bishop_Hastur
10/05/2022
11:40 AM
#5
No. It's just weird. And the box has 4 ways to eat them listed.
Have you seen the Yellow Sign?
Quando omni flunkus moritati
DipDipDiver
10/05/2022
11:40 AM
#6
Bishop_Hastur posted...
No. It's just weird. And the box has 4 ways to eat them listed.
Wait, what was the fourth way
pokedude900
10/05/2022
11:53 AM
#7
The desert-type ones like chocolate fudge, yeah. Never tried any that could conceivably be considered breakfast.
https://i.imgur.com/vuNZ2wj.jpg https://i.imgur.com/xitYdH6.jpg
Come to the (un)official GameFAQs Touhou board. http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/1110-
DipDipDiver
10/05/2022
12:00 PM
#8
I actually prefer the fruit ones for freezing
IronChef_Kirby
10/05/2022
12:01 PM
#9
Yeah, not bad
" Bro Just Let Me Karate Chop You And You Can Have As Many Skateboards As You Want "
GranQroppoop
10/05/2022
12:53 PM
#10
I noticed that on the box earlier this year or last year and couldn't believe I didn't try it before. I always put Hostess/Little Debbie stuff in the freezer. Only done it with the chocolate fudge so far but I prefer it in the freezer now.
Any last one-liners before I go ape on you? - Hoss Delgado
Mmm, toast some marshmallows for me too Mailman.- Chris Paul
K181
10/05/2022
12:54 PM
#11
I've tried it once.

Inferior to both toasted and room temperature.
Irregardless, for all intensive purposes, I could care less.
ArchNemo
10/05/2022
12:55 PM
#12
K181 posted...
I've tried it once.

Inferior to both toasted and room temperature.

Better than room temp worse than toasted imo
Down with the Signess.
NoxObscuras
10/05/2022
12:56 PM
#13
Yes. There are 2 flavors that I buy specifically to freeze and eat: Ice Cream Sundae & Hot Fudge Sundae. Those taste great frozen.
PSN - NoxObscuras
Z490 | i9-10900K | EVGA 3080 FTW3 Ultra | 32GB DDR4 3600 | 4TB SSD
DipDipDiver
10/05/2022
01:47 PM
#14
NoxObscuras posted...
Yes. There are 2 flavors that I buy specifically to freeze and eat: Ice Cream Sundae & Hot Fudge Sundae. Those taste great frozen.
I didn't even know those existed
GallisOTK
10/05/2022
01:48 PM
#15
Tried it once, never again
https://i.imgur.com/nN7dH18.jpg
Master_Bass
10/05/2022
01:48 PM
#16
No, I'm not sure why you'd ever want to eat one frozen.
Many Bothans died to bring you this post.
DipDipDiver
10/05/2022
01:55 PM
#17
Master_Bass posted...
No, I'm not sure why you'd ever want to eat one frozen.
It's pretty good man
DoesntMatter
10/05/2022
01:56 PM
#18
i never have, but i don't think i've ever actually bought any of the varieties that would naturally be well-suited for it. in the rare case that i buy poptarts, i mainly stick to frosted strawberry and brown sugar cinnamon, both of which are too good toasted and buttered to consider doing anything else with them.
It don't matter. None of this matters.
Umbreon
10/05/2022
02:13 PM
#19
DoesntMatter posted...
both of which are too good toasted and buttered to consider doing anything else with them.

Somehow I never considered a buttered poptart.
Black Lives Matter. ~ DYL ~ (On mobile)
12-18-19 and 01-13-21: Times Donald Trump has officially been impeached.
Master_Bass
10/05/2022
02:23 PM
#20
DipDipDiver posted...
It's pretty good man
The next time I have a pop top maybe I'll give it a try.
Many Bothans died to bring you this post.
ForsakenHermit
10/05/2022
02:32 PM
#21
Hot fudge sundae and cookie dough taste great frozen. S'mores not so much.
Beware the fanatic! Too often his cure is deadlier by far than the evil he denounces!-Stan Lee RIP
Make Arcades Great Again!
Alteres
10/05/2022
02:42 PM
#22
Umbreon posted...
Somehow I never considered a buttered poptart.
Ive actually done it on the brown sugar cinnamon since it reminded me of a cinnamon roll, actually pretty damn good if a bit American decadent
........the ghost in the machine...
IGN: Fox, FC: 5344-2646-0982
DipDipDiver
10/05/2022
02:46 PM
#23
My mom used to butter the pop tarts. I still do it once in awhile as a comfort food thing, but tbh it doesn't make a huge difference imo
#24
Post #24 was unavailable or deleted.
DoesntMatter
10/05/2022
02:47 PM
#25
Umbreon posted...
Somehow I never considered a buttered poptart.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlsFgDjyePc
It don't matter. None of this matters.
Prestoff
10/05/2022
02:53 PM
#26
Well I gotta try this one now.
DI MOLTO!
Lordgold666
10/05/2022
03:03 PM
#27
Theyre the bomb. I remember an ice cream sundae pop tart that was made to be consumed frozen
"May the Father of Understanding guide you."
http://error1355.com/ce/Lordgold666.html
DipDipDiver
10/05/2022
03:05 PM
#28
Prestoff posted...
Well I gotta try this one now.
All the kids are doing it
Bishop_Hastur
10/05/2022
08:56 PM
#30
DipDipDiver posted...
Wait, what was the fourth way
The four methods:

Straight from the foil
Toasted
Stacked
Frozen
Have you seen the Yellow Sign?
Quando omni flunkus moritati
Dakimakura
10/05/2022
08:56 PM
#31
I always put them in the freezer for about 10-15 minutes before eating.
This is signature
Not waste of data at all
ultimate_reaver
10/05/2022
08:57 PM
#32
i want to say i did it once but i dont remember how it tasted. maybe i should give it a try again sometime
I pray god will curse the writer, as the writer has cursed the world with this beautiful, stupendous creation, terrible in its simplicity, irresistible in truth
HA4e
10/05/2022
09:00 PM
#33
B-but the frozen germs!
"They don't decide who you are, you do. You are who you choose to be."
Okay, sigless.
DipDipDiver
10/06/2022
09:03 AM
#34
Bishop_Hastur posted...
The four methods:

Straight from the foil
Toasted
Stacked
Frozen
Ooh I just came up with a fifth way:
Toast two Pop-Tarts, and then put a room temp Pop-Tart in between them

Pop-Tart sandwich
MaxEffingBemis
10/06/2022
09:48 AM
#35
What constitutes as frozen? Putting them in the freezing? What about just putting them in the fridge? Because Ive only eaten them cold from the fridge. Is eating frozen from the freezer any different?
She took pity on me, horizontally, but most likely because of my band
DipDipDiver
10/06/2022
11:42 AM
#36
As far as freezing goes, I've found that leaving them in there longer causes the filling to firm up more and I like the texture. It doesn't freeze hard, it just gets chewy/gummy and I imagine the fridge wouldn't get them cold enough to get quite the same texture.

But they probably do get hard if you freeze them too long, idk
Stagmar
10/06/2022
12:10 PM
#37
I've never eaten a pop-tart, so no.
Drawings of me by CE:
https://imgur.com/a/rDSRWz8
MaxEffingBemis
10/06/2022
01:37 PM
#38
DipDipDiver posted...
As far as freezing goes, I've found that leaving them in there longer causes the filling to firm up more and I like the texture. It doesn't freeze hard, it just gets chewy/gummy and I imagine the fridge wouldn't get them cold enough to get quite the same texture.

But they probably do get hard if you freeze them too long, idk
I have some here at home, Ill try putting them in the freezer for a while and see how they taste
She took pity on me, horizontally, but most likely because of my band
DipDipDiver
10/06/2022
02:56 PM
#39
Hey, someone found yet another way to enjoy them!
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/3/9/6/AAeO62AADwFk.jpg
saspa
10/06/2022
03:29 PM
#40
I leave them for days on end in the freezer. I actually love eating them like that especially since it's pretty hot here. The box comes with 4 pouches, so back in the day during my pop tart craze I'd eat each a different way during the week. 1 day it would be frozen, another would be toasted, another would be microwaved and lastly eaten raw straight from the pouch.
http://i.imgur.com/0UFI0T9.jpg
Current Events » Have you ever eaten a frozen Pop-Tart?