Last Post: 7:30:27am, 10/16/2018
I'm guessing people not wanting to include Smash Bros. don't want to count appearances in games outside of their main series. What about Waluigi then? I haven't played a Mario Tennis game, but I have played Mario Party 5.
Cuphead
Chloe Price
Spyro
Neku Sakuraba (I have played Kingdom Hearts 3D)
Yu Narukami
Aya Brea
Primrose
Noctis (But I have FFXV in my backlog)
Monika
Shantae
John Marston
Neptune
Alucard
Godot
Cayde-6
Ness (I have played the 1st and 2nd Smash Bros. though)
Gordon Freeman
Joel
Estelle Bright
Hat Kid
D. Va
Shovel Knight
Captain Toad
Rosalina
Simon Belmont
Sans
Lucina
Shulk
Monokuma
Master Chief
Geno
GlaDOS
Isabelle
Richter Belmont
Captain Falcon (Bought a copy of F-Zero GX and it didn't work)
Draven
Ellie
Quiet
38/152
I've played a bit more than I thought I did.