Picking one from each category:

Wii U physical discs
Hyrule Warriors if you don't intend to get the Definitive Edition for Switch, Arkham Origins otherwise.

Wii U EShop
Dungeons & Dragons: Chronicles of Mystara. It's nostalgic for me - Towers of Doom was a quarter-muncher when I was growing up.

Wii U Virtual Console
Earthbound since it's the only legit way currently of playing it if you don't have the SNES cart or emulate.

Wii physical disc
Metroid Prime 3. I'm due for another playthrough of it myself, while I still wait for Prime 4 news...

WiiWare
Pass on all of these (I don't know how Blaster Master's remake went over, but it's the most interesting of the group to me by name.)

Wii Virtual Console
Paper Mario.

Also,
T0ffee posted...

Xenoblade X

I second this and hate that I haven't gotten much beyond the first area, myself.
---
[Brackets.] - Current obsessions (1/8/19): Dota, The Witness, Shovel Knight, replaying the main series Resident Evils.

Got my Wii U back, what to play?

[none]

[none]

---