Lurker > geno4smash4

Also host, next time can you actually make it clear what we are? My PM should've read "Ridley, NEWCOMER(Mafia) Goon".

GG, survived way longer than I expected lol.

Terra-enforcer posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

I'll also vote Sultan for obvious reasons.
##Vote:Sultan
Pend is like 99% scum at this point but Sultan is 100% scum for me.

You have a counterclaim for a fake doctor and you go for a pure gut read? Come on man. Even if Sultan looked bad, Pend has looked bad for far longer and there's no way in hell we have two docs, roleblocker, and BG. It's no 99%, it's 100%.

I was in the middle of something when Pend fake claimed so I was more impulsive and reactionary than I should have been, but it's pretty clear that like I said, it was an act to bait out the actual doc so they can get a clean shot.

I have no idea which of the 2 is the actual doc, I'm like 90 you 10 Pend but I don't want to risk the game, I want Sultan out because I KNOW he is scum.

I'll also vote Sultan for obvious reasons.
##Vote:Sultan
Pend is like 99% scum at this point but Sultan is 100% scum for me.

Ok didn't have time to catch up with Smash around, did now, I have a suspicion it's indeed 4 scum left guys. Sultan claimed miller to have me mislynched because people will believe him due to him being new. If I get mislynched and they get a night kill they win. F*** me, like f*** and I can't do s*** about it.

Careful, if there's 4 scum alive a mislynch and we lose.

Going to sleep so I'll vote Pend
##Vote:Pendragon

Lolo_Guru posted...

Sultan, didn't you also not claim?

I'm very confident that Ben's scum.
##unvote
The true reason for the "reason we can't be scum together", is that that was his favorite defense, and has been in most circumstances, but not here.

In short, he doesn't and hasn't thought about it because he knows as scum that it is nothing he'd ever be called upon to answer for because he knows I'm town.

His answer for why he wasn't scum buds with FD was already on his tongue the moment I suggested it. He felt it something to defend. He had an answer. He did not with me.

So I think I'm still on the right track here.
##vote: Ben

Wut? Explain why you don't want to vote claimed scum and instead go for Ben.

eaedwards6400 posted...

Deleted post was the host

Rip, game ends?

Forceful_Dragon posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Pend is 100%, Hb is at 60/40.

Hb?

You mean Shonen?

And Pendragon is not 100%. I'd go as far as 95%. Unless scum was literally formatted differently than town, because we know red was vanilla to compare from.

No I mean Hb, like I said my "ability" is not a move Ridley has either, I'm inclined to believe eaed f***ed up and just said Sleep.

Forceful_Dragon posted...

We do not 100% have two scum in hand. This isn't the same as day 3. We have good reason to suspect them both, but complacency will be the death of us.

Pend is 100%, Hb is at 60/40.

Pirate_Harris posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Something about Pirate isn't sitting right with me, like seriously can scum have a cop? Is that considered bastard?

I'm not a bastard... my parents loved me when I was born

This is exactly what I mean, posts like these, posts like "pls ben show me I have half your brain, guys pls give me lists". Like somehow you play dumb and the victim but you are actually not.

Have you realised that mafia is a game that is supposed to be fun, the way I have fun is joke around lots... do you seriously want the paranoid, sad pirate or a happy, energetic pirate?

I mean, when someone says fun they don't necessarily mean making jokes but whatever, if that's what you want to do go ahead but like I said I'm keeping an eye on you, something about this town doesn't seem right and I have to get to the bottom of it.

benjamin3740 posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Something about Pirate isn't sitting right with me, like seriously can scum have a cop? Is that considered bastard?

Pirate was very....very. ....very different than this in his previous scum games. By very I mean VERY. I really do think he's fine

I mean I'll take your word for it but still I'll keep an eye on him.

Pirate_Harris posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Something about Pirate isn't sitting right with me, like seriously can scum have a cop? Is that considered bastard?

I'm not a bastard... my parents loved me when I was born

This is exactly what I mean, posts like these, posts like "pls ben show me I have half your brain, guys pls give me lists". Like somehow you play dumb and the victim but you are actually not.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Oh not geno geno was Ridley hombad though I've been feeling good about hom

Explain because I'm not following.

Something about Pirate isn't sitting right with me, like seriously can scum have a cop? Is that considered bastard?

Alright then let's lynch Pend first and we will see how the HB thing will go next day.

Pirate_Harris posted...

Now im the only one talking... what has this game got against active players?

Well to be fair we did catch another scum for free some some people are just coasting.

So okay, sure let's trust the list the person who's probably mafia sent you, that's smart. Pirate listen, situations change, you can't stick to one list and say lalala I'll only scan someone from the list.

Pirate_Harris posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Still waiting on Geno for an explanation on why my claim makes no sense.

Also Im at school so Ill be less active than during the evening.

Your claim sounds very odd when town is stacked. I have an idea, the idea I wanted to present is this...does anyone want Pirate to scan Hb? I was thinking about it all day and I'm not sure if it's a good plan or not but wanted to ask what you guys felt about it.

I already have a scan list geno...

Mafia... it's real simple... yum yum come getcha some

Can you post the list again? Sorry I might've missed it when I caught up after waking up.

Hbthebattle posted...

Still waiting on Geno for an explanation on why my claim makes no sense.

Also Im at school so Ill be less active than during the evening.

Your claim sounds very odd when town is stacked. I have an idea, the idea I wanted to present is this...does anyone want Pirate to scan Hb? I was thinking about it all day and I'm not sure if it's a good plan or not but wanted to ask what you guys felt about it.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

In real life I'm in alot of pain.. I may or may not need to be replaced but I can claim and try as I can but will be alot less active then usual

I hope you get better man, if you want to be replaced then do so and don't claim.

The more time passes the more fake I think Hb's claim is.

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Neither of those are how redirects normally work. It's topically:

.

Cop - "I use my scan on A"

Host - "B is town"

.

With no explanation as to why your result was for someone else.

No way, that's broken, he just says town or not town.

Even as a joke, what the f is that Harris? You are wasting our time for no reason.

I feel like Han is a mistake, we gain more info by lynching Scare.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Wait what? In what world could this be town town?? Scare might be one to lie, but he'd be an idiot to push it this far into the day. I don't think it could possibly be a facade on either side at this point; one of you is scum.

The idea that you seemingly almost want to just go halfway has me taken aback somewhat.

The idea of him being Town relies on the bolded part, yes.

geno4smash4 posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I have a feeling Geno is going to remember his role as "Survivor".

I doubt, I remembered that switching alliances is pretty bastard so since I was told I'm town I will still be town after N2 ends.

That makes sense.

What if your role is Miller and you just haven't been told yet because eaed doesn't like our D1-Miller-Claim meta?

That would make a lot of sense, fits the flavor and is a role that is inconsequential.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I have a feeling Geno is going to remember his role as "Survivor".

I doubt, I remembered that switching alliances is pretty bastard so since I was told I'm town I will still be town after N2 ends.

Harris why do you believe that somehow reasons to lynch someone is tied to one person and no other can use it?

Pirate_Harris posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Can we lynch Scare already?

What is your reasoning for lynching scare geno?

I didn't like his lie originally, I don't care if he's scare or not scare or if he does this usually, I want him out.

Ok then tell me why you personally want to lynch him, that's my argument on why I wanted scare to lynched geno...

I don't care what your argument was, I've been saying this since yesterday.

Pirate_Harris posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

Can we lynch Scare already?

What is your reasoning for lynching scare geno?

I didn't like his lie originally, I don't care if he's scare or not scare or if he does this usually, I want him out.

Can we lynch Scare already?

benjamin3740 posted...

Geno did your role not even have a win condition?

It did. Although like I said I did ask eaed to make sure I wasn't some weird 3rd party.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Geno, you said you win with Town. You're going back on that?

I do win with town, that's why I'm saying switch.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I won't give any spoilers away, ben.

Anyway, I'm going to wait for Scare to respond, but I'm pretty positive this is a Scumplay where they are making an assumption that is wrong.

geno4smash4 posted...

Han I assume my role is inconsequential so it's not a trouble to balance it around other roles.

Do you promise you're not the version of a drunk who forces players to target a player of their choice?

I can't promise anything, my role says drunk, when N2 ends I might switch to scum, I might become 3rd party, anything might happen, I have never seen this role so I'm not sure what to expect.

Han I assume my role is inconsequential so it's not a trouble to balance it around other roles.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Ok, so now you should understand why I am asking for clarification. I thought one of those two was correct, but clearly I am wrong.

Ridley, newcomer veteran drunk.

Thank you Geno. And your role says you will remember what you are at the start of night 2? Or the end?

benjamin3740 posted...

Doopliss_Power posted...

At least we now know Han is Town for sure for sure.

Han, as our first 100% truly certified live Town, what do you think about the state of the game?

We've had a few already. Why Han for you though?

It should be obv at this point. Town Ben would have said so. ;P

End, I won't be able to use my role on Night 2.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Ok, so now you should understand why I am asking for clarification. I thought one of those two was correct, but clearly I am wrong.

Ridley, newcomer veteran drunk.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

What will you gain by me doing that Han? What's your plan here? Trying to bait me to say town or something? Because that's what I think this is.

Dude, your claim was unclear. I'm just trying to get it in the most clear words because you said a lot without being specific enough.

And I have asked you to repeat something that you basically already said. Why are you being so reluctant? You are whining and throwing a fit, and I'm just asking a really simple question.

Here, I'll help you out. Tell me if A or B is correct.

A. You are Ridley, veteran drunk.
B. You are Ridley, veteran _________ (drunk)

None.