Lurker > Sephiran1

Great! I expected and hoped the Shadow Temple would win this, as it's obviously a great dungeon (maybe even the best out of them all, in my opinion).

For the people interested, here's the ranking:
1. Shadow Temple (Original, challenging (especially its boss) and just plain fun to play through; a good winner)
2. Fire Temple (Disappointingly it got this far)
3. Gerudo's Training Ground (Pretty great mini-dungeon, but 3rd place? That's pushing it, in my opinion)
4. Ganon's Castle (Pretty fun dungeon, but very short, so why this ended up so high is beyond me)
5. Dodongo's Cavern (I never understand why people think this is a great dungeon...)
6. Ice Cavern (One of my favourite dungeons, so no complaining here)
7. Forest Temple (Along with the Shadow Temple and Water Temple my favourite dungeon, so I wish it'd ended up higher, but still not bad)
8. Spirit Temple (A lot of people hated/didn't like this Temple I guess; it's very easy, which isn't a good thing, but it's still a good dungeon)
9. The Great Deku Tree (I like this dungeon the least out of all dungeons in the whole game, so I think it ended up way too high)
10. Bottom of the Well (A bit annoying until you get the Lens of Truth, but a pretty fun dungeon, so no complaints here)
11. Water Temple (I'd imagine people who downvoted this only played the original OoT, because OoT 3DS's Water Temple is a real improvement)
12. Jabu-Jabu's Belly (Overall I understand why this dungeon was gone so fast, as it's a bit tedious and annoying, although I liked the boss of this dungeon a lot)

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Fire Temple - 1
Shadow Temple - 14
Gerudo's Training Ground - 2

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

Fire Temple - 2
Shadow Temple - 14
Gerudo's Training Ground - 4
Ganon's Castle - 1

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Fire Temple - 3
Shadow Temple - 12
Gerudo's Training Ground - 6
Ganon's Castle - 8

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Fire Temple - 3
Shadow Temple - 10
Gerudo's Training Ground - 10
Ganon's Castle - 13

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

You gotta be kidding me... Shadow Temple is almost done for and the Fire Temple still around?

Fire Temple - 2
Shadow Temple - 10
Gerudo's Training Ground - 16
Ganon's Castle - 20

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Fire Temple - 9
Shadow Temple - 32
Gerudo's Training Ground - 23
Ganon's Castle - 24

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 6
Fire Temple - 14
Shadow Temple - 25
Gerudo's Training Ground - 27
Ganon's Castle - 27

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Shadow Temple has to win this!

Dodongo's Cavern - 9
Fire Temple - 14
Ice Cavern - 1
Shadow Temple - 23
Gerudo's Training Ground - 27
Ganon's Castle - 27

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 11
Fire Temple - 14
Ice Cavern - 3
Shadow Temple - 21
Gerudo's Training Ground - 27
Ganon's Castle - 27

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 12
Fire Temple - 14
Ice Cavern - 7
Shadow Temple - 20
Gerudo's Training Ground - 26
Ganon's Castle - 27

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

industrializeit posted...
Yeah what happened was, it all just turned into spite. Spirit people were mostly just attacking Forest, and vice versa. I tried calling a "truce" by attacking the obviously inferior dungeons instead of Spirit when they were both around the same HP a couple times, but the Spirit people didn't stop attacking Forest. Ahh well, maybe if I would have said something Forest and Spirit could have teamed up and took out the freakin Gerudo's Training Ground, Ice Cavern, and Ganon's Castle before we destroyed each other. lol

I basically like all Temples a lot except for the Fire Temple, and I do think they're all superior to the (mini-)dungeons, although I liked the Ice Cavern and Gerudo's Training Ground more than the others. And I still don't understand why people like Dodongo's Cavern that much, as it's not really anything special in my opinion, compared to other (mini-)dungeons.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 14
Fire Temple - 13
Ice Cavern - 9
Shadow Temple - 19
Gerudo's Training Ground - 26
Ganon's Castle - 27

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

All of my favourites are gone except for the Shadow Temple... didn't see that coming when I started this topic to be honest, as I would've expected the Temples to crush the (mini-)dungeons.

Dodongo's Cavern - 14
Fire Temple - 14
Ice Cavern - 10
Shadow Temple - 24
Gerudo's Training Ground - 24
Ganon's Castle - 27

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

^ I have to agree... I mean, how is Ganon's Castle a better dungeon than the Spirit Temple? To each his own I guess.

Dodongo's Cavern - 17
Forest Temple - 14
Fire Temple - 14
Ice Cavern - 17
Shadow Temple - 24
Gerudo's Training Ground - 28
Spirit Temple - 22
Ganon's Castle - 27

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 19
Forest Temple - 18
Fire Temple - 15
Ice Cavern - 17
Shadow Temple - 25
Gerudo's Training Ground - 29
Spirit Temple - 20
Ganon's Castle - 29

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Wow, I'm gone for 3 days and this is still going on? Too bad the Water Temple didn't make it... at least the Fire Temple is going down as well!

Dodongo's Cavern - 19
Forest Temple - 24
Fire Temple - 17
Ice Cavern - 17
Shadow Temple - 27
Gerudo's Training Ground - 29
Spirit Temple - 15
Ganon's Castle - 29

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 6
Dodongo's Cavern - 27
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 15
Forest Temple - 40
Fire Temple - 25
Ice Cavern - 26
Water Temple - 25
Bottom of the Well - 22
Shadow Temple - 29
Gerudo's Training Ground - 29
Spirit Temple - 30
Ganon's Castle - 29

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 13
Dodongo's Cavern - 24
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 20
Forest Temple - 31
Fire Temple - 28
Ice Cavern - 28
Water Temple - 30
Bottom of the Well - 23
Shadow Temple - 30
Gerudo's Training Ground - 30
Spirit Temple - 39
Ganon's Castle - 30

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 16
Dodongo's Cavern - 24
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 24
Forest Temple - 32
Fire Temple - 29
Ice Cavern - 27
Water Temple - 30
Bottom of the Well - 23
Shadow Temple - 29
Gerudo's Training Ground - 30
Spirit Temple - 39
Ganon's Castle - 30

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 18
Dodongo's Cavern - 24
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 26
Forest Temple - 32
Fire Temple - 30
Ice Cavern - 27
Water Temple - 31
Bottom of the Well - 23
Shadow Temple - 31
Gerudo's Training Ground -29
Spirit Temple - 37
Ganon's Castle - 30

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 19
Dodongo's Cavern - 25
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 26
Forest Temple - 32
Fire Temple - 30
Ice Cavern - 27
Water Temple - 32
Bottom of the Well - 25
Shadow Temple - 31
Gerudo's Training Ground -28
Spirit Temple - 36
Ganon's Castle - 30

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 26
Dodongo's Cavern - 25
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 28
Forest Temple - 31
Fire Temple - 30
Ice Cavern - 29
Water Temple - 29
Bottom of the Well - 29
Shadow Temple - 30
Gerudo's Training Ground -30
Spirit Temple - 33
Ganon's Castle - 30

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 28
Dodongo's Cavern - 27
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 28
Forest Temple - 31
Fire Temple - 30
Ice Cavern - 29
Water Temple - 28
Bottom of the Well - 31
Shadow Temple - 30
Gerudo's Training Ground -30
Spirit Temple - 31
Ganon's Castle - 30

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Let's see what the most popular Dungeon/Temple in this game is. In my first topic about just the (mini-)dungeons Dodongo's Cavern won, and the ranking was like this:

1. Dodongo's Cavern
2. Gerudo's Training Ground
3. Ice Cavern
4. Bottom of the Well
5. Ganon's Castle
6. The Great Deku Tree
7. Jabu-Jabu's Belly

In my second topic about just the 5 Temples, the Forest Temple won, and the ranking was like this:

1. Forest Temple
2. Spirit Temple
3. Shadow Temple
4. Fire Temple
5. Water Temple

This topic will be the final one including all of the (mini-)dungeons in the game with triple points!

Rules: two hurts and one heal per post per HOUR. These rules apply because this way it'll end eventually instead of going on for a long time without even ending due to the lack of interest of the people on this board.

Let's begin! I'm double hurting the Dodongo's Cavern (the winner of the first topic) and healing the Water Temple (the loser of the second topic).

The Great Deku Tree - 30
Dodongo's Cavern - 28
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 30
Forest Temple - 30
Fire Temple - 30
Ice Cavern - 30
Water Temple - 31
Bottom of the Well - 30
Shadow Temple - 30
Gerudo's Training Ground - 30
Spirit Temple - 30
Ganon's Castle - 30

Copy and paste the above list in your message instead of just typing what you're going to hurt and heal.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Well, I didn't expect it to end this fast. Anyway, the Forest Temple is a great Temple... at least the Fire Temple didn't win (of which I'm glad). Seeing as this topic was pretty popular, I will make a last one with all of the dungeons in the game.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

I just screwed myself over with my own rules regarding the Water Temple. Oh well, I can at least try and bring the Fire Temple down.

Forest Temple - 12
Fire Temple - 6
Water Temple - 8
Shadow Temple - 6
Spirit Temple - 10

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

^ Fair enough, to each his own. I personally love the mechanic of the changing water level; it makes the dungeon far more challenging, since you actually have to think a bit to play through it.

And I'm talking about that key you can get after you've changed the water level the second time (in the center room of the dungeon); there's a new cutscene that shows the path to this key just after you change the water level.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Actually, the Water Temple is different enough in OoT 3D, but I just realised this isn't the OoT 3D board, so it's not really fair to exclude people who didn't play OoT 3D (yet). Still, the hate for the Water Temple isn't really fair because they made an extra cutscene for that one elusive small key, as well as the Iron Boots being very easy to (un)equip. And of course, the locations for changing the water level are now shown. Because of these reasons (mainly the Iron Boots one though) I think the Water Temple is hands down the best, most enjoyable and challenging Temple (and thus dungeon) in the game.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

Let's see what the most popular Temple in this game is. This should be a bit more interesting than the (mini-)dungeons in my previous topic, in which Dodongo's Cavern won.

Rules: two hurts and one heal per post per HOUR. These rules apply because this way it'll end eventually instead of going on for a long time without even ending due to the lack of interest of the people on this board.

Let's begin! I'm double hurting the Fire Temple (as it's just the only annoying Temple in my opinion; the others are all great) and healing the Water Temple (as it was just a ton of fun playing through it, surprisingly enough).

Forest Temple - 10
Fire Temple - 8
Water Temple - 11
Shadow Temple - 10
Spirit Temple - 10

Copy and paste the above list in your message instead of just typing what you're going to hurt and heal.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

^^^ Hah, you (and others) really wanted Dodongo's Cavern to win, didn't you? Anyway, my first topic (on the Zelda: OoT 3D board) was going in the same direction, as Dodongo's Cavern was about to win as well. I guess that settles it then.

I'm going to make a similar topic with the 5 temples... and maybe afterwards a topic with all dungeons in the game, if that's interesting enough.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

No, we can't just end it now, when we're so close. Both dungeons now have an equal chance of winning (and losing). After this I'll do the 5 Temples, so hurry up.

Dodongo's Cavern - 4
Gerudo's Training Ground - 4

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 7
Ice Cavern - 8
Bottom of the Well - 5
Gerudo's Training Ground - 6

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 11
Ice Cavern - 14
Bottom of the Well - 10
Gerudo's Training Ground - 8
Ganon's Castle - 1

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Dodongo's Cavern - 10
Ice Cavern - 13
Bottom of the Well - 10
Gerudo's Training Ground - 10
Ganon's Castle - 5

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 2
Dodongo's Cavern - 10
Ice Cavern - 13
Bottom of the Well - 9
Gerudo's Training Ground - 10
Ganon's Castle - 5

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Jabu-Jabu's Belly is gone.

The Great Deku Tree - 4
Dodongo's Cavern - 10
Ice Cavern - 10
Bottom of the Well - 12
Gerudo's Training Ground - 11
Ganon's Castle - 5

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 4
Dodongo's Cavern - 9
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 6
Ice Cavern - 9
Bottom of the Well - 12
Gerudo's Training Ground - 11
Ganon's Castle - 6

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

X_Dante_X posted...
Gotta double hurt the Ice Cavern, I'm not sure that dungeon actually exists

I wouldn't make it up, you know. If you don't believe me:
http://zelda.wikia.com/wiki/Ice_Cavern

It's a mini-dungeon, but that's still a dungeon. You get the Iron Boots before going to the Water Temple as a reward.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 5
Dodongo's Cavern - 9
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 10
Ice Cavern - 8
Bottom of the Well - 11
Gerudo's Training Ground - 11
Ganon's Castle - 9

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Skies of Arcadia (Tanooki Blitzball Conference)
Mario Kart 64 (Twilight Barrel Galaxy Conference)
Jet Force Gemini (Smash Trigger Conference)
-
Super Mario Sunshine (Thousand-Year World of Sunshine Conference)
-
-
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance (Cult RPG Galaxy Conference)
-
#4 Super Mario 64 (Nintendo Objections Conference)
-
#5 Super Mario Bros. 3 (Tanooki Blitzball Conference)
-
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker (Zelda Overload Conference)

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

The Great Deku Tree - 7
Dodongo's Cavern - 11
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 10
Ice Cavern - 7
Bottom of the Well - 11
Gerudo's Training Ground - 10
Ganon's Castle - 9

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

I made this exact topic on the Zelda: OoT 3D board, but it got deleted for being off-topic, which is ridiculous to say the least if you ask me.

Anyway, let's see what the most popular dungeon in this game is. I didn't include the Temples because I believe the dungeons won't stand a chance if that would be the case. After this topic, I'll do a similar topic with just the 5 Temples.

Rules: two hurts and one heal per post per HOUR. These rules apply because this way it'll end eventually instead of going on for a long time without even ending due to the lack of interest of the people on this board.

Let's begin! I'm double hurting The Great Deku Tree and healing Gerudo's Training Ground.

The Great Deku Tree - 8
Dodongo's Cavern - 10
Jabu-Jabu's Belly - 10
Ice Cavern - 10
Bottom of the Well - 10
Gerudo's Training Ground - 11
Ganon's Castle - 10

Copy and paste the above list in your message instead of just typing what you're going to hurt and heal.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Skies of Arcadia obviously.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Yes.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Jeff Zero posted...
The waggle controls did kinda suck.

How so? For me, they worked perfectly IIRC (though a person's memory isn't the most reliable thing, I'll admit that much).

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

I own the game on Wii, but played it at a friend on the GC once, and I think Wii's controls are a lot better for sure. The GC controller just feels limited compared to the Wii remote + nunchuck.

LinkMarioSamus posted...
Best Zelda game aside from A Link to the Past and The Wind Waker.

You forgot OoT there, buddy.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez

Fire Emblem.

--
"Where there is light... there is Darkness!" - Ramirez