Lurker > Lolo_Guru

I have one thought about there being no roleblock.

Basically, there wasn't a recorded roleblock day 1 either. And given Death being a roleblocker, and roleblocked Pendragon day 1 (as he stated), I can see him doing the same night 2.

Far from conclusive, but I can certainly see Death blocking Pendragon again given his role.
---

Lolo

Pirate_Harris posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

I scanned doop last night...

He's town

Why did you choose him? Or suspect him?

He was the weakest read I had and han said he was likely to be scum that could sneak as town

Doop was seriously trying to get people to vote for Scare when it was tied up. Is that actually something scum would do in this tight, mission critical lynch (6/6, you, hombad, and sultan the only ones not yet voted)?

If I look back on your vote and see that you voted Han... because you couldn't fathom his choice of not bodyguarding, so help me.

Well it was a toss up between you and doop... so count yourself lucky

Why would that bug me? I'm town.

So then why would han compile a case study on a town? He could've been scum oh wait he wasn't

Town, any town. Even Sir Chris himself, has imperfect information. If you make an incorrect conclusion about someone, and you further use that to deduce and distill your thoughts further, you come up with further incorrect thoughts down the line (such as Death on Han's list... and me, but you'll see that later).
---

Lolo

Pirate_Harris posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

I scanned doop last night...

He's town

Why did you choose him? Or suspect him?

He was the weakest read I had and han said he was likely to be scum that could sneak as town

Doop was seriously trying to get people to vote for Scare when it was tied up. Is that actually something scum would do in this tight, mission critical lynch (6/6, you, hombad, and sultan the only ones not yet voted)?

If I look back on your vote and see that you voted Han... because you couldn't fathom his choice of not bodyguarding, so help me.

Well it was a toss up between you and doop... so count yourself lucky

Why would that bug me? I'm town.
---

Lolo

Pirate_Harris posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

I scanned doop last night...

He's town

Why did you choose him? Or suspect him?

He was the weakest read I had and han said he was likely to be scum that could sneak as town

Doop was seriously trying to get people to vote for Scare when it was tied up. Is that actually something scum would do in this tight, mission critical lynch (6/6, you, hombad, and sultan the only ones not yet voted)?

If I look back on your vote and see that you voted Han... because you couldn't fathom his choice of not bodyguarding, so help me.
---

Lolo

Pirate_Harris posted...

I scanned doop last night...

He's town

Why did you choose him? Or suspect him?
---

Lolo

Heavily suspect you right back, FD. ;)
But even more than that, Sultan.
I'm sure I'll have the time this game day to compile my whole case there; you know, so it'll be useful after my flip.

Pendragon71037 posted...

First off, sorry Han. I really thought Scare was the one telling the truth.

How much did the fact that Han came out swinging at you in the first place play into this?
---

Lolo

ScareChan posted...

Also han is now literally arguing scum bomb

Or at very least planting the seeds for fear

Like come on dude you're better than this

wut
---

Lolo

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Has your mind changed on Han, Sultan?

I'm thinking all of this though because going back and reading the original stuff is making me think about it more.

Though I still think the best course of action is lynching someone else...

I'll humor you top 3 scum reads?

I know I'm 1of yours unless that changed who are the other 2 reads you got?

Don't really have much more than you that felt tied directly to red d1.
Knowing whether it's Han/red or Scare/red is what matters to me now. My vote is either moving, once, to Scare, or staying on Han the rest of the day.
---

Lolo

Has your mind changed on Han, Sultan?
---

Lolo

HanOfTheNekos posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Han its basically impossible for both of you not to be scum

If you are town, Scare is scum.
If you are scum, Scare is town (probably).

I can think of some possibilities.

Framer. Character who disguises themselves as another player. Possessor.

Another possibility is that this is a bluff and Scare is just gambling on me being Scum. Which doesnt really make sense that hed pick me, but picking Death first was a gamble in the same way.

This is the most likely scenario in which Scare is Town - he backed off Death who claimed info, but is not backing off me because I didnt.

lol

##Unvote
##Vote: Han
---

Lolo

Why are you throwing out possible theories for town Scare, Han?
---

Lolo

ScareChan posted...

I didnt vote red because lack of vitals, I wanted to know where things were with newer players around and potential accidental quick lynch

Why did you claim as early as you did?
---

Lolo

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Lolo, people have pointed out plenty of things against you, time and time again.

Here's a question - did you take advantage of my last minute train on Chris to hop off of Scare, your Scumbuddy, to avoid him being close to Jedi in vote total?

I'm town.

Chris's actions there made no sense. Nor sending me away to look for scare aligned pairs, then not going through with it. Yes, I was feeling better on Scare based on my reread and the activity he was providing there. Knew you distrusted me anyway, but did not feel like starting that lynch was something you'd do as Scum.
---

Lolo

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Lolo at this point is probably definitely Scum because he has been so reluctant to respond to peoples arguments on him. Ignoring suspicion is pretty Scummy.

What arguments?

There has been nothing but sideeye all day.
---

Lolo

htaeD posted...

Interestingly, red whined that han listened too Scare too much.

htaeD posted...

Then suddenly red pulls this out

Also someone else can ctrl-f the topics because I'm feeling lazy right now, but has Scare actually posted at all this game?

Now I dont know about you, but I dont know why scumred would complain about having to look up Scare posts if Scare is scum too..
Though yes this is hardly solid evidence.

Except as mentioned above, he knows that Scare had posted something.
... So why does this hint Scare/town instead of Scare/Scum to you?
---

Lolo

Good evening death.

Han or Scare as scum?
---

Lolo

Shonen_Bat posted...

Hm, okay.

Your vote on Chris late day 1 raised some eyebrows and I don't think I've seen you weigh in on that? What's the story there?

Thought Chris's Jedi train was off and didn't make sense, definitely didn't think chris sending me off to look for scare aligned pairs and then not going through with the lynch he'd guaranteed made sense at all. Was not feeling nearly as bad about Scare at the time given I'd just gotten back from looking at him. Knew my vote would absolutely make some waves, as Han was already quite vocal in his distrust of me, and because it's Chris (who absolutely crucifies), but... couldn't help myself from doing so.
---

Lolo

Shonen_Bat posted...

Maybe it's just my inexperience talking but I've been following all of day 2 so far and have no read on Han/Scare. They've both made strange claims and acted out in ways that I don't understand right now.

As for not asking questions, that's good ol' social anxiety speaking. Or not speaking, I guess. I haven't specifically asked you anything because it seemed like you weren't here.

I guess that's a good place to start. Why did you toss a vote on Sultan and then bounce for half of the day?

Voting Sultan is pretty clear with Red being confirmed scum:

Red garnered my vote in the first place due to Sultan's behavior towards him when the train on red started. It made them look aligned to each other in the first place. I saw Sultan's kneejerk "whoa why are you guys voting for red" in response to yours and ben's votes, grilled him on his actual opinion on red (none), and voted red, moreso on sultan's strange actions there than red's in the first place.

I've been dealing with the aftermath from my nose surgery Monday most of today. But anyway, another thing to keep in mind is that if you want to ask something, just ASK IT. They don't have to be there that second. I mean, they'll either see it on the catch-up reading, or you can ask it again later.
---

Lolo

Shonen_Bat posted...

I was getting more suspicious of Chris as the day went on, mainly due to him stifling discussion and avoiding most questions sent his way, but I'd say the Scare -> Jedi lynch switch was what sold it for me.

Ok, possible.

If I'm your main suspect now; I have a very simple question.
Why aren't you grilling me about the same stuff?

You see, the easiest way to get a direct answer out of anyone is to ask questions. Direct questions. Of them. If they deflect, you push forward.

Han/Scare is what matters today, sure. But when it gets to be day 3/4, you, and every single other newbie remaining absolutely has to be proactive on their own. Whether that's pushing my lynch or anyone's.

And on Han/Scare... yes, it's a tough call. But one we all need to make. You included, Shouen.
I am leaning towards Han being scum over Scare, at least right now.
---

Lolo

Shonen_Bat posted...

I was hoping to find out why Chris was acting so erratic yesterday, starting and dropping lynch trains and seemingly changing his views on a whim.

Red was my biggest scum read day 1.

Guess which two players died night 1.

Ok. Chris's behavior being the reason you hopped from Red to Chris yourself near the end of day?
What brought you to that decision?
---

Lolo

Shonen_Bat posted...

Well, there goes literally everything I was going to do today.

sets up tent

Your first post of day 2 (that one three above being your third). So what were you going to do going into day 2, and why was it shot, Shonen?
---

Lolo

Han, why did you claim vanilla in the first place, in the first post of the first topic?
---

Lolo

##Vote: Sultan

Why? His defense-not-defense of red on that train. It reeked of an aligned pair then and it still does now.
---

Lolo

hombad46 posted...

I decide to look in here for the end of the day since Im between games and what the hell is happening?

the usual end of day chaos

welcome to board 8
---

Lolo

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

Han's points on Chris make sense to me.

Jedi seems like a damn random endlynch for him.

##unvote
##vote: Chris

God, you just had to be the one person to do the one thing to make me second guess myself.

damn straight
---

Lolo

benjamin3740 posted...

Han is being rather alarming. A little too late in the day ...and Chris of all people. It's hard to accept you're serious

Mafia. SERIOUS BUSINESS
---

Lolo

Han's points on Chris make sense to me.

Jedi seems like a damn random endlynch for him.

##unvote
##vote: Chris
---

Lolo

go to next topic terra
Hbthebattle posted...

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77245647

Time to move

---

Lolo