| Board List | |
|---|---|
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 3: Does anyone Remember that Godzilla Cartoon? |
| masterplum 07/25/19 5:24:38 PM #42 | If I die tonight I think Chris is scum. Especially if popcorn is scum. I think popcorn splinters there in an attempt at a bus vote --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 4:25:01 PM #423 | fire_bolt posted... I'm still not convinced HB is scum and worry we're mislynching him because he's not really playing the game rather than because he's dirty. I mean, if he flips scum I'll eat crow for all the shit I've been giving Chris and be glad to do it, but if he flips town then all we've done is waste D1 going down a railroad I've been trying to slow down. Nobody even really seems to want to LOOK at a different lynch, or to try and get much out of anybody. HB's already dead it feels like and we're just going thru the motions Multiple people came up independently with several good reasons to lynch him. Do you want an angel to descend from the heavens and point to him? --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 4:17:48 PM #415 | I usually dont feel this good about a D1 lynch Which probably means HB is town. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 4:15:57 PM #414 | fire_bolt posted... So the HB wagon is two away from hammering now. That makes me uncomfortable :/ Why --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 4:07:16 PM #407 | IfGodCouldDie posted... How does it need to be formatted? Missed a space --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 3:21:38 PM #369 | UltimaterializerX posted... You think Scum Popcorn makes that vote? If Chris is scum he does. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 2:27:32 PM #352 | I think HB knows he is dead --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 1:25:55 PM #329 | Hey guys. Friendly reminder if Chris lives to end game that he is almost sure scum. Im questioning if this rage is influenced by knowing HB is scum Also bussing teammates and looking good doing it is one of his plays --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 1:21:57 PM #324 | DoomTheGyarados posted... masterplum posted...Chris, for someone who is using terms such as scum equity, Im surprised you are taking offense to this train which has such little chance of taking off. How do you know the third player isnt doing the exact same thing you do sometimes where you get on a train with no intention of ever following through to see what happens. I would probably do exactly that if I trusted myself to be around enough to carefully manage that ploy --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 1:19:17 PM #319 | My Chris-Monoxide alarm is chriping Not sure if real warning or low battery --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 1:18:32 PM #317 | Chris, for someone who is using terms such as scum equity, Im surprised you are taking offense to this train which has such little chance of taking off. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 1:13:24 PM #311 | |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 1:09:48 PM #304 | fire_bolt posted... DoomTheGyarados posted...even you fire_bolt see Hb is likely to be scum at this point. Eh? --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 1:06:12 PM #297 | Wow what a friendly guy --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 12:54:57 PM #291 | If HB is town Im immediately voting Corrik tomorrow for knowing too much --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 12:44:32 PM #281 | Bolt prob town if Hb is scum --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 12:29:05 PM #276 | Corrik7 posted... Leanansidhe posted...Scum Corrik got mad at me for bussing once, that's a tidbit to keep under the ol' hat depending on HB's flip. Although if he were actually trying to save HB he's doing an extremely lackluster job Being right doesnt make the vote good. Even if Blade is scum a splinter on to him isnt pragmatic. You arent getting the support --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 11:35:50 AM #251 | DoomTheGyarados posted... How bad must it feel to be caught by Chris so early. I bet on the scum board he is like "It was BS! It was BS!" Should I go with 30% chance or its easy to be right when you are scum for my witty retort --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 11:18:39 AM #246 | |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 10:57:40 AM #243 | DoomTheGyarados posted... Plum did you mistake that for a defense of HB? Nah, Im just still thinking about it. I was rereading back trying to see if I was reading to much into it. Leans comments just kind of sparked the thought I was having --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 10:52:58 AM #239 | Leanansidhe posted... The way I read HB is that he does not have these thoughts until he is asked about them. My question to that is.... how? I dont really see how HB seriously considers the possibility of Ulti lying but hasnt considered the possibility of him being scum at that point. At the bare minimum they are so tightly coupled that you would have an opinion on it at that point. What if Ulti is lying? What would that mean? Under no circumstance can I see town going through the thought process of considering a lying Ulti vs a truth telling Ulti and not have an opinion on whether a lying Ulti means he is scum. I mean that is literally the point of the game. How do you gloss over that as town? --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 10:39:53 AM #236 | Yep. It really felt completely wrong axis. Like he was trying to convince that Ulti wouldnt be making this play if he wasnt Mayor. Its like he was debating lying Town vs truthful town and you threw him a curveball that he totally whiffed at. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 8:40:35 AM #221 | .... sultan Occulams razor here --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/25/19 5:59:48 AM #219 | Hbthebattle posted... Lopen posted...Hbthebattle posted...Unless Ulti was lying, I'm safe either way, and Ulti lying would be immediately followed by him being lynched Day 2. Oh ##unvote ##Vote: Hb This feels like a pretty clear perspective slip. HB is saying Ulti will be lynched if he is a liar, to Thinking (Notice the hmm) and saying he is more likely to be scum. I have a hard time expressing my rationale sometimes, so perhaps Ill give an example of what I would expect a town Hb to say. Town Hb: If Ulti is lying he will be lynched. Would a lying Ulti be scum? Of course. Town Ulti would not lie about this. This is why we would lynch him Scum Hb knows Ulti is town so the question is whether town Ulti is lying about his role. Under this perspective Hbs posts make a lot of sense. He first hypothesizes Ulti would not follow through with a bluff because he would end up suiciding as town, then he has to fabricate thinking about if this would be a scum or town action by the way if Hb is scum Ulti is almost assured town here --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 10:32:23 PM #153 | I cant figure out Hb --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 9:03:19 PM #109 | Why are you entertaining the possibility Ulti is telling the truth --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 8:59:22 PM #107 | DoomTheGyarados posted... If Ulti is Mayor he played this very poorly, but that is also in his range. *blinks* Chris wtf --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 8:58:31 PM #106 | Hbthebattle posted... Lopen posted...Hbthebattle posted...That wasn't anger, it was worry that you blatantly lied Huh --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 8:40:08 PM #93 | Corrik7 posted... Chris, Lopen, Blade are scum. And likely IGCD also. You do not know Im town --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 3:25:31 PM #20 | Panthera posted... Not fine enough to outweigh the original post that got your attention though, I take it? Correct --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 2: SKREEEONK! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 3:20:11 PM #18 | Panthera posted... Good afternoon I thought it was fine. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:59:42 PM #442 | masterplum posted... Chris what are you doing --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:52:57 PM #435 | Leanansidhe posted... masterplum posted...Leanansidhe posted...masterplum posted...Leanansidhe posted...Plum, why are you going after Popcorn for that and not me? Yeah, your post has none of the issues. I dont see any added details that look like you completed your thought then added on more just because. Im voting popcorn because it feels like he completed his thought then expounded some more. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:49:44 PM #428 | Chris what are you doing --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:48:58 PM #426 | fire_bolt posted... So if Ulti doesn't mod confirm then we lynch him instead, right? Does gamefaqs support gify yet I need all the face palm gifs --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:47:57 PM #423 | Leanansidhe posted... masterplum posted...Leanansidhe posted...Plum, why are you going after Popcorn for that and not me? I looked back the last few pages and I dont see it. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:46:04 PM #419 | Ulti is one of a few players that I completely ignore their day 1 claims They are complete null tells --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:44:25 PM #414 | Leanansidhe posted... Plum, why are you going after Popcorn for that and not me? I either missed your post or you dont understand why Im going after popcorn. Probably the latter. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:42:07 PM #409 | ##Vote: Popcorn Popcorn_Fairy posted... UltimaterializerX posted...Mafia mayor, and I can absolutely promise you are not getting lynched today. This is the first truly bad post Ive seen. I dont like the over explaining of why he is against a no lynch. I think its pretty easily derived information. I could see scum over explaining in that situation to try to make their conviction better understood. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 1:39:35 PM #407 | Leanansidhe posted... You're right Plum - let's all lynch HB to teach Ulti a lesson Wait no what did I just do --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 12:57:42 PM #398 | Why is anyone believing this ulti claim --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 12:57:14 PM #397 | Lopen posted... Who said he's playing exactly the same? Lopen posted... I didn't vote Ulti cause he's bombastic I voted him cause his play reminds me of last game, but with red playing the part of me. Vote and basis for suspicion on red seem like a reach. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 12:03:59 PM #374 | Also, wasnt a big fan of Lopens post. I would think Lopen would realize the fallacy of comparing to a previous game. If I roll scum twice in a row I would usually make an effort to switch it up at least a little bit. Its a tell I wouldnt never use on mildly competent players --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 12:02:05 PM #373 | .... strongman is banned? --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 12:01:23 PM #372 | Meow1000 posted... masterplum posted...I swear the hardest part of mafiaing again is Ill be going about my day and then randomly Ill realize that I signed up for a game. Yeah, if the game wasnt about to be cancelled due to lack of participation I probably wouldnt have --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 8:41:24 AM #357 | Well, I mean I guess if you are scum you could. But you get my idea --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 8:40:43 AM #356 | Corrik7 posted... Okay in that case. Ulti and fire are town. Lopen is scum. There is zero chance you know ultis alignment. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 6:16:46 AM #352 | I read up. ULTI is bombastic but I think thats just Ulti. Voting him for that would be like voting me for being contrarian. --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 6:11:12 AM #351 | UltimaterializerX posted... Because when he does that he's usually scum. Uh huh. I think this my first game in a year and second in like 3? Interesting take --- |
| Topic | Godzilla Mafia Topic 1: It's Alive! |
| masterplum 07/24/19 5:59:46 AM #350 | I swear the hardest part of mafiaing again is Ill be going about my day and then randomly Ill realize that I signed up for a game. Reading up --- |
| Board List |
