Lurker > Ngamer

I'm glad we have a ticket in, but I think it will go over better if we could give a full list of 8 snubs to run in a complete "extra games" poll.

So... what are the five biggest misses so far, after FF and Jedi and Hogwarts?

Zylothewolf posted...

I havent played it but its a 2D Mario game so its unfair to expect anything more like a 6 or 7 out of
10.

Zylo, you're making less sense every day.

No, noooo, nooooooooooo!

Well, at least we'll always have my Games Yahtzee Actually Liked playlist!

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL_HuLDPlaA4wZv_dqeFzdEqBiKUO2BS2K

Yes, always good for a chuckle.

MegaMan

Yes, he was always fun (in the cartoon).

9.5 for me. Super interesting concept, and the history of the series worked in the episode's favor- we're all waiting with dread for the other shoe to drop but then WHAM, happy ending instead! (Well, depending how you look at it... but happy by this show's standards.)

For yesterday I will say

S3E3 - Shut Up and Dance - 8

The most terrifying episode for me, because the rest of the series says "watch out, this could happen soon!" but this scenario is (I assume) already happening every day. Probably with blackmail crypto payoffs so it never makes headlines.

I think you have to go Morgoth here. Sauron demands absolute control and will go to any lengths to achieve it, but he isn't "pure evil," he's evil-lite.

7, really cool concept but not my favorite execution.

7.7, a solid entry but not super deep.

Also I missed yesterday but would like to give it a

White Christmas - 10

Could have been split into two episodes, and both would have been Hall of Fame-level for me!

3, at the time a huge letdown after the brilliance of the previous episodes and still the only EP I actively dislike.

Also I missed last topic; I'll give a late vote of

White Bear - 8

9.85

One of my favorite episodes of anything ever!

9.25

Excellent episode, but doesn't quite reach my personal Hall of Fame.

9.5

Almost perfect television.

8.5

I was not only here, I was Cyber1166!

Calling it a "flop" is a bit harsh IMO... If you told me there was going to be another Indy film after Crystal Skull and it was going to gross around $180 million domestic while outperforming the new Fast & Furious and the new Pixar and the new Flash and basically tie the new Mission Impossible, I would have been darn impressed!

Yes, total bro.

1/6 was the worse offence, but my money is still on the Documents case being the one that breaks through because even a pre-schooler could follow the logic and realize he doesn't have any wiggle room to have not realized what he was doing was hugely illegal.

Unfortunately it's going to be decided by a Florida jury and is being lead by a judge who will probably delay delay delay, which is why 1/6 still might make the bigger impact pre-election.

Mario

Chrono

Mild yes, he gets the job done.

HECK yes, one of Pixar's best.

Mario

Galaxy

I went with the top option, because I think the site's actually done an admirable job of retaining it's 2008ish era userbase, all things considered. While new features were added it was always a slow rollout, not massive changes to frustrate entrenched users and drive them away.

And I'd argue the site basically looking like it did in 2004 has been a win as well- its always loaded quickly and been something you could pull up at work to do some light browsing without having to worry about pop ups and annoying flashing ads and users directly linking questionable images.

Also...

Yesmar_ posted...

My serious answer though is archiving the message boards in '08, and to an extent the proliferation of stickies on game boards. Both were obviously efficient ideas, but at the same time very anti-social.

I'll agree that being the #1 thing that killed the message boards. BUT, the boards didn't contribute as much to site traffic as the game help, so overall I'll stick with my Bad Wiki Execution vote.

Well considering this website was owned by CBS, who sold it for pennies to... a collection of fandom-specific wikis, it would be pretty hard not to pick the wiki option.

Mario

Mario
Portal

Chrono
Gear

Midna

Should be fun!

Lucas
Midna

Midna
Camacho
Frank

Donna
Lucas

Great winner, cool final (though an epic Ring showdown would have been better), but I don't understand why this board has turned on BotW in the last year.

Liz
V

Midna
J
Camacho
Alfred

Mario

You could seed based on IMDB rating

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2085059/episodes?season=4&ref_=ttep_ep_sn_pv

In which case the 4 byes would go to

White Christmas
Hang the DJ
San Junipero
Black Museum

Followed closely by

Hated in the Nation
The Entire History of You

Ammy
Robert
Dexter
Frank

My interest level would be THROUGH THE ROOF! Need to watch the new EPs before voting, but I'll get on that.

Smash

Demyx
Liz
Beast
V

If seeing the last poll was enough to drive someone insane, I have bad news for you...
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/5/5/3/AAAB8RAAEnDp.png

Mario

Camacho
Frank
Shawn
Alfred

Hiro