JC made a questionable post [T3P63]
Ben was first to quote it and said "cringe"[T3P65]. Blade quoted it shortly after and remarked "is this post actually saying anything"[T3P72]. They might not have cast the very first vote on JC, but this felt like the start of his lynch.
Peaf responds to Blade "will we join forces on jc?"[T3P76]. That by itself doesn't preclude Peaf from being a JC Scummate, self preservation is a strong motivator, but RBer is a pretty key role usually so Peaf would have to be something equally vital in that scenario.
Ulti is the first to react to JC's fake claim and he does it very loudly, as he does most things. I'm not convinced of Ulti's innocence based on this, I would not put it past him to pounce on a scummate for making a misstep (a combination of poor posts and a badly selected flavor/role combination). But it's a step in the "town" direction for ulti. Incidentally I gave corrik's day 1 play bonus points as he had locked JC into team "no move" which combined with the claimed vanilla flavor had a lot to do with his death.
With 3 minutes to go Corrik says "Jc real claim?" (T3P317) Feels like it could be a hail mary to give JC a chance to recant and squeeze someone else in at the deadline. Corrik had swapped his vote to red at that point, he swapped it to a JC vote with 57 seconds to EoD and then swapped it to NO vote 18 seconds later. At the time it was still 5/4 and it wasn't until Ben swapped from Ifrit to JC that it put things comfortable out of reach. Combined with his 'cringe' comment earlier I can't help but like Ben's involvement in JC's lynch, regardless of my feelings about his earlier play.
So Ben, Blade and Ulti all look better. Peaf mayyybe looks better? Corrik looks both better and worse.
.
On a different note I did not appreciate Ben chastizing me for "not providing" the Move / No Move list as though I'm the only person capable of tracking information. For one this was Corriks thing and he had already posted a fairly updated last the prior topic. For another I was at work and not at home with my spreadsheets. For another another I hadn't even updated my spreadsheet with any of the information yet because other than move/no move we basically didn't have anything.
But now that I had time here's what I have so far:
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/c/c52c33d6.png
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/7/76104c3c.png
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/c/c408c251.png
~C~
FD
http://i.imgur.com/dGDfxaw.png