I like the list a lot.if it was framed as a list of 100 great albums the discourse would be much different than it is.
It's not my list, or even close to it, but it's an interesting selection of the classics that appear on every list, a handful of more recent albums, and a few surprises.
These lists are good for sparking discussion and getting people to listen to something new. They're never definitive, and they aren't bad if they differ from yours.
if it was framed as a list of 100 great albums the discourse would be much different than it is.'Best' is just rhetoric to hype the list. There's never going to be a 'best'. It doesn't bother me if they call it that.
But saying its the 100 best albums and putting some of these on here while leaving out some incredibly obvious choices is wack.
'Best' is just rhetoric. There's never going to be a 'best'. It doesn't bother me if they call it that.I mean yeah I agree it can get boring looking at the same lists but I dont think Taylor swifts 1989 re-recording as a top 20 album is particularly interesting lmao
And it's just boring looking at the same old lists of the same of stuff all the time.
I mean yeah I agree it can get boring looking at the same lists but I dont think Taylor swifts 1989 re-recording as a top 20 album is particularly interesting lmaoThere's definitely some strange choices.
Some of the choices here just dont have business being in a top album list at all, thats my problem with most of it lol
It's missing anything country at all. I'd at least throw in something like Willie Nelson's Stardust or Johnny Cash's The Man Comes Around.Isn't Kacey Musgrave country or did she pull a TSwift and start leaning more into pop?
I was going to say that the list was crap when I saw Kid A
Not gonna lie, I have no idea who the 1st place artist is.
Anyways the list mostly makes sense, they were obviously not gonna throw in any curve balls like The Human Equation by Ayreon since stuff like progressive rock operas are not commercially viable. But as a list of 100 albums people should know of it is fine.
I do think the biggest omission is Boston's self titled album
dont know who the Fugees are? SMH
dont know who the Fugees are? SMHI don't know who Ayreon is/are, so it didn't feel right to point that out.
Like you mean to tell me Lorde, Billie Eilish, Beyonce, Taylor Swift belong on this list but nothing from Diana Ross/The Supremes, Donna Summer, Dolly Parton, Mavis Staples, Chaka Khan, etc?Patti Smith's Horses is a bit of an omission.
Is Madonna on the list? I really don't want to scroll through this shit on mobile lolYes.
I don't know who Ayreon is/are, so it didn't feel right to point that out.That is pretty much expected, my post was saying they are not going to include something like that because it is from a niche genre.
dont know who the Fugees are? SMHOh was she part of them? I am not much into hip hop, but I recognize that group, just didn't know the individual members
Patti Smith's Horses is a bit of an omission.Horses is at #83
I don't mind Lorde and Beyonce on the list.
Horses is at #83
i dont think those albums are bad or anything I just think there is definitely recency bias when it comes to women artists on these types of lists
or rather, music journalism has spent so long not actually taking music from women seriously that they have no idea how to rectify that
Legit surprised to see The Strokes on there, as they're one of my fav bands.Only people to get more then one entry are Beyonc, Prince, Radiohead and Beatles. So theyre definitely leaning towards the most representative albums and not the actual critically acclaim or retail best album. Hence the weird choices.
Not so surprised, but happy to see The Cure make it, Disintegration is an easy 10/10 album.
Aquemini is a fantastic album too, so it was cool to see here.
Dark Side of the Moon is GOAT tier, so being as low as it was kind of surprised me. And being the only Floyd album on the list was kind of shocking too. It's among the best selling albums ever and was on the top 100 longer than any other album ever, feel like it deserved more love here than 28.
Discovery is another all timer for me, so happy to see it ranked in the teens.
Beastie Boys making the list but for the wrong album was kind of weird to me. License to Ill was legit non stop bangers. No idea why Paul's Boutique was put in over it. Maybe along with it, but definitely not over it.
Beastie Boys making the list but for the wrong album was kind of weird to me. License to Ill was legit non stop bangers. No idea why Paul's Boutique was put in over it. Maybe along with it, but definitely not over it.gotta call this out, Pauls Boutique is their consensus masterpiece and Licensed to Ill is their fourth best album at most
Frank Ocean ahead of Songs in the Key of Life ?Channel Orange way stronger project then blonde anyway but I digress.
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/2/289aa712.jpg
Beastie Boys making the list but for the wrong album was kind of weird to me. License to Ill was legit non stop bangers. No idea why Paul's Boutique was put in over it. Maybe along with it, but definitely not over it.I've gotta agree with TheGoldenEel on this. Paul's Boutique is unquestionably their best record.