HG/SS vs Crystal, which is the best version of Johto?

Current Events

Current Events » HG/SS vs Crystal, which is the best version of Johto?
Duncanwii
09/11/2017
07:41 PM
#1
We all live in a Pokemon world.


View Results
Most people will say the remakes, but Crystal has good points like early Teddursa and Growlithe as well as no natures for easy breeding.
I dream of one day owning a SNES Classic.
I like Gardevoir, just not in that way.
ItsVinceRusso
09/11/2017
07:45 PM
#2
the johto post game is probably the closest thing we'll ever get to an open world pokemon game, sadly.
bro
Gafemage
09/11/2017
07:48 PM
#3
Objectively, HG/SS.

Personally, though, I'll always prefer Crystal; along with the obvious nostalgia, GSC also has my favorite visual style in the series.
http://imgur.com/1EOFcjn http://imgur.com/epjd8zk
JosefuJustice11
09/11/2017
08:12 PM
#4
Crystal. It was literally the first ever Pokémon game I ever played.
I felt like I was watching a dream I'd never wake up from... Before I knew it, the dream was all over.
alphagamble
09/11/2017
08:13 PM
#5
Both are good but Crystal nostalgia is too strong
ooh
Calwings
09/11/2017
08:28 PM
#6
Battle Frontier >>>>>> anything in 2nd gen's Johto
"Someday I too will fly... and find you again!"
http://i.imgur.com/n2ikBX2.jpg
ItsVinceRusso
09/11/2017
08:38 PM
#7
Calwings posted...
Battle Frontier >>>>>> anything in 2nd gen's Johto


i'm still mad at gamefreak for not including battle frontier in the hoenn remakes.

inexcusable.
bro
LinksLiege
09/11/2017
08:40 PM
#8
DS remakes, no debate.

It takes the best parts of Crystal and adds it to an improved post-game. And the physical-special split is there too. I don't care about nostalgia, I care about function.
This is LinksLiege's signature. It is fantastic.
Eevee-Trainer
09/11/2017
08:45 PM
#9
Duncanwii posted...
Most people will say the remakes, but Crystal has good points like early Teddursa and Growlithe as well as no natures for easy breeding.

the positives of Teddiursa/Growlithe are laughably irrelevant compared to the vast array of everything else. Same for Natures, especially when there's next to no competitive environment outside of Generation VII now.
Maybe I'll put something here one day.
Current Events » HG/SS vs Crystal, which is the best version of Johto?