Persona 4 was weak back when it first came out. In Game of the Decade it barely beat Dead Rising. It's a solid midcarder now, and its strength probably transfers to P5 if that ever makes a contest, but I'd still take Brawl and MGS4 over it.
Hell, I'm not sure Fallout 3 holds up either, and we don't have a good read on it thanks to Undertale.
---
Come watch me on Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/gameryogi