Current Events > GTA 5 or RDR 2?

Topic List	Page List: 1
CastletonSnob1 09/11/25 8:21:20 PM #1:	Which game is better? - Results (44 votes) GTA V 27.27% (12 votes) 12 RDR 2 72.73% (32 votes) 32 Which game is better? <cite>CastletonSnob1 posted [p:986376743] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote> Which game is better? - Results (44 votes) GTA V 27.27% (12 votes) 12 RDR 2 72.73% (32 votes) 32 Show Voting Form Which game is better?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
archizzy 09/11/25 8:32:28 PM #2:	Both awesome games and I love both series but RDR2 is my favorite game of all time that I think is a masterpiece and with a couple small changes would be perfection to me. I think it is the best world ever created. So GTA V was amazing, but I'm taking RDR2 every time. --- PSN ID: sled_dogs76 60" Pioneer Kuro Elite PRO151FD, Yamaha RX-V3900 A/V Receiver, Oppo DV983-H player. Coming soon: 2 Seaton Submersives from Mark Seaton <cite>archizzy posted [p:986376833] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>Both awesome games and I love both series but RDR2 is my favorite game of all time that I think is a masterpiece and with a couple small changes would be perfection to me. I think it is the best world ever created.So GTA V was amazing, but I'm taking RDR2 every time. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
el_cheato 09/11/25 8:50:59 PM #3:	RDR2 has a very strong story. GTA V is just kinda stuff happening. --- Source: it is known among the wise <cite>el_cheato posted [p:986377022] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>RDR2 has a very strong story. GTA V is just kinda stuff happening.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis 09/11/25 8:55:25 PM #4:	RDR2 and it's not even close. <cite>vigorm0rtis posted [p:986377065] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>RDR2 and it's not even close.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Demigod_Elessar 09/11/25 8:59:12 PM #5:	Love both games but have to go with RDR2. Red Dead 1 was one of my favorite games last generation, and I was blown away by the sequel. Probably the single greatest, most "alive" game world I've ever played in, with amazing characters and story. In between missions, I would often go off road and just explore or wander around for an hour or more at a time. Not necessarily looking for any side quests or stranger missions (though sometimes being rewarded with them), but just because of all of the little interactions and random events you could discover. --- Iron Maiden is my religion <cite>Demigod_Elessar posted [p:986377118] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>Love both games but have to go with RDR2. Red Dead 1 was one of my favorite games last generation, and I was blown away by the sequel. Probably the single greatest, most "alive" game world I've ever played in, with amazing characters and story. In between missions, I would often go off road and just explore or wander around for an hour or more at a time. Not necessarily looking for any side quests or stranger missions (though sometimes being rewarded with them), but just because of all of the little interactions and random events you could discover. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Hayame_Zero 09/11/25 9:00:04 PM #6:	RDR2 is a better experience, but GTAV is more fun. --- ...I think I'm done here... <cite>Hayame_Zero posted [p:986377133] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>RDR2 is a better experience, but GTAV is more fun.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
bevan306 09/11/25 9:00:34 PM #7:	vigorm0rtis posted... RDR2 and it's not even close. --- http://rateyourmusic.com/~bevan http://i.imgur.com/5Ta28.jpg <cite>bevan306 posted [p:986377139] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>vigorm0rtis posted... </cite><quote>RDR2 and it's not even close.</quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mad-Dogg 09/11/25 9:02:11 PM #8:	Red dead redemption 2 overall. (And especially red dead online. I played red dead online so, so much back when it was actually getting updates). With GTA5 I wanted way more heist missions then what we actually got during the story. --- GTag:MadDogg730 PSN:lMadDogg NNID:xMadDoggx NS friend code:5313-0564-0819 Go buy cyber shadow like right now. <cite>Mad-Dogg posted [p:986377160] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>Red dead redemption 2 overall. (And especially red dead online. I played red dead online so, so much back when it was actually getting updates).With GTA5 I wanted way more heist missions then what we actually got during the story.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MonkeyBones23 09/11/25 9:04:00 PM #9:	I have almost no attachment to GTAV and overall thought it was forgettable compared to past entries. RDR2 is a masterpiece of a game. --- We're a forest of lives, but we grow tall and wide. We'll never be cut down. <cite>MonkeyBones23 posted [p:986377185] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>I have almost no attachment to GTAV and overall thought it was forgettable compared to past entries. RDR2 is a masterpiece of a game.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
archizzy 09/11/25 9:09:14 PM #10:	Mad-Dogg posted... Red dead redemption 2 overall. (And especially red dead online. I played red dead online so, so much back when it was actually getting updates). With GTA5 I wanted way more heist missions then what we actually got during the story. I skip online 99.99% of the time. I played the hell out of RDR2 online because what was so great was it was viable to play solo. It was just an extension on single player. I fucking loved setting up the camp and doing the trader role which allowed me to do my favorite activity which was just to hunt. Then I got to deliver the goods in the wagon. The supply restocking missions were fun too. Then the bounty hunting, the moonshiner stuff, the naturalist role with missions and like 40 additional legendary animals. Then you had dynamic events, stranger missions, and other missions from people on the map and so much stuff and you didn't have to interact with a single person and rarely even saw anybody else. The online was fucking great. I swear if they released a ps5 specific RDR2 game with improvements I'd buy it again and jump back into the online. I had an absolutely blast playing online. I loved all the unique horses, saddles, and outfits that came with each role and the fact they gave you tons of money and gold to buy whatever you wanted. It was really well done. --- PSN ID: sled_dogs76 60" Pioneer Kuro Elite PRO151FD, Yamaha RX-V3900 A/V Receiver, Oppo DV983-H player. Coming soon: 2 Seaton Submersives from Mark Seaton <cite>archizzy posted [p:986377236] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>Mad-Dogg posted... </cite><quote>Red dead redemption 2 overall. (And especially red dead online. I played red dead online so, so much back when it was actually getting updates).With GTA5 I wanted way more heist missions then what we actually got during the story.</quote>I skip online 99.99% of the time. I played the hell out of RDR2 online because what was so great was it was viable to play solo. It was just an extension on single player. I fucking loved setting up the camp and doing the trader role which allowed me to do my favorite activity which was just to hunt. Then I got to deliver the goods in the wagon. The supply restocking missions were fun too.Then the bounty hunting, the moonshiner stuff, the naturalist role with missions and like 40 additional legendary animals. Then you had dynamic events, stranger missions, and other missions from people on the map and so much stuff and you didn't have to interact with a single person and rarely even saw anybody else.The online was fucking great. I swear if they released a ps5 specific RDR2 game with improvements I'd buy it again and jump back into the online. I had an absolutely blast playing online.I loved all the unique horses, saddles, and outfits that came with each role and the fact they gave you tons of money and gold to buy whatever you wanted. It was really well done.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AndyReklaw 09/11/25 9:12:10 PM #11:	GTA V is great and a lot of fun. RDR2 is a masterpiece. It's been 7 years and no one has come close to the realness of RDR 2's world. And Arthur is an incredible character (at least as a good guy... I could never bring myself to play him as bad). --- This user is awesome!: https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/user/gamefaqs-user?account=12351915135 <cite>AndyReklaw posted [p:986377267] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>GTA V is great and a lot of fun. RDR2 is a masterpiece. It's been 7 years and no one has come close to the realness of RDR 2's world. And Arthur is an incredible character (at least as a good guy... I could never bring myself to play him as bad).</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Mad-Dogg 09/11/25 9:14:18 PM #12:	archizzy posted... I skip online 99.99% of the time. I played the hell out of RDR2 online because what was so great was it was viable to play solo. It was just an extension on single player. I fucking loved setting up the camp and doing the trader role which allowed me to do my favorite activity which was just to hunt. Then I got to deliver the goods in the wagon. The supply restocking missions were fun too. Then the bounty hunting, the moonshiner stuff, the naturalist role with missions and like 40 additional legendary animals. Then you had dynamic events, stranger missions, and other missions from people on the map and so much stuff and you didn't have to interact with a single person and rarely even saw anybody else. The online was fucking. I swear if they released a ps5 specific RDR2 game with improvements I'd buy it again and jump back into the online. I had an absolutely blast playing online. I loved all the unique horses, saddles, and outfits that came with each role and the fact they gave you tons of money and gold to buy whatever you wanted. It was really well done. I did the exact same thing. Like 80 percent of the time I was solo just......enjoying the world, lmao. Like how you have those people who would play stuff like no man's sky or minecraft for their vibe game, red dead online was mine. My favorite role was definitely bounty hunting (really enjoyed the legendary bounties they eventually added, and then they let us get our own wagon lol), but hunting and treasure hunting was fun as hell too. I used to play a lot of the lobby events related the bounty hunting and treasure hunting too just to do it. (Including condor egg. I got so good at condor egg that I used to carry around stacks of money from all my wins). Doing the trader runs. Getting all the clothes just for fashion. Full stable of horses. Actually completing all those battle pass things they had (with the older daily system they had this stuff didn't even feel like a drag to do. It was mad easy to make progress with it). Man I loved me some red dead online. https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/a/adcb2935.jpg --- GTag:MadDogg730 PSN:lMadDogg NNID:xMadDoggx NS friend code:5313-0564-0819 Go buy cyber shadow like right now. <cite>Mad-Dogg posted [p:986377299] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>archizzy posted... </cite><quote>I skip online 99.99% of the time. I played the hell out of RDR2 online because what was so great was it was viable to play solo. It was just an extension on single player. I fucking loved setting up the camp and doing the trader role which allowed me to do my favorite activity which was just to hunt. Then I got to deliver the goods in the wagon. The supply restocking missions were fun too.Then the bounty hunting, the moonshiner stuff, the naturalist role with missions and like 40 additional legendary animals. Then you had dynamic events, stranger missions, and other missions from people on the map and so much stuff and you didn't have to interact with a single person and rarely even saw anybody else.The online was fucking. I swear if they released a ps5 specific RDR2 game with improvements I'd buy it again and jump back into the online. I had an absolutely blast playing online.I loved all the unique horses, saddles, and outfits that came with each role and the fact they gave you tons of money and gold to buy whatever you wanted. It was really well done.</quote>I did the exact same thing. Like 80 percent of the time I was solo just......enjoying the world, lmao. Like how you have those people who would play stuff like no man's sky or minecraft for their vibe game, red dead online was mine. My favorite role was definitely bounty hunting (really enjoyed the legendary bounties they eventually added, and then they let us get our own wagon lol), but hunting and treasure hunting was fun as hell too. I used to play a lot of the lobby events related the bounty hunting and treasure hunting too just to do it. (Including condor egg. I got so good at condor egg that I used to carry around stacks of money from all my wins).Doing the trader runs. Getting all the clothes just for fashion. Full stable of horses. Actually completing all those battle pass things they had (with the older daily system they had this stuff didn't even feel like a drag to do. It was mad easy to make progress with it). Man I loved me some red dead online.https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/a/adcb2935.jpg</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
boxoto 09/11/25 9:31:01 PM #13:	Red Dead Redemption 2 is a GOAT video game contender, as far as I'm concerned. Grand Theft Auto V is an amazing achievement, though. --- Don't you agree, Zach? https://streamable.com/ueacaz <cite>boxoto posted [p:986377471] in GTA 5 or R... [t:81039671]...</cite> <quote>Red Dead Redemption 2 is a GOAT video game contender, as far as I'm concerned. Grand Theft Auto V is an amazing achievement, though. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1

Current Events > GTA 5 or RDR 2? (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > GTA 5 or RDR 2?