Board 8 > Star Trek Mafia - Topic 12: There are Four Lights!

(+) Yeah! (+)

Sultan why didn't you just vote Ben at the end? lol

Anyway, Ben, sorry. I had to double down on me defense because it was mostly a true defense. I played D1 exactly like I would as Town, except I cleared Dumey early on because I thought he picked up my hint that I was Traitor.

Still baffled scum chose to bus Chris like that

Congrats, Dumey, on winning scum MVP despite being town! Truly impressed with such a feat.

Seriously, what I was able to read was painful. Scum had you guys hoodwinked. I, like Ben, would have gone after Han because he was still alive and waffling. But then Lea and Sultan were another matter, and I would have never gotten both of that pair.

gg scum!

Oh look at that, the whole scum team was on Chris.

And I was right about Sultan day 1, but not right enough to the point where I shot Death instead of him, that one I do feel stupid about.

But it really was Han and Lea, that's the redemption I at least can have.

EDumey posted...

I did it guys. I was scum MVP. Hooray.

Don't blame yourself, Neighbor chat is dangerous and Lea is wily.

Besides, I'm not sure Sultan gets lynched ever? Like... he was pretty unlynchable I thought.

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/5/8/2/AAOt6hAAESzO.jpg

Note the timestamp @htaeD

Scum played great. Ben played great but there wasn't much he could do, and Town just got complacent after that D1. And Han's play was hilarious to watch knowing his role.

Sultan eventually looked pretty bad to me, he was only saved due to Chris' posts

I honestly wanted to come in and vote Sultan but ran out of time and panicked.

The problem was I was sure Dumey was town, and thought Sultan was scum, so the vote on Han totally threw me off.

Sorry team. I'm going to take a break for a bit, that was an atrocious game for me.

SirChris posted...

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/5/8/2/AAOt6hAAESzO.jpg

Note the timestamp @htaeD

I respect it, but this will never work again

Most of the train on Chris was people who would bus him as I said.

And that clown decided to out me. JC scum MVP.

Chaeix posted...

I honestly wanted to come in and vote Sultan but ran out of time and panicked.

The problem was I was sure Dumey was town, and thought Sultan was scum, so the vote on Han totally threw me off.

Sorry team. I'm going to take a break for a bit, that was an atrocious game for me.

Nah you played great tbh. I found you to be the biggest threat

UltimaterializerX posted...

Dumey will see that Han flip and still somehow call him town lmao

Good job buddy. How many mislynches does he need to lead before you kill him? 28? 29? Looking for a ballpark number here.

I only led 1 mislynch this game, bucko

And it was on Ben

ctesjbuvf posted...

Oh look at that, the whole scum team was on Chris.

And I was right about Sultan day 1, but not right enough to the point where I shot Death instead of him, that one I do feel stupid about.

But it really was Han and Lea, that's the redemption I at least can have.

To be fair, I was really more Survivor who could only win with Scum, SOOOO

Being 15 sure sucks

Han you were definitely trying to get me mislynched now cmon

@Chris

I almost voted Sultan purely because you were hyping him up in the mafia legends topic. You haven't played much with Sultan this year and it struck me as if you were interacting with him and seeing his game behind the scenes.

I didn't want to bring that into the game because it would have been extremely poor form but I saw that and was like 'this looks super sus'.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Dumey will see that Han flip and still somehow call him town lmao

Good job buddy. How many mislynches does he need to lead before you kill him? 28? 29? Looking for a ballpark number here.

Lets not pretend like you weren't completely wrong on me though, buddy. This whole "how many mislynches" thing is a pretty fucking awful benchmark, seeing as how it was wrong when it came to me. Please don't act sanctimonious when you had no idea what was happening either.

Anyway ctes you only have your perspective because you haven't lived through the horrors of scum Chris tbh

Also this only needs to work once! My next scum game I will have another evil plan

You town folk really do need to be nicer

Also we thought han was town xd

Chaeix posted...

@Chris

I almost voted Sultan purely because you were hyping him up in the mafia legends topic. You haven't played much with Sultan this year and it struck me as if you were interacting with him and seeing his game behind the scenes.

I didn't want to bring that into the game because it would have been extremely poor form but I saw that and was like 'this looks super sus'.

Would have been bad seeing as I love Sultan even before this game tbh

Also, was I the only one to propose that Lea going after Chris was a bus?

Feels like every game, nobody listens to some theory of mine that ends up being completely true.

Thanks for subbing in for me, Ben. You did admirably and had 3/4 of the scum pegged. Don't know why they lynched you after JC scanned you idle. So dumb.

I mean why wouldnt you think Han was town?

Try to remember I gutted Ben like a fish a year ago for talking smack to town sultan!

Hey JC

Why did you vote your own scan these last two days instead of killing Han with me >_>

HanOfTheNekos posted...

wtf it was Sultan?

LOL

all the claimed Town power was power except the drunk, that's a riot

I had the same reaction holy shit

And you were Traitor???

WAIT
So Sultan didn't know you were scum and voted you?
That was actually the biggest brain play he could've done to make him look good and it was probably totally unintentional holy fucking shit

BROOOOO what the fuck is this game LMAO

htaeD posted...

Han you were definitely trying to get me mislynched now cmon

I didn't know you were Town!

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I didn't know you were Town!

It shouldve been obvious!

I thought you were town death

htaeD posted...

It shouldve been obvious!

It wasn't!

SirChris posted...

Also we thought han was town xd

Even to the end? Was I not obvious enough with:
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/5/8/7/AAOJ0pAAESzT.jpg

there was an early game in my mafia days where chris regarded me the same way he regarded sultan in this game. really brought out some nostalgia! VN2 maybe?

SirChris posted...

I thought you were town death

0 points

SirChris posted...

Anyway ctes you only have your perspective because you haven't lived through the horrors of scum Chris tbh

What do you mean lol

ctesjbuvf posted...

Hey JC

Why did you vote your own scan these last two days instead of killing Han with me >_>

because i thought the 4d chess was being played around my scans and sultan was scum.

in all seriousness if sultan hadn't voted for han the EoD would have been completely different

that being said, i wouldn't have been the one to lose the game if sultan had just hammered anyways so uh

i just straight up ran out of time and had like 60 seconds left before i had my sultan vote typed up and realized i wasn't going to be able to swing that in time

ALSO important to note i thought i was tying it. i thought it was 3-2 Han-Ben. so i straight up fucked up by voting and tiebreaking anyways.

But even without the ploy, I dont think town has a great chance against a scumteam with Chris, Lea and Han on it

ctesjbuvf posted...

What do you mean lol

What game have we played where I steamrolled people as mafia? I don't recall!

very very glad i did not replace in and let isquen do it instead

would have been awful timing for me and i don't think i ever would have caught up to live gameplay

although i did suspect something nefarious afoot after seeing chris go down relatively easily for what i would expect

Man it's frustrating that I went with Death instead of Sultan and then town talked me own of my Sultan suspicions.

Though I reconsidered him heavily the last day with that vote.

changmas posted...

very very glad i did not replace in and let isquen do it instead

would have been awful timing for me and i don't think i ever would have caught up to live gameplay

although i did suspect something nefarious afoot after seeing chris go down relatively easily for what i would expect

this was bothering me the whole time and i wish i had leaned further into this

it irked the shit out of me that chris just disappeared and died

i should have trusted that instinct

ctesjbuvf posted...

Man it's frustrating that I went with Death instead of Sultan and then town talked me own of my Sultan suspicions.

Though I reconsidered him heavily the last day with that vote.

Yeah if you read scum chat I was a little worried there

But my cute kouhai pulled it off

Just dont shoot night1 is my advise!

htaeD posted...

But even without the ploy, I dont think town has a great chance against a scumteam with Chris, Lea and Han on it

Goddammit Ben, we were so close

Oh and spoilers

I didn't take a nap

Like the only reason I didn't vote Chris was because I wanted to see Han do it

I wasn't even on the team! I was just in a corner by myself.

I was ready to claim Survivor as Borg Queen.

SirChris posted...

Yeah if you read scum chat I was a little worried there

But my cute kouhai pulled it off

I would have shot him n2 if I had another shot for what it's worth lol.

SirChris posted...

Oh and spoilers

I didn't take a nap

You missed out then

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I wasn't even on the team! I was just in a corner by myself.

I was ready to claim Survivor as Borg Queen.

Ugh
Thanks for reminding me of Picard Season 2 (and season 1 as well)

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I wasn't even on the team! I was just in a corner by myself.

I was ready to claim Survivor as Borg Queen.

i'll be honest i was pretty convinced it was a 3-man team and we weren't actually at lylo

independent scum was not what i expected

I have one host question.

I PM'd SBell what the hell Ulti's role actually did but was not allowed an answer, why?