Board 8 > Star Wars and Pokemon Mafia Topic 1 - The Phantom Menace

(+) Yeah! (+)

For what its worth Sheep, I expected it to be more about Sultan than me. But I had to be sure.

I have become an old man. I don't like the term 'sus' in mafia, and I do not like 'vibecheck' I'm over it

let's use the new topic please :)

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80023425

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80023425

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80023425

move

Sheep, I'm gonna be honest, I like your post. I don't necessarily agree with it, but I like your way of thinking. I agree that town should be more pro-active. I just don't think pressuring Plum is going to help here. In fact, I'd argue it makes more sense for you to push for Lea since you don't have any reservations about always thinking she's scum, unlike Lopen and Plum.

Truthfully, I think Plum has said more than enough to get a decent grasp on him. Lopen and Lea, not so much. But just as you're certain that Scare is town (which is something I agree with upon re-reading), I believe Plum is very likely town this game.

Speaking of Plum...

masterplum posted...

Here is a day 1 wall from Kirby. Still way less fluff than early this game

I... really don't see what's so different about this post compared to what I've posted so far? If anything, I think my post was hardly substantial, and that's ignoring the fact that it's Topic 4 of Day 1. You'd think I'd have more to say after 1,500+ posts, but I was also going into a game where I didn't know anyone except Ben. I only commented about Ben, who I know from outside the game, and Han, who was deliberately trying to provoke me into making a newbie mistake. And in that very post, all I concluded was "I don't like them, but it could go either way".

Plum, I think you're grasping at straws here. But your conviction is only furthering my belief that you are town.

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


You, on the other hand, do not get a pass. What is your analysis of the wall quoted by Plum? What makes my posts today "fluffier" than my posts from the previous game?

I still do not like Plum, his voting on Kirby feels opportunitistic

But I also am not feeling great on Kirby. While Plum is trying to argue apples and oranges, I'd rather just say that these fuji bits of content are not the granny smiths I want from Kirby. His tone feels different and he feels fluffy, he wants to be here without doing much. And I definitely disagree with a Sheep vote.

I also do not like JC. Its a bit of a combo of both of the previous issues I have. JC is here and posting but it feels almost tactical to blend in and be safe

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Kirby I have clarified my issue with this post, as this operates under an assumption that is untrue. I didn't vote him for 'being confused about the flavor.' When you have a moment can you please address that as well, curious to hear your thoughts.

So your recent posts have added some extra clarity on why you wanted to lynch chang, and although I don't necessarily agree with your conclusion, I recognize your reasoning. I especially don't agree with the conclusion when you also recognized that town doesn't necessarily choose their words carefully, and I think chang was just generalizing about your pro-Town nature and playstyle rather than anything specific. (Not that I would know; I'm simply going off of hearsay and the flavor you gave me during the last game about your own abilities)

That being said, I saw the Page 4 posts this morning as part of the "111 new messages" notification. It was a lot to read, and I didn't feel scummy about chang at all, so could you really blame me when the last thing I remember before seeing the chang vote was you replying to his message about the lack of Pokmon flavor? Hence my confusion on why chang was leading the votals at the time.

Ack sorry wrong topic

bumpo

bumpo