Board 8 > Favorite Ace Attorney Case 2 culprit? (Spoilers)

(+) Yeah! (+)

Names in case you need them or you don't want them spoiled for a game you haven't played:

1-2 - Redd White

2-2 - Ini/Mimi Miney

3-2 - Luke Atmey

4-2 - Alita Tiala

5-2 - Florent L'Belle

6-2 - Roger Retinz/The Great Mr. Reus

E1-2 - Cammy Meele

E2-2 - Patricia Roland

L-2 - Kira

Kind of a mixed bag here. While I do have a soft spot for 1-2's culprit, the last testimony of 3-2 is one of my favorite moments in the series.

Special shoutout to 6-2 for having perhaps the best villain theme in the series.


---

zvarri! the answer to this poll has been elegantly revealed to me
---

Do my locutions confuse?

---

Weak field, E1-2 is cute though so I voted for her

---

I still don't understand why E1-2 blows bubbles when she's upset.

---

1-2 is a bad case, and 3-2 is a top-tier case, but I honestly don't really care for Atmey and White is fantabulistic.

---

bubble girl

I thought it was weird that I found myself liking Meele, but i guess it's a common opinion

---

Anagram posted...

I still don't understand why E1-2 blows bubbles when she's upset.

She uses the bubbles to pretend to be asleep so I guess they decided to run with the gag.

---

Zvarri!
Apparently, his English catchphrase was going to be "Schwing!" until they changed it to a nonsense word close to the original Japanese.

Yeah, the Case 2 culprits is a pretty weak field. I think all other fields when dividing by case is pretty solid. Its weird having L-2s culprit in my top 3 here.

anyways easy 3-2

also regarding E-2 Meele, they specifically designed Rhoda to be line based and Meele is more circle based.

---

I think 3-2 is the only case to win all of its days so far if this holds

(It won't win victim though!)

---

I mean, you could count Maya as the victim, and then it has a chance.

---

I think 1-2's victim has the X-2 victim poll on lockdown.
---

SeabassDebeste posted...

zvarri! the answer to this poll has been elegantly revealed to me

Couldn't have said it better myself.

I will say this, I was very scared to watch 3-2 in the anime because Atmey is the only character in the entire franchise that I had a very specific voice for in my head, and was afraid that the anime wouldn't do it justice. And while his anime voice was fine, it just wasn't the same.

---

Underleveled posted...

Couldn't have said it better myself.

I will say this, I was very scared to watch 3-2 in the anime because Atmey is the only character in the entire franchise that I had a very specific voice for in my head, and was afraid that the anime wouldn't do it justice. And while his anime voice was fine, it just wasn't the same.

I imagined him as having a screechy British voice.

---

His voice in the dub was fine, but I feel like the dub didn't have any real "home runs" in terms of their voice selections.

Maybe Maya.

---

I only watched a few clips of the dub so maybe my impression is off, but I remember liking Phoenix's dub voice.
---

Team Rocket Elite posted...

I only watched a few clips of the dub so maybe my impression is off, but I remember liking Phoenix's dub voice.

Yeah, it's pretty good, but I wouldn't call it a home run. Better than Edgeworth's though. Wasn't a fan of that one.

---

"'Culprit'...that's, like, the person who kills someone, right?"
sways back and forth

---

E1-2 because of cleavage

Nah not really, real answer is Zvarri

---

3-2's overrated

Voted for 6-2 though I do think E1-2's is great for the short time that they're around

the anime doesn't really nail anyone tbh even outside of the dub

Quietude!

---

It pleases me greatly that E2-2 has no votes.

---

Leonhart4 posted...

It pleases me greatly that E2-2 has no votes.

Why?
There wasn't anything wrong with her
She just wasn't anything special

---

E2-2 kind of highlights the problem with the Edgeworth games where cases get artificially inflated when the culprit just repeatedly brushes aside the supposedly decisive evidence because it's not decisive ENOUGH. It gets even worse when they come back in E2-5.

Like I get all the games do it to an extent, but the Edgeworth games do it a lot.

---

I did not expect 3-2 to be running away with this. Didn't know that person was so popular! Not the strongest category, to be fair.

---

I think he'd do fairly well overall if we ranked all the culprits! 3-2 is one of the more popular non-epic cases in general.

---

Yeah, this is just a two horse race between 1-2 and 3-2. I am a bit surprised 3-2 is the clear favorite, but it's not completely unexpected.

---

andylt posted...

I did not expect 3-2 to be running away with this. Didn't know that person was so popular! Not the strongest category, to be fair.

If you have seen how 3-2 performed in the previous polls you would have expected this
I honestly thought 3-3 was the most popular non-epic case of T&T but this poll series taught me differently

---

3-3 is probably the most divisive T&T case. I think most people generally like it, but I've also seen some people who really hate it.

---

3-2 isn't the *most* amazing culprit, but this batch is superweak. i think e2-2's might rank in the top half.

the case 1 culprits are so much stronger overall.
---

SeabassDebeste posted...

i think e2-2's might rank in the top half.

And yet that's the only one with 0 votes
---

E2-2 might rank above 5-2 but that's about it.

---

I voted for 6-2. I found that character charismatic and effective in both his trollish director persona and his wronged magician persona

3-2 is great too, not gonna find any fault in them winning.

MrSmartGuy posted...

1-2 is a bad case, and 3-2 is a top-tier case, but I honestly don't really care for [3-2 killer] and [1-2 killer] is fantabulistic.

Huh, that surprises me. 3-2's killer is sooo important to the case that I would expect anyone's opinion of the case to line up with the character. I've known a couple people who aren't so hot on 3-2 and it always comes down to being not so hot on the culprit, since they're by far the most important character in both trial days.

(On the other hand it's certainly reasonable to prefer 1-2's killer to the case... I like the 1-2 killer pretty well too, but the case has some problems.)

---