Board 8 > Best Red Hot Chili Peppers album?

(+) Yeah! (+)

The Beatles:
1 (tie). Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
1 (tie). Abbey Road
3. Revolver

Led Zeppelin:
1. Led Zeppelin IV
2. Houses of the Holy
3 (tie). Led Zeppelin II
3 (tie). Led Zeppelin III

AC/DC:
1. Back in Black
2. The Razors Edge

Queen:
1. A Night at the Opera
2. A Day at the Races

Pink Floyd:
1. The Dark Side of the Moon
2. The Wall
3. Wish You Were Here
---

by the way free all killer no filler
---

Californication > By the Way > Blood Sugar Sex Magik > One Hot Minute > Stadium Arcadium > The Getaway > Mother's Milk > I'm with You > RHCP > Uplift Mofo > Freaky Styley
---

BSSM is really one of the most underrated albums of all time
---

SmartMuffin posted...

BSSM is really one of the most underrated albums of all time

I feel this way with One Hot Minute, I love the more metal-influence sound of that album.
---

SmartMuffin posted...

BSSM is really one of the most underrated albums of all time

I feel like it's the generally accepted best RHCP album though. Maybe the youths gravitate more toward californication or SA now?
---

Stadium Arcadium by a mile.
---

surprised stadium arcadium is winning with all the mediocre filler tracks
---

Stadium Arcadium should absolutely not be two hours long.
---

By the Way.

---

The answer is Californication.

---

MysticBrohan posted...

surprised stadium arcadium is winning with all the mediocre filler tracks

voted for it for its peak songs
---

The official
Red Hot Chilipinions (tm):

By the Way's the best album.

Californiacation has the best collection of their top-tier songs.

Under the Bridge is the greatest song of all time.
---

Damn this is tough.
---

SeabassDebeste posted...

MysticBrohan posted...

surprised stadium arcadium is winning with all the mediocre filler tracks

voted for it for its peak songs

i guess but i mean for every Wet Sand or Animal Bar there's a Storm in a Teacup or an Especially in Michigan
---

Wayne's World soundtrack because it has their best song

https://youtu.be/fs15T177rBk

---

I'd like to vote SA because of Dani California, as that's one of my all-time favorite songs, but realistically there's way too much wasted space on that album.

Californication is the right answer.
---

blood sugar sex magik is underrated? it's generally seen as one of their best albums (though i'm surprised it's in third place now. didn't know people loved stadium arcadium this much).

anyway, the answer is mother's milk.
---

SaveEstelle posted...

By the Way.

SaveEstelle posted...

The answer is Californication.

...you changed your mind in the span of one minute?
---

I think he was trying to be cute.

Anyway, OHM > BSSM > Cali > SA > IWY > MM > BTW > rest
---

The Uplift Mofo Party Plan

---

The one where California is mentioned multiple times
---

I went with Stadium Arcadium.

I know it's long, but that's not a downside for me. And there are songs you might consider "filler", but they don't detract from the overall vibe of the album. And that's why I've continued to throw on SA over the years. It sets the cool vibe and its a slow burn that I can just enjoy for a couple hours without being upset that not every song is a banger. This probably also speaks to my listening style which is to generally listen to albums in their entirety rather than just selecting one or two songs.
---

I am here today, to talk about THE UPLIFT MOFO PARTY PLAN!
---

Mr Lasastryke posted...

...you changed your mind in the span of one minute?

I think I was trying to be cute.

---

ah ok
---

I'd still stand in line to listen to By the Way.


---

Wow this one blew up.

Really didn't expect to see BSSM get called "underrated" because, like others, I usually see it cited as one of their best.

Voted Stadium though.
---

Nominates David Bowie
---