Board 8 > English literature mafia topic 10: ask host for a good title

(+) Yeah! (+)

Playerlist (19 alive)
1. Pezloco
2. UltimaterializerX
3. Lea3Lea
4. Red13n
5. Benjamin
6. SBell (Obellisk)
7. Camarija
8. MZero
9. Sir Chris (DoomTheGyarados)
10. 5tarscream
11. Hbthebattle
12. Death (HtaeD)
13. Tom Bombadil
14. TheSultanOfSlam
15. Lopen
16. turbopuns3
17. Corrik
18. Lolo_Guru
19. Dowolf

Deadlist (2 dead)
LD1 - Luis_Sera aka The One Ring (Lord of the Rings), MAFIA Redirector.
KN1 - Scarechan (replaced eaedwards) aka J.D. Salinger (as portrayed on BoJack Horseman), TOWN Villager

With 19 players alive, it takes 10 votes to reach a majority. Day will end on Sunday, June 23th at 9PM EDT or if majority is reached ahead of time.

If you want votals, you're going to have to get that from the host
---

I play pretty much exclusively from my phone. It makes it a bit more hectic when going back over days. No one appreciates it tho.
---

This is my first time playing at length from phone

I hate it

But I get home this evening :D
---

I took a quick look to find who mentioned Red after Chris got the conch.

Lea3Lea posted...

Probably Red, so we can pretend that finally got more than 4 votes

I'm the best, obviously

Lolo_Guru posted...

Sure.
Not interested in red being lynched;

This was bad then and bad now.

Camarija posted...

Camarija posted...

red13n
MZero
5tarscream
luis_sera
lolo
Sultan

kk

dowolf off the list then

You have sultan off that list, as well as 5tarscream right?

So that would leave something like:

red13n
MZero
luis_sera
lolo

Of these 4 I dunno

Cam is either extremely good at Town, or scum. Because I could totally see this just being the entire scum team.

Lopen posted...

My current guess on the scumteam

Red13n
Scare
Hbthebattle
Tom Bombadil
Lea (not a chance that claim makes sense)

Cam as wolf actually makes some sort of sense

We'll see how well that pans out I guess.

Lopen was pushing Red before the conch, highly consistent

RogueNoble posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Lea who is it you want Chris to vote again?

Probably Red, he's too annoying to try to lynch. I don't think he even claimed until the final three last game. Wait, no, Puns, he's going to AFFC me, I know it.

Me again, another lynch I'll get no bragging points for because I didn't commit.

i uhhh kept failing at coming up with a subtitle so i figured i'd let someone else do it.

"lol"
---

Pez being on Red so early is a positive look, back when day one was a democracy. I hope Cam can finally rest now without fearing a physical violence fetish.

I mean, it is good that people were pushing red and such or mentioning him. But, I wouldn't overly look at that more than necessary. It is day 1 when people are making best estimations with very little info. And, it is possible certain people were suggesting things in order to get Chris not to listen to them.

I was fairly confident Chris would misfire if town, so I wanted him to shoot dowolf (who still isn't confirmed town btw) because at worse it was spent town power who could make people think they were confirmed town when they weren't or could actually end up being scum.

That said, Red self-admitting he went to Chris last night when he thought he was gonna get away with it, coupled with Chris' shot of Luis, coupled with Chris' play from hour 36 on of Day 1 has me pretty much locking him up as town.
---

Oh neat, we dont have to be cautious and proper we can just murder red.

God this is going to be a long game for scum. Please protect me always I am the best town power. On his game Chris strong like bull.
---

I've arrived at the hotel. Countdown to ROOMMATE POWERS has officially (arbitrarily) begun.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Oh neat, we dont have to be cautious and proper we can just murder red.

God this is going to be a long game for scum. Please protect me always I am the best town power. On his game Chris strong like bull.

Red likely poisoned you, Chris. Let's be honest.
---

Mafia DONE QUICK speed running lynching the scum team (WR)

Doctor nullifies poison btw. They did some action.
---

Other*
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Doctor nullifies poison btw. They did some action.

Every host does poison differently. Did you ask Han for the mechanics of how he handles poison to say that?
---

Are you guys actually putting stock into red giving a truthful result

Im going to bed. Youre welcome townies.

I have seen. Poisoned person gets told they are poisoned and it is unblockable. Multi use

I have seen poisoned person gets announced in game and is unblockable. Multi use

I have seen poisoner is multi use and poisoned person can be cured of poison by poison curer if cured night of the death (2nd night). Person not told if poisoned.

I have seen poisoner is multi use and poisoned person can be saved by doctor if saved any night it is applied or would go off. Person not informed.

I have seen poison is single use and person is not informed and it is incurable and unblockable.

I mean, if we are talking poison. It would be foolish to assume it can be doc saved.
---

Thanks 5tarscream!

So does anyone have a compelling reason why Lolo and Mzero are Town?

I put stock in scum targeting me yes. Red would not give a result tracker could bust.

I know he isnt roleblocker. Probably scanner
---

Okay i think im caught up?? Might have missed some things..

So corrik wanting all town powers to basically claim is super scummy

So red or 5tar have to be lying obviously and looks like the votes in red make more sense beacuse watcher is easy to fake i hightly doubt that 5tar would claim flavor cop outta the blue to just try to lynch red of he was scum right beacuse that would be dumb.

Furthermore i dont 100% understand the train on mzero but indo like the one on Tom

Outta most of the post ive seen corrik looks like the most scum player to me other then red whole thing...

Also corrik contradicts himself he has this whole argument agaisnt hb ( that was actually wrong) youre scum beacuse you have the claimed watcher at -1 then comes and does the same thing after realizing noone else was going to jump on the Mzero train
---

Tom Bombadil posted...

Obellisk posted...

Dowolf, we lynch a scum red and wake up day three without a damning scan on another scum member, I'll let you lynch me, how Bout that?

Can I help

Anything less would be uncivilized.
---

Man unblockable poison would make me sad. Let's root for not that.

Also Luis posted in such a way to lolo that I dont think is wolf theater.

Still with my gf but I will try to re-read red
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

beacuse watcher is easy to fake

Au contraire. Watcher is almost impossible to fake. That is why I am surprised Red would have chosen that claim as scum. Like, absolutely stunned.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I put stock in scum targeting me yes. Red would not give a result tracker could bust.

I know he isnt roleblocker. Probably scanner

Ok I more meant the seeing 1 person target you part

Corrik7 posted...

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

beacuse watcher is easy to fake

Au contraire. Watcher is almost impossible to fake. That is why I am surprised Red would have chosen that claim as scum. Like, absolutely stunned.

Then why you voting for red? And almost get him hammered??
---

Oh yeah fair. Clearly just trying to out power
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Corrik7 posted...

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

beacuse watcher is easy to fake

Au contraire. Watcher is almost impossible to fake. That is why I am surprised Red would have chosen that claim as scum. Like, absolutely stunned.

Then why you voting for red? And almost get him hammered??

Lol
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Man unblockable poison would make me sad. Let's root for not that.

Also Luis posted in such a way to lolo that I dont think is wolf theater.

Still with my gf but I will try to re-read red

I will be highly surprised if you are alive tomorrow tbqh. 6/21 most likely. I can't see scum not having an extra kill.

Possible dowolf was their extra kill and it backfired drastically. But, not buying it.

Would be cool if the extra kill was a sniper and you killed red before he could steady his rifle to get the shot off.
---

Sultan is a precious kouhai
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Corrik7 posted...

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

beacuse watcher is easy to fake

Au contraire. Watcher is almost impossible to fake. That is why I am surprised Red would have chosen that claim as scum. Like, absolutely stunned.

Then why you voting for red? And almost get him hammered??

Because he is scum. It is proven within a shadow of the doubt and red has already rolled over. That is why I am literally stunned. That's such a suicide claim.

Having to try and fake watches all game on targets that make sense and any old person being able to prove it wrong all game? He never could have gotten away with that. Ever. That was a claim to buy time. Not to not get lynched.
---

But you just said red would never claim that as scum! Dont you think a player of Reds caliber would know better?
---

You'd have to be an incredibly bold, highly attractive super genius to successfully fake being a Watcher as scum with no powers.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

But you just said red would never claim that as scum! Dont you think a player of Reds caliber would know better?

Are you even reading what is posted?
---

Lea3Lea posted...

You'd have to be an incredibly bold, highly attractive super genius to successfully fake being a Watcher as scum with no powers.

What do you think of all this lea? Why would a fantastic player like red claim that as scum then?? Im kind of counfused like i could understand it in a way that he could potentially fake it 1 day or maybe 2 but why would he do that like people said it be suicide?
---

Lea3Lea posted...

You'd have to be an incredibly bold, highly attractive super genius to successfully fake being a Watcher as scum with no powers.

If he was scum watcher, he would have revealed who visited Chris to try and defend himself. He would have had to. He will not flip scum watcher. He has absolutely zero idea who visited Chris or even how many people did.
---

Oh Red is probably just scum watcher who watched Red and knew that fake claiming a scanner is a good way to buy a couple of days against B8, at which point the best players would be dead and he'd either done enough damage or was left with a game who wouldn't question why he was still alive

Notes:

Cam is super cleared. Like, I will snap vote anyone who wastes my time on this slot anymore. Dude read thr game day 1 very well and gave me good targets and is effort ++

Lea is not clear. I was suspecting lea and so soft bussing red could have been poisoning the well.

Also I admit I want lea to be scum so my top 3 shot choices day 1 were all scum
---

Always the bridesmaid, never the bride

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

You'd have to be an incredibly bold, highly attractive super genius to successfully fake being a Watcher as scum with no powers.

What do you think of all this lea? Why would a fantastic player like red claim that as scum then?? Im kind of counfused like i could understand it in a way that he could potentially fake it 1 day or maybe 2 but why would he do that like people said it be suicide?

He was trying to buy time or felt he was caught and was just trying to get some powers to out themselves to try and defend him before it blew up.

His claim was a suicide claim and I have never seen Red do it as scum. MI is the heroball suicide claim gambler as scum (with protection claims so he doesn't have to keep supplying info). Blade had been known for a doozy claim here and there as scum. But, red? It is literally jaw dropping. But, here we are. He is scum.

I mean, the fact it is so astonishing is why I was defending him so hard. I never thought he would do that.

Question is... What was he trying to buy time for. His flip should help regarding that.
---

Actually watcher is incredibly easy to fake as red just demonstrated. Just give scans that implausibly give no info, and cowards will fear lynching you because OMG it's WATCHER it's SO POWERFUL
---

I don't think it's complicated

Red saw he was doomed

Claimed the role and action with the literal highest potential for outing maximum power

It's not deeper than that

Lopen posted...

Actually watcher is incredibly easy to fake as red just demonstrated. Just give scans that implausibly give no info, and cowards will fear lynching you because OMG it's WATCHER it's SO POWERFUL

Takes literally one wrong thing to die any day on any target. It is not easy at all. It is downright impossible. And would require so many things falling in place as luck to justify it. Especially without a roleblock excuse.
---

If everyone thinks this why is day still going on?
---

Mzero hasn't claimed yet

I was about to be offended but then I realized despite being ok with pressuring other people I never unvoted red so I guess my heart wasn't so charitable...!
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

If everyone thinks this why is day still going on?

1. It could be Chris' last day to give input. 2. I don't think an early hammer will lead to an earlier day 3. Just a longer night. If we wanted to early hammer, we needed to do it last night ya bunch of chickens.
---

DO NOT END DAY EARLY. I MAY BE DEAD TOMORROW. GIVE ME MAX TIME TO PICK APART RED AND GIVE YOU INFO.

... caps
---

Sultan take a chill pill my dude we can still have fun

Plus if we go straight into night phase we might miss the chance for roommate powers who knows!! We can't risk it

Lea3Lea posted...

Mzero 180ing his read of Corrik because Corrik is going after him is hilariously transparent.

Try actually reading my post. It's because of the reasons he's going after me. I didn't call you or Ben or anyone else scum for going after me. It's specific to Corrik
---