What exactly is suspicious about not talking about the corrik stuff, anyway?
Makes it seem like you wanted to keep your hands clean in case corrik targeted me. (especially if corrik is town, scum would love for corrik to do so) It was more a comprehensive list anyway. But hearing you say that you didnt want Corrik to use it would have sounded better before his deadline.
---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3
Corrik was acting extremely theatrical with the gladiator stuff and his threat of targeting you with it. I'm pretty sure I just dismissed it because I figured it was most likely him just trying to ruffle your feathers and see if other people might chime in to defend/attack you. I simply felt no compulsion to join in on it.
Color me unsurprised that we have not seen a gladiator ability used today.
Asks me to use my power start of day 2 on Ulti first post ---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3
It is h2h when we are the only likely lynches today. You dont think Corrik or MZero are town? I mean surely they both are. If MZero isnt Miller thats a hell of a risk to claim first post and just gamble that there isnt going to be a counter. It basically confirms him as town and same for Corrik really.
Asks me to use my power start of day 2 on Ulti first post
Oh my fucking god.
Corrik, seriously, I'm out.
I said this earlier but couldn't resist 5tar's amazing wall.
I'm town. Your play is self-centered and you put way too much weight on little things people say about you that in the grand scheme of the game don't actually indicate much.
I've called my shot. It's on you now to grow a pair and move beyond fear of losing to me or red.
Literally all of town is telling you the answer. Swallow your pride and blast this babbling noob.
I'm out. I will check the game again saturday night.
Just caught up and have a few minutes before lessons. I can't beleive we're literally at the same point. Like we've spent hours just going round in circles.
I thought originally scare was white knighting death because of the timing of his posts and because he jumped on a 5tar must be scum because he's being too soft despite the fact that I wasn't being soft. Death was. Han has offered nothing in way of any read on me other than to say yeah I agree with Scare's terrible read based on the opposite of what was happening. SBell I actually still think is playing poor town and is focusing on me because he's worried that he is himself going to get lynched and instead of looking at the people driving the votes on him he's looking at me because I argued with him a lot. Ulti is starting to look more peculiar the more he posts. First of all begging Corrik to use the dayvig on him doesn't make sense, if you think he is town then why are you trying to call him out and expose his claim that he was using to exert pressure on people he was suspicious of. Like in what way does asking for the dayvig help the other town players. Nobody has 100% reads on D1 even the best players. Han himself even admitted he makes mistakes sometimes like he is with me. Red and IGCD it's hard to tell for different reasons. IGCD has basically just shown up to throw a vote with little reasoning behind I think they're scum. Red has been patchy which is explainable by his Disney visit but also gives him a ready made excuse to hide out and lurk if he wants too I wouldn't push for a lynch on either of them yet because there simply isn't enough evidence of them being scum for me to push yet but I will be watching both closely going forward. Pez I had as a hard town lock bnecause I bought his reasoning and explanation for Tom suspicions and more importantly he stated his reason but also said that's my read you should all make your own decisions and I feel like he was posting to help town make their own decisions instead of trying to tell everyone do this now. Death I'm in the air about. I feel like my reads on him are so heavily influenced by what I think of others. Like his play with Corrik seems to me to be more town but the scare thing is still confusing me. Like if Scare isn't white knighting Death then I have no idea what on earth is going through his Scare's head.
TL;DR Ulti leaning Scum. Han leaning scum. Scare is scum. Tom i'm not sure about he seems off I'll agree with that. Death I'm also not sure about at the moment. IGCD, red, Mzero no idea their activity hasn't really given me anything to go on. Panth, pez, corrik, ea, sbell I think are town.
Read the paragraph. He lists every last town to talk about and not a single scum besides someone explaining on Tom for his read on them. All 13 town with thoughts. None of the scum. But lists them below in his leans. ##vote: 5tar ---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3
I'm town. Your play is self-centered and you put way too much weight on little things people say about you that in the grand scheme of the game don't actually indicate much.
And then pun with the flair for dramatics to Instantly make me rethink my vote. ---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3
Pez is tom sill only town because corrik capitalized a word in topic 1?
turbopuns3 posted...
pezloco posted...
turbopuns3 posted...
Pez is tom sill only town because corrik capitalized a word in topic 1?
Didn't I also mention I liked his posts from early this morning? But yeah the way he went after Corrik sounded very Town Tom to me.
You and Tom both have reacted with this indignation like every player will have read 100% of posts lol.
Not saying it's a bad thing just, you don't have to get defensive if someone asks a question you've clearly covered already. Sometimes if everyone's here at the moment it's just easier to ask and have someone say it off the top of their head than to go digging back through 8 pages to find it.
HMMM well given this I doubt Tom's lynch will get enough traction at this point.
##Unvote
but who will it be
Within 20 minutes of the update and with his preferred Lynch down by 1 to the vote leader, puns jumps off tom. ---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3
Good afternoon. I should mostly be here until deadline, maybe with a break for supper in there somewhere.
First off, Han you unvoted SBell to vote for Scare, but you noted that you felt like SBell was setting himself up to bus Scare. If that's the case, wouldn't SBell be the higher priority target?
Second, let me draw some attention to a pair of posts by 5tar.
This was to Pez:
5tarscream posted...
So you simply think they are mistaken. Well I mean you think Im scum and Im not but when I flip town youll just dismiss this as oh I guess they were wrong and give them a pass?
This was to SBell and was noticed by a few players: 5tarscream posted...
SBell youre making a mistake and youre playing right into scum hands doing it. Remember this if I get lynched D1. Make sure you are 100% certain that in the scummiest person here and when I flip town feel absolutely horrible for putting my name on the board and allowing scum to just slowly drive the votes up
People noted the latter post looks like he knows SBell is town. The former also gives me the sense he knows Pez is town. There's no suspicion that these thought processes are scummy and that's why they don't add up, just certainty that it's mistaken town play. You can argue either of them just being addressed to a town read, sure, but put together it really feels like 5tar was trying a little too hard to appeal to what he knows are town mindsets.
Now, Ulti. I've asked this before and got no answer so here it is again: You have said you think Death is trying to figure the game out and noted that he's different than he is as scum, which you describe as "faking activity". In this game Death has gotten into lengthy arguments with people that suspect him and questioned a lot, but not really taken many strong positions without them being coaxed out. This feels like faking activity to me. I want to know what you think I'm missing (this could be directed to anyone who thinks Death is town, actually). Death has raised a couple of points I liked here and there but I don't see where he's trying to do much with them.
I could go for either of these two (Death or 5tar). By extension I don't like the SBell lynch due to 5tar's comment to him. This Scare lynch feels like it's grown up pretty suddenly but I like Han and Puns and don't see how Pez could be scum at this point, and am slightly leaning town on Ulti so I don't think it's a scum push. Scare has largely done under the radar for me beyond checking his posts for whether they add up with what 5tar was saying about him or not, I'll have to look into him more I think.
Still don't like IGCD, for everyone saying he does this kind of thing as town, have you ever seen him as scum to know he doesn't also do it that way? It's not so much the votes (I have seen him troll the game with his vote as town before) as some of the things he's said, he's commented a few times in ways that try to make it seem like he's been more relevant than he has (saying he'll be busy soon when he wasn't posting before that, saying nothing is being said to look like there wasn't anything going on worth posting about). I also feel like MZero has vanished from the game. I know timezones and all but did he even post last night or whenever his last period of being awake would have been?
---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3
The nice thing about an IGCD lynch is, even if we're wrong, how much are we losing, with how little he talks? Town 5tar and Sbell would be a loss to town, and Red and Scare....CAN be good when they show up. Same logic also applies to MZero with the bonus of only losing a miller, but like I said I think that's one to look at a day or two from now.
The guy everyone thought was new would be a loss to town if lynched. While red and scare just CAN be good.
While he is also voting 5tar still. ---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3
I'd prefer to lynch Tom or red at this point. I don't like Tom saying IGCD costs us nothing if he's town. Even a poor town is better than a scum. There are town deaths that can provide insight into scum moves but IGCD's isn't one of them at this time.
Tom Bombadil posted...
5tarscream posted...
Even a poor town is better than a scum.
right but I'd rather be wrong about and mislynch a poor town than a strong town
I think Death leaving his vote on Red right after Han and Puns said the Red train was a trap is ballsy enough to make him less of a focus to me.
##Unvote ##Vote: 5tar
I am going back to this and am bothered by the way the game just forgot about him. His thought process has not felt like coherent scum hunting and those posts to Pez and SBell feel like perspective slips, though SBell is starting to give me pause with his argument about IGCD and Ulti both being scum if one is. There was a lot of attention on him and suddenly everyone forgot and there doesn't seem to much reason for it. Why?
I still haven't seen what makes the Scare lynch appeal to people beyond what Pez said, which I disagree with but at least it's an answer. Not sold on Red either, he got fluffier today I think but prior his posts had a decent enough amount of content to make it plausible he's just busy with the Disney World thing. IGCD looks like an alright lynch but Tom's vote on him was very opportunistic and makes me rethink it. I'm getting pretty wary of Tom at this point.
I feel like this day is starting to boil down to repeating reads without the explanation to make them persuasive.
Didn't vote him earlier when he was in Lynch position. Votes him when he is behind 4 other lynches and voteless. Dangerous train potential tho.
8 to lynch early, 11pm edt 8 pm pdt otherwise, 40 min left
Panthera posted...
People. Lynch 5tar. He made a big deal of suspecting Scare because he thought Scare was attacking hm to defend Death. His logic made it clear they had to be scum together. Then as time passed he started softening on Death, but not on Scare even though his logic required him to still think of Death as scum to suspect Scare. When I called him on this he said acknowledged it, but never explained what thought process led him to still suspect Scare. And now that I check I see he never even voted either. His only vote is on Red, after the floodgates had been opened. He was very sure for ages Death and Scare were scum, but never cared to vote and didn't seem to be totally sure why he thought Scare was to begin with.
And if you think Pez and/or SBell are town, you should really be feeling like he slipped perspective a bit in trying to make them question themselves. The post to SBell in particular. If SBell isn't a scum read for you that should be a very hard post to ignore.
UltimaterializerX posted...
Not a fan of the 5tar lynch. Reeks of Board 8 picking on an outsider.
eaedwards6400 posted...
5tar isnt an outside he's been here. He predicts on my TEW diary lol
You've been played. I hope that puns is the only scum left and it isn't him and red. That way you at least have a shot at getting him tomorrow. Corrik gladiated town then lynched town vanilla with the game on the line. Well played Corrik.
I actually can't believe you're pinning this on day 1 reads. After you already fucked up by jumping the gun with the Ulti gladiate. D1 you thought these people were scum and they weren't. I stayed on Tom after Pez cleared him, I was the one pushing Panth all day yesterday and caught the flavour slip. MZero/red please tell me you two at least aren't buying this ridiculous 5tar bussed Tom and Panth to try and go solo story.
Puns started to set this up yesterday he half heartedly tried to defend Panth in the off chance that he came back. He removed his own vote from scum at -1,
As is standard practice. Literally what town is supposed to do.
Literally the opposite of what puns is doing right now because Im not scum and hes not town.
I repeat this because Im right and I want people to remember 5tar Town Vanilla Puns Scum Godfather.
I have a reason i am going to keep to myself for now to think Corrik is town, but I like him less with me and ulti in his scumpile. That's potentially standard corrik misdirection.
Reason?
I got to go back and check context, I remember this but its been awhile. ---
"First thing that crosses my mind: I didn't get any GameFAQs Karma yesterday." Math Murderer after getting his appendix removed.