Board 8 > Wwe mafia Topic 5 suicide dive!

(+) Yeah! (+)

So ulti fakeclaimed scum cop scan on puns.
Igcd claims track ulti to scare.
Ulti backs claim up to original vanilla claim.

So ulti or igcd is scum.

If ulti is scum there is probable reason to buy igcd as town til gamestate dictates otherwise.

If ulti is town igcd has to be scum but it would make this play essentially a suicide trade from scum for ulti.

Or crazy play where they planned it and are both scum.

has it been explicitly mentioned that if igcd is scum we are still in a state of 0 town scanning claims

turbopuns3 posted...

has it been explicitly mentioned that if igcd is scum we are still in a state of 0 town scanning claims

Yes I mentioned it. And someone said maybe cop doesn't counter tracker. And someone else said that makes for a very powerful town. And maybe one or two other comments after that.
---

cop + tracker in 15 isn't what I'd call very powerful but it would likely mean a godfather/ninja + roleblocker

Ninja wasnt even trending for most of my mafia years.
Then again games were bigger, so sometimes you'd have three scanners in one game.
---

pezloco posted...

Let's say the we lynch Ulti and he indeed flips scum. Then MZero's miller claim gets really fishy. If Ulti gets lynched, then that's likely because we don't have another scanner countering IGCD's claim. If we don't have another scanner, then we don't have a cop. If we don't have a cop, why do we have a miller?

This is absolutely bullshit and looks like trying to out the cop. There can be a tracker and a cop. Also, there can be a miller and no cop. There is nothing to suggest there is not a cop just because it was not countered. A good cop would NOT have countered there. And IGCD didn't really counter, he revealed a guilty scan.
---

5tarscream posted...

I find it highly unlikely that theyre all scum. Its just too much a stretch to have one guy lie to bus another guys lie to cover another bus attempt. Like who the fuck would go that deep with their fake out.
Id say its more likely that Corrik would be the third over IGCD. He was all over that puns kill with Ulti which if it played out makes them look great. Corrik 180d real quick but then that could be explained by him believing Ulti until he was caught.
I think it could definitely have been a bus attempt that got derailed. Also Ulti is really adamant about puns being town which if Ulti is scum is a massive red flag.
Pez, panth and death. You guys are my strongest town reads right now. If ulti flips scum why do you think he is so adamant about puns being town

I 180'd because new information was presented and I am town. Bad argument. Noted.
---

MZero11 posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

cop+tracker+weak bp+presumably other defense is kinda a lot for 15, isn't it?

Maybe, but the other roles could be weakened just like the bp was

Depends on the scum team. If scum is high power, so is town. And vice versa.
---

5tarscream posted...

MZero11 posted...

htaeD posted...

MZero11 posted...

htaeD posted...

Also IGCD faking this reminds me of a past game where someone sold a scummate out for entirely shortsighted gains.

That said, IGCDs claim is really hard to fake/pull off for more than one night.

I wonder who that was

Ohright.

We still wont somehow, didnt we?

Yeah cause Corrik is a beast

In hindsight I played that terribly but the fact that it was so terrible allowed Corrik to bus me and turn the tide

This is why Im cautious of Corrik he is super capable of jumping all over Ulti for fucking up bussing him and even have Ulti go too far in a confrontation. Ulti getting modkilled is the same as him getting lynched but makes it look less likely that he and Corrik are buddies

You should always be cautious of me. CorrikFear is real. I am the best scum player on this board by far. But, let's deduce scum logically here and not succumb to undue paranoia.

I have given you a 4 scum list. I have told you why Puns is still not town if Ulti flips scum. I have given you arguments on all of them as scum besides eaed really. And I have explained how IGCD has to be town and Ulti has to be scum. Can we actually listen to my posts and see if they make sense logically? Ignoring them and stating what I say 80 posts later for your epiphany doesn't make me think ur town.

If ur town, you should wanna work together. I have told you why Ulti has to be scum.

Is this a reminder of last game when I told people how Cam had to be Town Vanilla logically and no one would listen? I know I was scum last game, but you should be taking my arguments and listening to the logic.

Whether you think I may be Town or Scum, my logic is completely sound.
---

Also, Red not able to logically point out who is scum there is a big red flag. No way he is that devoid of logically piecing that together. Barely says anything either.

Red has not been helpful this entire game. Scumtells going crazy.
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77763661
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77763702

My bad this one
---

Tagamania
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Tagamania

---