Board 8 > Red Dead Redemption 2 Mafia: Topic 7 - I'll Keep Her In Black, On Your Behalf

LurkerFAQs, Active Database ( 12.31.2018-present ), DB1, DB2, DB3 DB4
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 9
Suprak the Stud
03/15/19 3:19:31 AM
1
Not In Black (THE LIVING):
1) Benjamin3740
2) HanOfTheNekos
3) Hbthebattle
4) htaeD
5) IfGodCouldDie
6) MasterZeldaGuy (replaced Pirate_Harris)
7) Meow1000
8) MZero11
9) OPShaft (replaced Pendragon)
10) Pjbasis
11) Shaduln (replaced eaedwards6400)
12) TotallyNotMI

In Black (THE DEAD):
KN1 - red13n: ???
KD2 - TheSultanOfSlam - Colm O'Driscoll, SCUM Jack-of-all-kills
LD2 - Ashethan - Andrew Milton, SCUM Detective
KN2 - ScareChan - Charles Smith, TOWN Watcher

Sbell has been kidnapped!

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch! Day ends at 8 PM CST tonight!

---
Moops?
"I thought you were making up diseases? That's spontaneous dental hydroplosion."
Obellisk
03/15/19 9:45:21 AM
2
Tag
---
(\____/)
( SBell )
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 9:47:23 AM
3
Regardless, I feel like there's so much evidence against you death. You can hand wave and say that it's all explained, but it's not.

I'd vote you here but I don't know what votals are actually at.
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 9:48:30 AM
4
Shaduln posted...
htaeD posted...
Shaduln posted...
I feel like i'm watching MI play a Phoenix Wright game.


I feel like you could be saying more. (No offense)

Like what? I have a vote down, explained it, and have nothing else to add. Not my fault you just don't like where my vote is.

Town doesn't have to convince scum that their scum!

Who did you replace again? Pendragon? I'm having a hard time keeping these replaces straight
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 9:48:56 AM
5
Oops, you replaced eaed. It's like two posts above me. lolme
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
htaeD
03/15/19 9:49:25 AM
6
TotallyNotMI posted...
Regardless, I feel like there's so much evidence against you death. You can hand wave and say that it's all explained, but it's not.

I'd vote you here but I don't know what votals are actually at.


It fucking is explained
You liar.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Hbthebattle
03/15/19 9:49:32 AM
7
Well, lets look at the facts. First of all is that scum likely has a power player, someone experienced with mafia who would want to kill Red ASAP. This looks worse for Death than, for example, Blade, because Blade didnt play P5 Mafia where Red was dominant.
---
Patience.
htaeD
03/15/19 9:50:00 AM
8
TotallyNotMI posted...
Shaduln posted...
htaeD posted...
Shaduln posted...
I feel like i'm watching MI play a Phoenix Wright game.


I feel like you could be saying more. (No offense)

Like what? I have a vote down, explained it, and have nothing else to add. Not my fault you just don't like where my vote is.

Town doesn't have to convince scum that their scum!

Who did you replace again? Pendragon? I'm having a hard time keeping these replaces straight


But I am town, so he does have to do that.

Shad, you;re gonna be in so much trouble when I flip. Haha
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 9:50:18 AM
9
Hbthebattle posted...
Well, lets look at the facts. First of all is that scum likely has a power player, someone experienced with mafia who would want to kill Red ASAP. This looks worse for Death than, for example, Blade, because Blade didnt play P5 Mafia where Red was dominant.

...this is adorable.

Blade and Red have been playing Mafia together for more than a decade.
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
htaeD
03/15/19 9:50:29 AM
10
Hbthebattle posted...
Well, lets look at the facts. First of all is that scum likely has a power player, someone experienced with mafia who would want to kill Red ASAP. This looks worse for Death than, for example, Blade, because Blade didnt play P5 Mafia where Red was dominant.


Are you kidding me?
Blade probably knows red better than me, han or ben combined!
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 9:51:25 AM
11
There is no evidence, just unfortunate circumstances.
Do not try to hide behind lies after my death.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Shaduln
03/15/19 9:51:28 AM
12
htaeD posted...
TotallyNotMI posted...
Shaduln posted...
htaeD posted...
Shaduln posted...
I feel like i'm watching MI play a Phoenix Wright game.


I feel like you could be saying more. (No offense)

Like what? I have a vote down, explained it, and have nothing else to add. Not my fault you just don't like where my vote is.

Town doesn't have to convince scum that their scum!

Who did you replace again? Pendragon? I'm having a hard time keeping these replaces straight


But I am town, so he does have to do that.

Shad, you;re gonna be in so much trouble when I flip. Haha

And death just called me town lol
---
Emperor of Board 8
Posted using GameFlux
Hbthebattle
03/15/19 9:51:40 AM
13
Ok, jeez. I retract that bit.
---
Patience.
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 9:52:00 AM
14
I used the wrong they're and it's killing me that I can't edit it :(
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
htaeD
03/15/19 9:52:42 AM
15
Shaduln posted...
htaeD posted...
TotallyNotMI posted...
Shaduln posted...
htaeD posted...
Shaduln posted...
I feel like i'm watching MI play a Phoenix Wright game.


I feel like you could be saying more. (No offense)

Like what? I have a vote down, explained it, and have nothing else to add. Not my fault you just don't like where my vote is.

Town doesn't have to convince scum that their scum!

Who did you replace again? Pendragon? I'm having a hard time keeping these replaces straight


But I am town, so he does have to do that.

Shad, you;re gonna be in so much trouble when I flip. Haha

And death just called me town lol


No actually MI did.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 9:53:57 AM
16
Also Shad

Shaduln posted...
htaeD posted...
I mean you're not wrong. But thats not the answer I was looking for.
I am just saying, you should already be thinking about what changes for you when I flip town. Who looks worse or better?

Boy people are making weird declarations this game. Why would I be thinking about what to do if you flip town if I'm making the assumption that you're scum?

To answer why i'm voting you, after MI pointed out your interactions near the end of the day, it really looked like you were trying to help ashe out.


This is quite literally not an answer to my question there.
I will flip town. that is reality. What will you do, once I flip town. If you dont even want to think ahead, you're not trying very hard.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 9:54:29 AM
17
You wouldnt normally think it. But I am asking you to.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Shaduln
03/15/19 9:56:11 AM
18
But you see, in my opinion you're wasting my time by me doing that. I entertain that option, and then you flip scum. Whoops.

If you flip town, I have 24 hours to reevaluate. But that doesn't seem likely atm.
---
Emperor of Board 8
Posted using GameFlux
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 9:56:33 AM
19
If we're playing these kind of imagining games.

Death, imagine someone else, let's say Mzero, had all of the posts interacting with Ashe that you have. Then you ISO'd Ashe after he flipped scum.

How do you react?
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
htaeD
03/15/19 9:57:13 AM
20
I mean I realize my lynch is never going to stop being hotly desired by almost everyone.
But that doesnt mean I am gonna take the accusations quietly and not yell.
..
I need to get back to work though <.<
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 9:59:01 AM
21
Yes I would suspect him too MI. But what the hell does that kind of argument do for me?

Shaduln posted...
But you see, in my opinion you're wasting my time by me doing that. I entertain that option, and then you flip scum. Whoops.

If you flip town, I have 24 hours to reevaluate. But that doesn't seem likely atm.


I get that logic.
I just like to have opinions noted down before my lynch happens. To give scum less time to think off excuses and such.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Hbthebattle
03/15/19 9:59:27 AM
22
But my point is Death has looked the worst out of the power players. He stapled himself to Sbell Day 1. He looked suspicious in his choice to unvote Ashe (Speaking of which, we really forgot about Pen/his replacement) and hes far pushover than necessary in his attempts to get Ashe to claim.

My question to you, Death, is that if you are town, who do you think the Scum Power Player is?
---
Patience.
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 9:59:45 AM
23
htaeD posted...
Yes I would suspect him too MI. But what the hell does that kind of argument do for me?

I feel like you are acting like we're all ridiculous for suspecting you.
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
htaeD
03/15/19 10:01:06 AM
24
I am not even assuming there has to be one.

But in order of suspicion Ben > han > Blade > MI (and thats only because of his role)
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 10:02:19 AM
25
TotallyNotMI posted...
htaeD posted...
Yes I would suspect him too MI. But what the hell does that kind of argument do for me?

I feel like you are acting like we're all ridiculous for suspecting you.


I know you arent. I feel like you are tho. Its a perspective thing.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 10:04:53 AM
26
Am I even a powerplayer? Is also my question, honestly.
At least I can take that praise with me now.

Hbthebattle posted...
But my point is Death has looked the worst out of the power players. He stapled himself to Sbell Day 1. He looked suspicious in his choice to unvote Ashe (Speaking of which, we really forgot about Pen/his replacement) and hes far pushover than necessary in his attempts to get Ashe to claim.


Also. Stapled?
Pushover?
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Hbthebattle
03/15/19 10:05:41 AM
27
htaeD posted...
I am not even assuming there has to be one.

But in order of suspicion Ben > han > Blade > MI (and thats only because of his role)

Why would Red be killed first then? Why would Sultans claim be tailor made for tracker and not cop?
---
Patience.
htaeD
03/15/19 10:06:16 AM
28
Really the worst thing is that all this tunneling is almost destroying my motivation to even care about the game. Why ISO stuff when I am going to die anyway and all..

Selfish I know.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Hbthebattle
03/15/19 10:06:18 AM
29
Oh uh, pushover was supposed to be overzealous
---
Patience.
Shaduln
03/15/19 10:07:20 AM
30
Oh my post was eaten.

Why am I specifically in trouble if you flip town?
---
Emperor of Board 8
Posted using GameFlux
htaeD
03/15/19 10:07:55 AM
31
Hbthebattle posted...
htaeD posted...
I am not even assuming there has to be one.

But in order of suspicion Ben > han > Blade > MI (and thats only because of his role)

Why would Red be killed first then? Why would Sultans claim be tailor made for tracker and not cop?


A lot of players know red. IGCD, Mzero, PJ

Not sure what the second part matters. I trust every player here is smart enough to help sultan if they had to.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 10:08:49 AM
32
Hbthebattle posted...
Oh uh, pushover was supposed to be overzealous


again
if I were scum
Why would I not do that stuff on the scumboard?
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 10:27:39 AM
33
I already answered that question before!

But I'll see if HB has an answer before I give mine.
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
IfGodCouldDie
03/15/19 10:29:52 AM
34
MasterZeldaGuy posted...
IfGodCouldDie posted...
How do you suppose I would have gone about doing that?

By at least trying to redirect the kill?

And targetting someone I assume is scum doesn't have that possibility?
---
Mind post. XBL:Cyanide Sucker PSN:Paters1 IGN:SuperPattyCakes FC: SW-1615-6159-5504
htaeD
03/15/19 10:34:32 AM
35
TotallyNotMI posted...
I already answered that question before!

But I'll see if HB has an answer before I give mine.

I know.
Still doesnt apply to me. But thats all I can say
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 10:49:25 AM
36
Hey @MasterZeldaGuy I have a question for you when you're around.
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 10:50:45 AM
37
Ehhh maybe I don't.

I mean I do.

But I don't know if I should actually ask it because I don't know if I'd be revealing something if you're actually town.

Hm.
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
Shaduln
03/15/19 10:51:16 AM
38
I don't know death's reasoning for thinking i'm scum other than assuming it's because I wasn't active D2 and now i'm voting him.
---
Emperor of Board 8
Posted using GameFlux
htaeD
03/15/19 10:59:05 AM
39
I dont know either, honestly.
I just feel that I am behaving so much like my townself that someone voting me is clearly not trying to see that and is scum for it.
And your vote is the one I like the least. Even less than Bens
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Shaduln
03/15/19 11:03:03 AM
40
htaeD posted...
And your vote is the one I like the least. Even less than Bens

Yes but why?
---
Emperor of Board 8
Posted using GameFlux
htaeD
03/15/19 11:03:53 AM
41
Maybe its unfair. But because it had the least lead-up to it.
Tell ya what, I will give you an ISO when I am back home.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 11:07:04 AM
42
Ben too, since he brought it up.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
htaeD
03/15/19 11:07:46 AM
43
But most scum are probably just sitting on the sidelines doing nothing.
Which would still be like 2 at best.
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
OpShaft
03/15/19 11:10:52 AM
44
Hbthebattle posted...
But my point is Death has looked the worst out of the power players. He stapled himself to Sbell Day 1. He looked suspicious in his choice to unvote Ashe (Speaking of which, we really forgot about Pen/his replacement) and hes far pushover than necessary in his attempts to get Ashe to claim.

My question to you, Death, is that if you are town, who do you think the Scum Power Player is?


I dont think anyone forgot about me, they would just rather go after scum than town.

By all means, distract from the death lynch and bring it on over to me. There won't be anything that I've done that you can say is scummy, so you'll just be going after an inactive player that, if you're assuming he was scum, would have ditched out on his team or given up as the only scum left.

But people seem smart in this game, so I probably wont get lynched unless it's a special and I get stubborn and refuse to play along.
---
I lost the game.
Shaduln
03/15/19 11:15:27 AM
45
That said, if Tange just coasts the rest of the day, I have no problem going back on that lynch.
---
Emperor of Board 8
Posted using GameFlux
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 11:20:58 AM
46
Shaduln posted...
That said, if Tange just coasts the rest of the day, I have no problem going back on that lynch.

Truth
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
htaeD
03/15/19 11:22:59 AM
47
I will admit, OPShaft is a refreshing change of pace
---
3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice
Meow1000
03/15/19 11:31:55 AM
48
Hbthebattle posted...
From my perspective, Death is the likeliest person to be scums power player, but that doesnt preclude there being two- Death/Ben, Death/Blade, Ben/Blade- all of these are options. And then theres Han vs. IGCD who I still cant agree with both being town. Of the two, Han looks townier.

Oh yeah that reminds me

Right at the end of day 2 you called me town and never explained it after.

Explain kthx.
---
Never underestimate the power of stupidity in numbers. ~War13104
Never stoop to the level of idiots. They will drag you down and beat you with experience.
OpShaft
03/15/19 11:36:54 AM
49
htaeD posted...
I will admit, OPShaft is a refreshing change of pace


I kinda like this, but I feel like it might drag me down with you.
---
I lost the game.
TotallyNotMI
03/15/19 11:40:38 AM
50
OpShaft posted...
htaeD posted...
I will admit, OPShaft is a refreshing change of pace


I kinda like this, but I feel like it might drag me down with you.

Eh, assuming Death flips scum anything he says today I would consider WIFOM at best and not delve into it.

D1 posts would be a lot more meaningful in my mind
---
I'm not sure who this MI guy is but he sounds sexy.
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 9