Board 8 > Sir Chris Music Mafia topic 9: Time for a party....

(+) Yeah! (+)

a NINJASEXPARTY
---

1. TheSultanOfSlam
4. ColZach
7. Mzero11
8. Sheep007
10. ChaosTonyV4
11. turbopuns2
12. Leafeon13N (red13N/Red)
13. Forceful_Dragon
14. DoubleTangicide
16. HanOfTheNekos
17. Crescent-Moon
18. Edumey
19. ScareChan
20. Benjamin3740
21. htaeD (Death)

[LD1] - Alakazam, MAFIA Vanilla
[KN1] - Masterplum, Role Unknown
[LD2] - Leo, MAFIA Detective
[KN2] - Corrik, TOWN Bodyguard
[LD3] - IfGodCouldDie, TOWN Vanilla
[KN3] - Panthera, TOWN Jack of All Trades
[KN3] - Eaed, TOWN Jailkeeper

It is now Day 4. With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch. Day ends 11:00 EDT on Monday. Go!
---

When was the last time han was town?

zach is not confirmed, no

but I feel likely town
---

since this is music mafia

as much as ff7 is maybe my favorite 'classic' final fantasy

I think 8 had better music
---

Town or Townie Points (like brownie points get it, its a pun and this is a game) YOU DECIDE

Crescent-Moon posted...

Ok Leo just claimed scum I guess that's all we needed to know.

Especially since it's long since been established that Scare took back his claim of any sort of scan, and Panthera just blew it on his reaction.

Leo isn't claiming to try to play us and draw the day towards him instead of towards Panthera, if I had to guess.

---

Crescent-Moon posted...

Starting games at midnight is bad. How am I supposed to be cute and catty when I'm already passing out for the day?

Didn't Tony make weird/check in posts a lot on day 1 in the previous game? I do not really see why this one stands out in comparison. It's also pretty similar to a post FD made in Blade's game. I feel like there's nothing to read out of it except that he hasn't posted much overall yet.

The difference in Plum and my responses to the millers are mildly interesting. There was a nonsensical passivity from him about it, like he didn't really care.

In PW Mafia we had heavily considered faking or joking about miller early and Puns was on that team. Han was also there. My immediate feeling was that Puns decided to play cute this time after getting destroyed in PW.

Have not had the time to really get everything in my head yet but will tonight.

Alright it was her second post. I just didnt like the line about starting at Midnight. "Cute and catty" doesn't mean anything to mafia, so it seemed like she mentioned it because she was worried showing up late looked bad or something.

Honestly this whole time I've been lazy with reading Crescent because I'm used to scum and town her being pretty distinct. But she made it clear those were out of game circumstances affecting the last game, and the other time I saw her as scum she subbed into a team that was getting destroyed and most of town was confirmed.
---

red13n posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

My list of people who don't look good are Panth, Sultan, Tange, and IGCD.

My list of people who worry me are eaed, red, and to a lesser extent, Leo.

Zach has seemed really Scummy to me, but this I have said already.

Of all the posts han makes day 1, this is by far the strangest to me. 3 lines to say essentially the same thing is just weird.

That said, he put up a really weak defense of zam. Like, really weak. I'm not sure what to think of it but my first instinct is I actually would expect him to go harder to defend him if he were a scumbuddy. They were awkward though, to say the least.

---

ScareChan posted...

Red I think you are the one with most han experience so I am going to need you to iso him

I would like your thoughts too puns

Oh my tired brain read that as you asking red for thoughts on me, too

Now I see you meant for me to respond

I'll have to iso tomorrow. But han hasn't triggered any scum signals for me. Maybe I've neglected him too much

yeah Im getting tired of reading so I think I will stop for now, may do more later but going to step aside from recapping
---

ScareChan posted...

since this is music mafia

as much as ff7 is maybe my favorite 'classic' final fantasy

I think 8 had better music

I agree! Unpopular opinion, but Force Your Way is my favorite FF boss theme.

Though I think 6 has the best. Mainly because the SNES soundchip aged so much better than the PS1. I hooked up my SNES to surround sound speakers and turned on FF6. Ohhhhh man.
---

Rats

My picks for scum

Red, Han, Ben seem likely

Scare has been rubbing me the wrong way for awhile, maybe I need to reread some days but a lot of that Panth pressure came from scare IIRC

Crescent is still too indecisive for my liking

Puns is puns and I could see him bamboozling us

Sultan seems scummier today than yesterday. I would take the risk and lynch here.

Mzero has been scanned so I feel like its okay but the longer sheep is alive the more suspicious it is

Tony is town

FD is town

Tange I have a neutral read on but I am feeling townie

Edumey would be my wildcard lynch. I dont want to lynch him, but I could see it.

Death is in this game? Lol jk, more skating by. Inactivity is annoying.

Goodnight yall

ok good because i too am also tired. The scrolling was starting to hurt my eyes.
---

Puns isn't bamboozling anyone. Except Leo

One cannot be both Town and Scum MVP at the same time.
---

ColZach posted...

Sultan seems scummier today than yesterday. I would take the risk and lynch here.

Huh. Did sultan post today yet

Oh he means because of the panth flip.

It really is 3am

turbopuns2 posted...

ColZach posted...

Sultan seems scummier today than yesterday. I would take the risk and lynch here.

Huh. Did sultan post today yet

No.

But Zach is also town so it doesn't matter
---

I don't get why Sheep would fakeclaim cop and take two potential mislynches off the table (me and Tange weren't widely town read)

Well it's possible Tange is scum too but eh seems like a dangerous gamble. He's going to have to keep clearing people or bussing his team
---

I mean I've got to be honest here, it's not like I'd have known town would lawyer from Panth onto Leo. Given I rescinded the claim when I did, Leo could have easily lived on. Doubly true if plum is cop since it fits Leo's obvious prepared fake claim to the tee and makes me look good at the same time. But lol lawyers

MZero11 posted...

I don't get why Sheep would fakeclaim cop and take two potential mislynches off the table (me and Tange weren't widely town read)

Well it's possible Tange is scum too but eh seems like a dangerous gamble. He's going to have to keep clearing people or bussing his team

Not like he necessarily plans to live forever. If he flips mafia all bets are off

Tag
---

Why on earth did you let red off the hook to lynch IGCD?
Ugh.
And why on earth didnt Panth tell us who his target was gonna be?
Double ugh.

And Tony and Sheep have yet to give us results?
And Sultan has yet to talk? He's looking mighty suspect already and that adds more to it.
---

Quick tangent: I came this close to quitting my job in the past couple days.

If I was more confident about the new job I hope to have in the next month or so. Or if I was less of a good person than I am, I probably would have just walked out. Nothing like being viciously lectured when you've done nothing wrong to force you to reconsider your stance on never walking out on a job. :/

.

But that's neither here nor there as far as mafia goes. I've got church in the morning, but no work (gasp) tomorrow evening so I'll definitely have some stuff to say and time to say it tomorrow afternoon/evening.

.

In light of panth's flip I will be primarily focusing on how things went down day 2. Based on how that day was progressing I believed as well as everyone else that 2 separate members of scum more or less collapsed and it was a scum vs scum lynch. That is a big part of why, when I was available during that twilight, I felt confident enough to use my power. It seemed like there would not be a better chance to use it regardless of who was going to be leading that day. As it turns out I got very lucky that it was panth and not leo, or I could have lawyered the other direction and killed both myself and panth. Or maybe not so lucky? Now that we know that what appeared to be scum vs scum was actually town vs scum I want to take a close look at who was instrumental in guiding the day towards panth. I know a good bit of it was the "simple logic" that scum had to be the RBer and was thus a more important target than a presumably spent janitor, but i'm betting there is something important from that day to look towards.

.

And lastly before bed, scare:

thinking

if scum has a bus driver ability

panth swapped with [?] last night

panth blocks tony

panth claims blocked because eaed claimed his action first

This was your "mentioning bus driver post" from topic 5 (RIP topic 5). I didn't want to call too much attention to it yesterday, but I was wondering if you had anything more to add to this topic. Or something more to add in general. I could be way off base here, but if I was reading you right then I hope you have something else to say.
---

If you are asking if I have info I'm a vanilla
---

But was thinking panth was blocker made me think up redirection scenarios where he still blocked tony
---

The game's up, Dumey. I scanned you last night, and you came up as scum. Was fun knowing you.

##Vote: Dumey

Overall, I'm really disappointed that we didn't lynch Red yesterday, and pissed at myself that I let the little bit of work he put in convince me to an extent instead of sticking to my initial read. I'm also a little pissed at the rest of town for being swayed so easily, and make no mistake that lynch was majority Town. However, I think we did catch two scum from it, since along with Red I'm fairly sure that Ben is also scum, and I already know Dumey is. The fact that Dumey is scum very, very heavily indicates that Red is also scum based on the votes. I could be wrong and it could have been a town/town lynch, but I just don't see it.

We're getting Dumey today, by the way, unless Red was blocked and neither of me and Tony were.
---

I dont follow that last line

And dumey huh.

You sneaky guy you

Also take it you were not masonized sheep
---

I was not masonised

And the last line is a stupid roundabout way of saying if Red is probably RB we kill him first for autowin
---

Sheep007 posted...

I was not masonised

And the last line is a stupid roundabout way of saying if Red is probably RB we kill him first for autowin

...this is literally dumb as hell dont throw the game.
---

Why would one more mislynch (assuming here) 'throw the game'?
---

htaeD posted...

Why would one more mislynch (assuming here) 'throw the game'?

He literally claims a guilty scan on someone and is randomly trying to come after me for the day. That makes 0 sense.
---

Seriously death, am I really having to explain to you why that makes no sense. What the hell dude.

I didn't survive yesterday just to get mislynched again the next.
---

Oh and Edumey as scum is a very probable thing. Too soon for scum to trade 1 for 1.

Surprised scum chose to not block the cop though.
---

I'm not trying to come after you for the day, if I was my vote would be on you. I'm saying that if you're likely to be scum roleblocker, we should lynch you, because that's basically an autowin barring any catastrophic errors.
---

red13n posted...

Seriously death, am I really having to explain to you why that makes no sense. What the hell dude.

I didn't survive yesterday just to get mislynched again the next.

I get that part, obviously. EDumey goes first.

But throwing the game is strong language.

Also you are fare from cleared any way, Red. I dont see how last day makes it so that we shouldnt lynch you ever.
---

htaeD posted...

I get that part, obviously. EDumey goes first.

But throwing the game is strong language.

Also you are fare from cleared any way, Red. I dont see how last day makes it so that we shouldnt lynch you ever.

lynching someone you very well know might be town over someone you are pretty much certain is scum is absolutely attempting to throw the game.
---

Good thing nobody is saying that then.
---

Sheep007 posted...

And the last line is a stupid roundabout way of saying if Red is probably RB we kill him first for autowin

he literally said it.
---

There's an if in that statement though.
If we had conclusive evidence of you being RB, I would do it too.

But I dont think Sheeps logic is correct: Even if Tony comes in unblocked with a watch, it could mean anything.
Scum could have blocked Eaed instead (Or Sultan). Do we even know who Eaed blocked?
---

Sheep007 posted...

if Red is probably RB

Is this you claiming probably RB then?

I wasn't talking about what I know of the current scenario, it was for if any information comes to light that indicates Red is probably RB. Which I realise is now unlikely since Eaed died last night and I didn't actually know until death said cause I skimmed flavour and the start of today, so we can't confirm his block.
---

Sheep007 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

if Red is probably RB

Is this you claiming probably RB then?

I wasn't talking about what I know of the current scenario, it was for if any information comes to light that indicates Red is probably RB. Which I realise is now unlikely since Eaed died last night and I didn't actually know until death said cause I skimmed flavour and the start of today, so we can't confirm his block.

no honestly you just worded it kind of weirdly. It felt like you were somehow implying I was roleblocker and trying to kill me.
---

(Spoilers, I am not scum of any kind)
---

Yeah I did word it weirdly, Scare said so too so that's probably my bad. I'm posting on about 3 hours of sleep right now so forgive me for being a bit off the ball.
---

Hell we technically have like 3 mislynches left.
With scum this disadvantaged I am thinking its possible they did have a poisoner, but on a scumjack who had to use janitor first.
---

How Ever
It makes no sense for scum to shoot Panth.. So I am stumped again.
---

Maybe Janitor was an extra kill on a Jack (because I struggle to believe there's not an extra kill for the scum team), and Corrik was the normal N1 target, but was saved by Ed?

Should that be the case Ben looks awful for his "clutch save last night" comment D2, which was already pretty shifty.
---

I would definitely be inclined to say scum didn't kill Panth, and his masonry did it, by the way. There was still a shot of lynching him, so if they had a second shot they should have gone for Tony, or me if Tony was able to be blocked.
---

Me too. Panth flipping town tells us more about day2 than scum might like.
---

Luckily for scum, topic 5 has purged and I think that's where the lynch itself was.
---

Unluckily for scum, we have the log site that gamefaqs doesnt want anyone to see.
---