Topic List |
Page List:
1, 2 |
---|---|
Lopen 04/14/17 2:01:40 AM #1: |
people outlasting ""the meeting room""(10):
1. Ben 4. IfGodCouldDie 6. Death (replaced JC) 8. Oddity 9. Tony 10. Eaed 12. Scare 14. Mzero 16. MenuWars (replaced Shad) 17. Lopen in the afterlife mercs golden corral happy hour (8): LD1: Ulti: Drakeryn, INDEPENDENT Spectator (renamed Survivor) KN1: ""Sir"" ""Chris"": Boko, TOWN Doctor KN1: JeezyMiyagi, TOWN RNJesus LD2:. Kanz: Luis, BADMIN Yes Man KN2: Corrik: trdl, TOWN Thief LD3 Johnbobb: Lopen, BADMIN "The" Badmin MKN3: Jaded_Eye: JC, TOWN Conspiracy Target KN3: Leo: KanzarisKelshen, TOWN Scumlord It is now Day 4. With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch. Day ends Friday 4/14/2017 at 10:00PM EST. --- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Leo3L 04/14/17 2:05:50 AM #2: |
Tag.
--- Do you enjoy fantasy card games, heavy drinking and awful puns? Check out Wasted Wizards! http://www.tinyurl.com/WastedWizards http://i.imgur.com/Rroj86F.png ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 2:06:27 AM #3: |
Lets see. Who the heck am I voting. I dunno. Lets do this though.
##Unvote ##Vote: ScarEaed --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Eddv 04/14/17 2:06:51 AM #4: |
... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 2:11:48 AM #5: |
Unofficial votals
[2] Ben - Tony, eaed [2] Oddity - Menu, MZero [1] IGCD - Lopen [1] eaed - IGCD [1] Death - (MZero), Scare [0] Scare - (IGCD), (Ben) [0] Tony - (Ben) No idea how to parse that vote Ben --- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 2:15:01 AM #6: |
End of Day 1 Votals
[9] Ulti: (IGCD), Corrik, Lopen, (IGCD), Chris, Leo, Leo2, Scare, Ben, Oddity, IGCD [3] Johnbobb: (Kanz), Tony, Ulti, Death, (Oddity) [1] Corrik: Shad, (VI), (Ulti) [1] Oddity: (Lopen), (Scare), MZero [1] Tony: (Death), Johnbobb [0] Shaduln: (Ben), (MZero) [0] MZero: (Oddity), (Kanz), (Oddity) [0] Ben: (Ulti), (Scare), (Mzero), (Leo), (Leo2) [0] Kanz: (MZero), (MZero) [0] Death: (Chris), (Ben), (Chris), (VI), (Ulti) [0] IGCD: (Ulti), (Oddity) [0] Chris: (Corrik) [0] Leo: (VI), (Ben), (Death), (Oddity), (chris) [0] Lopen: (IGCD), (Oddity), (Ulti), (Chris) [0] VI: (Ulti), (Ulti), (Oddity), (Oddity) End of Day 2 Votals [7] Kanz: (Corrik), (Oddity), (MZero), (Scare), (Leo), (Leo2), (Tony), (Corrik), Corrik, Ben, Lopen, Leo, Leo2, IGCD, Johnbobb [5] Johnbobb: Death, (Leo), (Leo2), Oddity, (Menu), Kanz, (IGCD), Menu, Tony [3] Death: MZero, (Lopen), Scare, (Corrik), (Oddity), (Johnbobb), (Jaded), (IGCD), Jaded, (IGCD) [1] Ben: Eaed, (Tony), (Leo), (Leo2), (IGCD) [0] Oddity: (Kanz), (Jaded), (Tony) [0] Jaded: (Menu) [0] Corrik: (IGCD) [0] Eaed: (Kanz), (Menu) [0] Menu: (Corrik) End of Day 3 Votals [7] Johnbobb - Lopen, Tony, Death, eaed, oddity, Menu, Scare [1] Lopen - (Leo), (Leo2), (Oddity), (Tony), Johnbobb [1] Death - MZero [1] ben - jaded [0] Leo - (IGCD) [0] IGCD - (Ben) [0] Oddity - (Tony) [0] eaed - (Tony) [0] Jaded - (Ben), (Leo), (Leo2) --- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 2:18:06 AM #7: |
Anyway I just wanna say that IGCD slipped big and I think everyone should read the last few pages of the last topic dammit. Also read how he reacts on post 404 and 405 to pressure and try and explain to me how that makes sense.
--- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 2:21:58 AM #8: |
not fully caught up yet
but My issue with death comes from just not liking how he handled everything with Ben, the inconsistencies miz pointed out. And when it was pointed out it was a slip he said it was barely a slip. Saying barely a slip means he acknoledged he slipped, and town doesn't slip I explained this back then (thanks for paying attention only to the parts that make me lynchable) It did slip my mind that I purposely pretended to not be PJbasis with that question so in that sense I counted it as technically barely a slip --- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 2:22:10 AM #9: |
forgot to quote the middle part there
--- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 2:26:40 AM #10: |
Lopen posted...
Anyway I just wanna say that IGCD slipped big and I think everyone should read the last few pages of the last topic dammit. Also read how he reacts on post 404 and 405 to pressure and try and explain to me how that makes sense. I read them and pondered about them in detail but... that's the thing about IGCD though... he'll get like that if you make him mad. I think the pressure I put on him was more telling, as if he thought I was scum trying to 1:1 him, because he didn't get mad and expressed thoughts clearly. But very very often when he's Town I'll see him self destruct like he did there, when people accuse him as you did there, so that's why I'm not into killing IGCD. Have you played with him before? --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 2:27:08 AM #11: |
oops I pulled a death. I hit the enter key prematurely
--- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 2:29:19 AM #12: |
No I have not and I don't think "they implode as town" is a good excuse for anyone. Particularly because Menu said he's never played with scum IGCD in the last topic IIRC.
--- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lolo_Guru 04/14/17 2:30:24 AM #13: |
Tag
--- Posted using GameFlux Get it now for Android from Google Play! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 2:31:36 AM #14: |
Lopen posted...
No I have not and I don't think "they implode as town" is a good excuse for anyone. Particularly because Menu said he's never played with scum IGCD in the last topic IIRC. Hey that's a good point. I dont really remember what scum IGCD is like either. I guess I'm just paranoid from all the countless times he's been mislynched and how I'm always one of the few defending him --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 2:45:52 AM #15: |
Can everyone confirm these claims are correct, and also put together the last 4.
Lopen - FFD, Watcher. Eaed - DC, Vengeful Poisoner Benjamin - Articuno, Vanilla MZero - Mewtwo, Vanilla Scare - Dante, Miller. Death - Pjbasis, Vanilla. Then I've also got ArkOfTurus, Tom Bombadil, Terastodon, and KommunistKoala in my head, all as vanillas, but no idea which of those are which. BTW I love how lucky scum was with hitting power roles christ. I was like "how are there 7 vanillas on the board + a miller" and it's like "well no vanillas are actually dead" On a purely claims basis I would be inclined to disbelieve: Dante, Ark, pj, DC. In that order. We can actually form a decent idea of what a balanced setup looks like at this point given what power there is and isn't. Who does a lot of balancing? What number of vanillas actually looks right? What number of scum? --- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
MenuWars 04/14/17 2:48:52 AM #16: |
I'm KommunistKoala, the others look correct. Can't remember who Ark was but I seem to remember someone calling bs on that claim.
--- I'm bad at Maffs. BEDMAS Bioshock, Earthworm Jim, Diablo 2, Mass Effect 2, Ark: Survival Evolved, Super Meat Boy ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 2:51:11 AM #17: |
IIRC it was Oddity as Tera, IGCD as Ark, Tony as Tom.
Possible I'm swapping the first two because I want IGCD to die and that fits my narrative almost too well. I remember discussing Tom's flavor text with Tony though. --- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
MenuWars 04/14/17 2:51:51 AM #18: |
It all depends on scum number and power aswell as the number of uses, but as a general rule less than half of town will be power. At least from the games I've played anyway.
--- I'm bad at Maffs. BEDMAS Bioshock, Earthworm Jim, Diablo 2, Mass Effect 2, Ark: Survival Evolved, Super Meat Boy ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 2:54:57 AM #19: |
Heh, you can't ask me. I do all my games with no Vanillas. (And no disabling roles like Miller either)
Hmm, I notice you distrust the vanilla claim of Ark. Why is that? I'm curious. Also, ArkOfTurus Claim belongs to Tony. Koala is menu. I thonk Tom was Oddity and the last one is IGCD's --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
MenuWars 04/14/17 2:59:03 AM #20: |
benjamin3740 posted...
Heh, you can't ask me. I do all my games with no Vanillas. (And no disabling roles like Miller either) Irrelevant to the game at hand but do these games play out well? I can only imagine them turning into dumpster fires for scum teams. Unless you use a lot of anti power like like vengeful, schizo and granny and stuff. --- I'm bad at Maffs. BEDMAS Bioshock, Earthworm Jim, Diablo 2, Mass Effect 2, Ark: Survival Evolved, Super Meat Boy ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 3:03:15 AM #21: |
Ugh, sorry, ignore my previous statements I'm probably remembering wrong. Also this is taking 5+ minutes to post, game faqs on my phone is lagging SO MUCH TODAY
--- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 3:06:05 AM #22: |
Ark was weird because the flavor given was "took over pj's team + lone shoto" Pj with two flavor references in the game seems dumb-- hell pj with one in the game sounds dumb but I digress. , To me it feels like a claim that may have been chosen because of an existing tether in the game to give it 'credibility' ala Kanzaris fakeclaiming Alany despite Leo2.
--- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 3:08:42 AM #23: |
also I am okay with testing Eaed today
better today than tomorrow in case we have 3 scum left (and worst case scenario, Eaed is town and his target is town, wont matter much when we're at even numbers) and since its a poison, I expect the target to not die until the next night, dont know if Eaed was ever clear on that regardless he feels shockingly inactive today --- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 3:10:03 AM #24: |
Lopen posted...
Ark was weird because the flavor given was "took over pj's team + lone shoto" Pj with two flavor references in the game seems dumb-- hell pj with one in the game sounds dumb but I digress. , To me it feels like a claim that may have been chosen because of an existing tether in the game to give it 'credibility' ala Kanzaris fakeclaiming Alany despite Leo2. thats also a thing for postgame discussion if Alany was on the safelist, Gravy was a big troll or he wanted people to not pay attention to inflavor name drops so much --- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 3:12:57 AM #25: |
MenuWars posted...
benjamin3740 posted...Heh, you can't ask me. I do all my games with no Vanillas. (And no disabling roles like Miller either) Well recently I've been doing non-traditional games which played out very well (In FF mafia there were multiple moves to choose from per class, and in Anonymous Death Note mafia the roles were set to characters and worked independently from allignment, so that players could claim their real role and only be judged on how it was claimed + how they used it). All my regular games were hosted on another forum, and if people complained about balance it was to Say that scum was too powerful... so I dunno how that happened... o__o somehow I've never heard a complaint about leaving out vanillas --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
bng_mmmk 04/14/17 3:14:12 AM #26: |
mmm golden corral
--- turbopuns ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 3:15:11 AM #27: |
If we're ever going to lynch eaed, today is the day. Otherwise scum can outfox it by just jumping off if 3 scum were left even if we're right on who the scum are-- if they do that when we're not at lynch/lose then we can punish.
We should decide who goes on the lynch beforehand though, as well as who eaed should poison. Now personally I think he should poison IGCD, but I'd also be okay with Scare. Any others would be compromise lynches at best and "no what the hell are you doing" at worst. --- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Lopen 04/14/17 3:17:27 AM #28: |
Really really doubt Alany was on the safelist. I've picked non safelisted roles before. Just gotta pick something that has sufficiently low chance of being in the game.
Angeal Hewley the Jack of All Trades in FFVII Mafia was my all time favorite. No one challenges the Crisis Core, son. --- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 3:35:29 AM #29: |
dont make me remember that Angael exists
--- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 5:45:39 AM #30: |
back to reading
one immediate question comes to mind @IfGodCouldDie you seemed suspect Ben at first did that change? --- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 6:15:59 AM #31: |
allthough Jaded did taunt IGCD and nothing bad happened to him, didnt he?
--- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 6:37:13 AM #32: |
aside: I dont like people dismissing my point against scare just because I only called it 'odd'
focus on the point, not just the pointmaker notes on the big Kanzpost from this page http://www.logfaqs.com/topic.php?id=75197504&page=8 - Kanz first vote-target after his easily abandoned quest against John is Mzero. makes Mzero even more town - Kanz seemingly didnt realize that Bens claim as PJ was a joke, which is also a point in Bens favor - He calls John and Oddity town in the same style basically, pushing Oddity towards a more townish slant - He stays ambivalent about Scare, dont like that for Scare's image - He has nothing to say about Eaed, Shad or IGCD. Cant say much on that yet, just wanted it noted --- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 6:54:41 AM #33: |
and the archives link
since this topic wasnt nice enough to give a link right away http://www.logfaqs.com/board.php?id=1&search=mafia --- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 7:29:41 AM #34: |
- Ben liked both John and Scare day1, something to keep in mind if Scare is flipped before Ben
Chaostony even questions him about this but only cares to ask why John looks good, not Scare wonder if Tony can even remember that far back to answer why he asked that (http://www.logfaqs.com/topic.php?id=75200663&page=3) - Mzero votes Kanz early even during the growing Ulti/Ben madness, especially a good act if Ben turns out to be town -Oddity has jumped around a LOT with his votes and it kinda stands out to me because they feel very reactive. But he's 'shooting from the hip' and none of them feel wrong or unexplainable. Getting a solidly town read from him, just town that focuses a lot on the game at hand instead of 'the archive' (as I think of the evidence backlog from past games). - regardless, pretty good senses by Mzero here, I wish I could say he was good enough to guess 3 scum day1, but I am not confidently there yet - minor push towards John starts halfway through topic3, Tony seems interested, but since its headed by Ulti it doiesnt really lead anywhere. All it gets is everyone immediately jumping on Ulti and Ben being indecisive about John. not getting many good vibes from early Bens own posts. Scare doesnt even talk about John, he just wants me/Ben or Oddity gone and votes the latter. Of course by now non-Ulti votes are starting to lose power, so I dont know if Scare was bussing Oddity here (and I am still not 100 % on Scare being scum anyway) - IGCD says What I would like is for the people that have been suspecting Miz to post some quotes regarding their attack on him. I want tangible proof. The reason I ask this, they seem to be saying a lot of things that Miz defends by saying that it just isn't true. Yet, I keep seeing him ask for it and they just keep going back at him. I think it's Kanz and death, maybe Johnbob. I will reread a little and point out the specific things I want responded to. He also says he's gonna help Mzero figure out people defending other people. He never comes back to either point, why not? - Oddity votes John when its way too late to matter, since ulti claimed Independent He says he is not caught up yet, but it still feels like a weak attempt to look towny that was it for day1 --- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Oddity 04/14/17 8:10:22 AM #35: |
Sup death, I'm around for 10-15ish minutes. I am unsure if I will be around before day ends. I will make every effort to be here before day ends, but I just wanted to put that out there (rl is complicated today). I was just going to put my vote on Tony but now I have to go back and look at whatever lopen's argument vs IGCD was (as for my own thoughts on him, I'm neutral to scum on him, not sure ben's gambit clears him).
--- His mind finally snapped and his rage boiled over. Like a slavering beast it consumed him destroying reason. He gazed upon the innocent, and they knew pain. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 8:19:30 AM #36: |
eh you could just vote Eaed and help the test the poisoner initiative if the worst happens
--- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Oddity 04/14/17 8:19:35 AM #37: |
##Vote: IGCD
I think Lopen's argument is solid (surprise surprise everybody, I'm running with an argument from my town reads again!). I have disagreed with IGCD a lot this game (day 1 or 2 I think it was he was exclaiming Ulti and Corrik both scum and eventually a side of ben, all of whom are town from scum's eyes). I was unconvinced by ben's 'gambit' against IGCD, I don't think it makes him look town. On the subject of ben, I still feel like he's town based off of the feel of his posts. If ben is scum, he's got me completely fooled. --- His mind finally snapped and his rage boiled over. Like a slavering beast it consumed him destroying reason. He gazed upon the innocent, and they knew pain. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Oddity 04/14/17 8:20:21 AM #38: |
I'm fine with testing the poisoner initiative, but if I might not be around, I'd rather have my vote on suspected scum. If you guys decide you want to test ed, I'm fine with it. Hopefully I'll be back around before end of day to change my vote.
--- His mind finally snapped and his rage boiled over. Like a slavering beast it consumed him destroying reason. He gazed upon the innocent, and they knew pain. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Oddity 04/14/17 8:26:16 AM #39: |
Oh yah, since I got called on this last time, I believe ben to be town, I just view him that way.
--- His mind finally snapped and his rage boiled over. Like a slavering beast it consumed him destroying reason. He gazed upon the innocent, and they knew pain. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
htaeD 04/14/17 9:02:09 AM #40: |
dont mind being prudent
--- 3DS FC: 3437-4283-5849 IGN: Alice ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
eaedwards6400 04/14/17 9:10:21 AM #41: |
Lopen I don't remember why I wasn't down on anyone on day 2.
Is it bad that I am not opposed to the lynch of myself? I have not been very useful as town this game and if we have a good idea on who else may be scum we can use this poison to our advantage. --- Cheer, Cheer for Old Notre Dame! GO VOTE FOR UCA! ~Join B8 on TEW!~ http://img818.imageshack.us/img818/9339/7vke.jpg ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Arti 04/14/17 10:25:06 AM #42: |
i was actually going to use Buy Brock as a topic title if it wasn't made at 2 AM votals:
[2] Ben - Tony, eaed [2] Oddity - Menu, MZero [2] IGCD - Lopen, Oddity [1] Death - (MZero), Scare [1] eaed - IGCD [0] Scare - (IGCD), (Ben) [0] Tony - (Ben) 6 to lynch, day ends in 11 hours 40 minutes --- DpOblivion's Best Game Ever Guru Bracket filled you with determination. http://backloggery.com/articuno2001/sig.gif ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
IfGodCouldDie 04/14/17 10:46:51 AM #43: |
Just fucking lynch me and end the game I am the last scum
--- Mind post. XBL:Cyanide Sucker PSN:Paters1 IGN:SuperPattyCakes ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
eaedwards6400 04/14/17 11:12:39 AM #44: |
##Unvote
##Vote: IGCD Happy easter??? --- Posted using GameFlux Get it now for Android from Google Play! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
IfGodCouldDie 04/14/17 11:13:32 AM #45: |
And remember at end game how Lopen "caught" me with "inconsistencies" that he "dug up" all while claiming a role that happened to catch scum red handed while never having to use his ability again because we don't even fucking know if a role blocker flipped
--- Mind post. XBL:Cyanide Sucker PSN:Paters1 IGN:SuperPattyCakes ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
eaedwards6400 04/14/17 11:16:20 AM #46: |
Why is no one here for this?!
--- Posted using GameFlux ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
IfGodCouldDie 04/14/17 11:20:15 AM #47: |
eaedwards6400 posted...
Why is no one here for this?! Don't know but congrats on the win --- Mind post. XBL:Cyanide Sucker PSN:Paters1 IGN:SuperPattyCakes ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 11:37:46 AM #48: |
@Death: I didnt necessarily like either as Town, I just didnt want to lynch them, especially not over the people I suspected (KANZ). I said I didnt want to lynch Scare that day, because his Miller claim sounded legit and I wanted to give him time in the pot. For Johnbob that was a very stupid weak read that I shouldnt have even had in the first place. I basically just said that Johnbob seems too nice to be scum. Yep, I actually thought that! Hadnt played with him before though, so it was dumb of me
--- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
IfGodCouldDie 04/14/17 11:41:46 AM #49: |
benjamin3740 posted...
@Death: I didnt necessarily like either as Town, I just didnt want to lynch them, especially not over the people I suspected (KANZ). I said I didnt want to lynch Scare that day, because his Miller claim sounded legit and I wanted to give him time in the pot. For Johnbob that was a very stupid weak read that I shouldnt have even had in the first place. I basically just said that Johnbob seems too nice to be scum. Yep, I actually thought that! Hadnt played with him before though, so it was dumb of me I've already admitted to being the last scum --- Mind post. XBL:Cyanide Sucker PSN:Paters1 IGN:SuperPattyCakes ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
benjamin3740 04/14/17 11:44:57 AM #50: |
Uhh... okay so I guess IGCD is scum. You had me mostly fooled
##Vote: IGCD But still, I dont get this. @_@ Sounds like scum team must be mad at Lopen. I see IGCD is trying to tell us Lopen is scum but... I dont think he'd do that. WHY GET YOURSELF LYNCHED AFTER BEING THREATENED WITH POISON? I guess that confirms Eaed town. Or is that the master plan? --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
Topic List |
Page List:
1, 2 |