all other Star War movies.

Topic List	Page List: 1
PIITB415 09/03/19 9:02:15 PM #1:	Fact --- https://imgur.com/VawbBVM https://imgur.com/6Si4h <cite>PIITB415 posted [p:926930358] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Fact</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/03/19 9:02:43 PM #2:	Factually wrong. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926930378] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Factually wrong.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
PIITB415 09/03/19 9:04:00 PM #3:	au_gold posted... Factually wrong. Imagine actually having this opinion. Your favorite Indiana Jones film is with Shia le whatever isn't it? --- https://imgur.com/VawbBVM https://imgur.com/6Si4h <cite>PIITB415 posted [p:926930441] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>Factually wrong.</quote> Imagine actually having this opinion. Your favorite Indiana Jones film is with Shia le whatever isn't it?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
joe40001 09/03/19 9:05:47 PM #4:	It's at least better than any other in the disney era --- "joe is attractive and quite the brilliant poster" - Seiichi Omori https://imgur.com/TheGsZ9 <cite>joe40001 posted [p:926930514] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>It's at least better than any other in the disney era</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
TheAnthraxBunny 09/03/19 9:06:41 PM #5:	Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out and took everything good about the franchise and turned it up to 11. The original trilogy is still better though. --- Yes, it is against the terms of service. Do not use the boards to set up orgies. -Alucard188 <cite>TheAnthraxBunny posted [p:926930553] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out and took everything good about the franchise and turned it up to 11. The original trilogy is still better though.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
PIITB415 09/03/19 9:25:26 PM #6:	TheAnthraxBunny posted... Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out and took everything good about the franchise and turned it up to 11. The original trilogy is still better though. As a solo film it is the strongest. It's sad the originals need a trilogy to compete --- https://imgur.com/VawbBVM https://imgur.com/6Si4h <cite>PIITB415 posted [p:926931389] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>TheAnthraxBunny posted...</cite> <quote>Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out and took everything good about the franchise and turned it up to 11. The original trilogy is still better though.</quote> As a solo film it is the strongest. It's sad the originals need a trilogy to compete</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/03/19 9:26:42 PM #7:	TheAnthraxBunny posted... Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out They even cut out the character development. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926931448] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>TheAnthraxBunny posted...</cite> <quote>Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out </quote> They even cut out the character development.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
The X Dawg 09/03/19 9:26:56 PM #8:	I mean, outside of the OT, it is the bee's knees. Might take it over A New Hope. <cite>The X Dawg posted [p:926931463] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>I mean, outside of the OT, it is the bee's knees. Might take it over A New Hope. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
SomeLikeItHoth 09/03/19 9:28:00 PM #9:	Solo was way better. --- FAM FOREVER. <cite>SomeLikeItHoth posted [p:926931504] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Solo was way better.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Zack_Attackv1 09/03/19 9:29:06 PM #10:	lol at actually believing that. --- https://imgur.com/kdF8WK0 <cite>Zack_Attackv1 posted [p:926931543] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>lol at actually believing that.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Behaviorism 09/03/19 9:31:09 PM #11:	Loved Rogue One. Best Star Wars after Empire --- Nikki Cross is a tag team champion! 8/5/19 <cite>Behaviorism posted [p:926931628] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Loved Rogue One. Best Star Wars after Empire </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Tired-Insomniac 09/03/19 9:31:18 PM #12:	It's the best prequel for sure --- "I like turtles" <cite>Tired-Insomniac posted [p:926931637] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>It's the best prequel for sure</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Southernfatman 09/03/19 9:34:02 PM #13:	ATSTs! ATSTs! Recognize thing!? Remember character!? I'm glad I can finally take Star Wars seriously now! For real, that's what RO seemed to me. A movie made so fanboys can ruin their underpants. Nothing really appealed to me. The story didn't need to be told and the characters (if you can call them that) were boring and not memorable. --- https://imgur.com/hslUvRN When I sin I sin real good. <cite>Southernfatman posted [p:926931739] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>ATSTs! ATSTs! Recognize thing!? Remember character!? I'm glad I can finally take Star Wars seriously now! For real, that's what RO seemed to me. A movie made so fanboys can ruin their underpants. Nothing really appealed to me. The story didn't need to be told and the characters (if you can call them that) were boring and not memorable.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
meralonne 09/03/19 9:36:11 PM #14:	I mean, its good and all... but better than all other Star Wars movies? --- "Sigs are for dorks."-- my wife <cite>meralonne posted [p:926931840] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>I mean, its good and all... but better than all other Star Wars movies? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
#15	Post #15 was unavailable or deleted.
Tired-Insomniac 09/03/19 9:39:03 PM #16:	RedWhiteBlue posted... The only thing that I'd have done to make the movie better is ramp up the force. Give it more showtime than just I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE AND THE FORCE IS WITH Me and the ending (which was fucking phenomenal). It's probably a top 3 Star Wars movie for me. There's one thing that IMO would have made it about 100x better Completely cut ~~Vader out of the movie, up until the hallway scene. Mention his name in passing once or twice, but don't show him at all until that lightsaber ignited in the dark~~ --- "I like turtles" <cite>Tired-Insomniac posted [p:926931955] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>RedWhiteBlue posted...</cite> <quote>The only thing that I'd have done to make the movie better is ramp up the force. Give it more showtime than just I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE AND THE FORCE IS WITH Me and the ending (which was fucking phenomenal). It's probably a top 3 Star Wars movie for me.</quote> There's one thing that IMO would have made it about 100x better Completely cut Vader out of the movie, up until the hallway scene. Mention his name in passing once or twice, but don't show him at all until that lightsaber ignited in the dark</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BlueBoy675 09/03/19 9:41:22 PM #17:	https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfJRm0WssOE" data-time=" --- Hope rides alone <cite>BlueBoy675 posted [p:926932045] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfJRm0WssOE" data-time=" </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
I Like Toast 09/03/19 9:41:27 PM #18:	Southernfatman posted... The story didn't need to be told No that's solo Southernfatman posted... and the characters (if you can call them that) were boring and not memorable. I am one with the force ,the force is one with me. Also mads mikkelsen is not forgettable in anything he does. The droid was also the best comic relief droid, much better than c3p0 Southernfatman posted... For real, that's what RO seemed to me. A movie made so fanboys can ruin their underpants. And that's tfa + slave leia in rtj --- If you do things right, people won't be sure you've done anything at all <cite>I Like Toast posted [p:926932052] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Southernfatman posted... </cite> <quote>The story didn't need to be told</quote>No that's solo Southernfatman posted... </cite> <quote>and the characters (if you can call them that) were boring and not memorable.</quote> I am one with the force ,the force is one with me. Also mads mikkelsen is not forgettable in anything he does. The droid was also the best comic relief droid, much better than c3p0 Southernfatman posted... </cite> <quote>For real, that's what RO seemed to me. A movie made so fanboys can ruin their underpants.</quote> And that's tfa + slave leia in rtj </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
billcom6 09/03/19 9:43:39 PM #19:	Rouge One is my favorite and it's not even close really. --- //constant loneliness// --- Steam and Fortnite: billcom6 My Teams: The Ohio State Buckeyes, New York Yankees, Buffalo Bills, The CBJ, Cavs <cite>billcom6 posted [p:926932143] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Rouge One is my favorite and it's not even close really.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Touch 09/03/19 9:45:01 PM #20:	When's Rogue Two --- https://i.imgtc.ws/6bQHG9L.gif <cite>Touch posted [p:926932211] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>When's Rogue Two</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
UnholyMudcrab 09/03/19 9:46:44 PM #21:	The last 45 minutes are good, but the rest of the movie is pretty dull. --- https://imgur.com/VeNBg https://imgur.com/gd5jC8q https://imgur.com/PKIy7 https://imgur.com/3p29JqP <cite>UnholyMudcrab posted [p:926932282] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>The last 45 minutes are good, but the rest of the movie is pretty dull.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/03/19 9:51:07 PM #22:	I Like Toast posted... Also mads mikkelsen is not forgettable in anything he does. His character was very forgettable. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926932454] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>I Like Toast posted...</cite> <quote>Also mads mikkelsen is not forgettable in anything he does. </quote> His character was very forgettable.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
I Like Toast 09/03/19 9:52:39 PM #23:	au_gold posted... His character was very forgettable. Spoken like a pleb --- If you do things right, people won't be sure you've done anything at all <cite>I Like Toast posted [p:926932514] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted... </cite> <quote>His character was very forgettable.</quote> Spoken like a pleb </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Hexenherz 09/03/19 9:52:42 PM #24:	BlueBoy675 posted... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfJRm0WssOE" data-time=" I'll never get tired of that rofl --- FFXIV: Herzog Erislieb (Cactaur) \| RS3: UltimaSuende . 99 WC/Fish/Cook/Fletch/Div/Mining/Smithing. 80 crafting <cite>Hexenherz posted [p:926932518] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>BlueBoy675 posted...</cite> <quote> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfJRm0WssOE" data-time=" </quote> I'll never get tired of that rofl</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/03/19 9:54:19 PM #25:	I Like Toast posted... au_gold posted... His character was very forgettable. Spoken like a pleb He was literally a plot device and nothing more. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926932580] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>I Like Toast posted...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted... </cite> <quote>His character was very forgettable.</quote> Spoken like a pleb </quote> He was literally a plot device and nothing more.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
tullock 09/03/19 9:54:29 PM #26:	Tired-Insomniac posted... RedWhiteBlue posted... The only thing that I'd have done to make the movie better is ramp up the force. Give it more showtime than just I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE AND THE FORCE IS WITH Me and the ending (which was fucking phenomenal). It's probably a top 3 Star Wars movie for me. There's one thing that IMO would have made it about 100x better Completely cut ~~Vader out of the movie, up until the hallway scene. Mention his name in passing once or twice, but don't show him at all until that lightsaber ignited in the dark~~ ~~His scene at the end was so fucking good.~~ --- ImgTC owner. <cite>tullock posted [p:926932589] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Tired-Insomniac posted...</cite> <quote>RedWhiteBlue posted...</cite> <quote>The only thing that I'd have done to make the movie better is ramp up the force. Give it more showtime than just I AM ONE WITH THE FORCE AND THE FORCE IS WITH Me and the ending (which was fucking phenomenal). It's probably a top 3 Star Wars movie for me.</quote> There's one thing that IMO would have made it about 100x better Completely cut Vader out of the movie, up until the hallway scene. Mention his name in passing once or twice, but don't show him at all until that lightsaber ignited in the dark</quote> His scene at the end was so fucking good.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
boxington 09/03/19 9:58:40 PM #27:	SomeLikeItHoth posted... Solo was way better. and while I don't feel strongly about Rogue One in any way, I agree with this: The droid was also the best comic relief droid, much better than c3p0 --- b-bb-box <cite>boxington posted [p:926932758] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>SomeLikeItHoth posted...</cite> <quote>Solo was way better.</quote> and while I don't feel strongly about Rogue One in any way, I agree with this: <quote>The droid was also the best comic relief droid, much better than c3p0</quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ledbowman 09/03/19 10:06:27 PM #28:	Rogue One is so tedious. Only Solo is worse --- I wish we all waved <cite>ledbowman posted [p:926933093] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Rogue One is so tedious. Only Solo is worse</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Skye Reynolds 09/03/19 10:09:58 PM #29:	It ruined the series in its current incarnation because of how much better Jyn is than Rey. Why would you ~~kill off a good protagonist~~ and give us multiple films of a bland one who has everything handed to her? If they can retcon ~~Darth Maul~~, they can retcon the ending of Rogue One as well. <cite>Skye Reynolds posted [p:926933247] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>It ruined the series in its current incarnation because of how much better Jyn is than Rey. Why would you kill off a good protagonist and give us multiple films of a bland one who has everything handed to her? If they can retcon Darth Maul, they can retcon the ending of Rogue One as well.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
PIITB415 09/03/19 10:14:53 PM #30:	Skye Reynolds posted... It ruined the series in its current incarnation because of how much better Jyn is than Rey. Why would you ~~kill off a good protagonist~~ and give us multiple films of a bland one who has everything handed to her? If they can retcon ~~Darth Maul~~, they can retcon the ending of Rogue One as well. This 100% Rey is garbage --- https://imgur.com/VawbBVM https://imgur.com/6Si4h <cite>PIITB415 posted [p:926933461] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Skye Reynolds posted...</cite> <quote>It ruined the series in its current incarnation because of how much better Jyn is than Rey. Why would you kill off a good protagonist and give us multiple films of a bland one who has everything handed to her? If they can retcon Darth Maul, they can retcon the ending of Rogue One as well.</quote> This 100% Rey is garbage</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
#31	Post #31 was unavailable or deleted.
Southernfatman 09/03/19 10:32:39 PM #32:	I Like Toast posted... No that's solo It's both. I Like Toast posted... I am one with the force ,the force is one with me. Also mads mikkelsen is not forgettable in anything he does. The droid was also the best comic relief droid, much better than c3p0 Only kind of remember that line, but only because you mentioned it. You're generally right about MM, but he is forgettable here to me. In terms of comic relief droids, CP30 is a low bar. I Like Toast posted... And that's tfa + slave leia in rtj You're right, but I won't complain about that last one. BlueBoy675 posted... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfJRm0WssOE" data-time=" I clapped when I saw this video! I know what that is! Seriously, they nailed it. --- https://imgur.com/hslUvRN When I sin I sin real good. <cite>Southernfatman posted [p:926934226] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>I Like Toast posted...</cite> <quote>No that's solo</quote> It's both. I Like Toast posted...</cite> <quote>I am one with the force ,the force is one with me. Also mads mikkelsen is not forgettable in anything he does. The droid was also the best comic relief droid, much better than c3p0</quote> Only kind of remember that line, but only because you mentioned it. You're generally right about MM, but he is forgettable here to me. In terms of comic relief droids, CP30 is a low bar. I Like Toast posted...</cite> <quote>And that's tfa + slave leia in rtj</quote> You're right, but I won't complain about that last one. BlueBoy675 posted...</cite> <quote> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfJRm0WssOE" data-time=" </quote> I clapped when I saw this video! I know what that is! Seriously, they nailed it.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BLAKUboy 09/03/19 10:34:21 PM #33:	I go back and forth whether ESB or RO are my favorite. --- Aeris dies if she takes more damage than her current HP - Panthera https://signavatar.com/26999_s.png <cite>BLAKUboy posted [p:926934283] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>I go back and forth whether ESB or RO are my favorite.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
HerpToTheDerp 09/03/19 10:37:18 PM #34:	au_gold posted... Factually wrong. <cite>HerpToTheDerp posted [p:926934412] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>Factually wrong.</quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ledbowman 09/03/19 10:39:46 PM #35:	RO is literally just a technical exercise --- I wish we all waved <cite>ledbowman posted [p:926934506] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>RO is literally just a technical exercise</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
joe40001 09/04/19 4:10:21 AM #36:	au_gold posted... TheAnthraxBunny posted... Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out They even cut out the character development. It had great character development, it just wasn't super in your face about it. --- "joe is attractive and quite the brilliant poster" - Seiichi Omori https://imgur.com/TheGsZ9 <cite>joe40001 posted [p:926943327] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>TheAnthraxBunny posted...</cite> <quote>Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out </quote> They even cut out the character development.</quote> It had great character development, it just wasn't super in your face about it.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MabusIncarnate 09/04/19 4:19:16 AM #37:	Rogue One was legitimately fantastic, I feel like even with the praise it's underrated. I can't put it in front of the original trilogy, but it's probably my favorite thereafter. --- Ten million dollars on a losing campaign, Twenty million starving and writhing in pain. Vicious_Dios Original - https://i.imgtc.ws/Zl0aw6F.png <cite>MabusIncarnate posted [p:926943428] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>Rogue One was legitimately fantastic, I feel like even with the praise it's underrated. I can't put it in front of the original trilogy, but it's probably my favorite thereafter. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/04/19 4:21:35 AM #38:	joe40001 posted... au_gold posted... TheAnthraxBunny posted... Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out They even cut out the character development. It had great character development, it just wasn't super in your face about it. It really didnt, but Id love to hear your case for it. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926943462] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>joe40001 posted...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>TheAnthraxBunny posted...</cite> <quote>Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out </quote> They even cut out the character development.</quote> It had great character development, it just wasn't super in your face about it.</quote> It really didnt, but Id love to hear your case for it.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
joe40001 09/04/19 4:36:13 AM #39:	au_gold posted... joe40001 posted... au_gold posted... TheAnthraxBunny posted... Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out They even cut out the character development. It had great character development, it just wasn't super in your face about it. It really didnt, but Id love to hear your case for it. Take Jyn, lots of people site how nothing she is in the first conference room as evidence for lack of character, but the fact that she is basically a passive nothing in the first coference room scene and then she's making a case for action in the second one was a pretty clear example for the audience of "hey this character is different now" It's like people wanted her to cartoonishly emote like rey does before they noticed her character. The characters are more realistic than lots of star wars characters and so because their expressiveness isn't turned up to 11 some people didn't see it, but basically every character goes from some sort of conformity or cynicism to rebellion and optimism. It's hope in the face of bad odds, and not the BS bad odds that the OT deals with where luck saves the day, no this time when the robot says There is a ninety-seven point six percent chance of failure." the percentages matter. Not everybody can be han solo and luke skywaker, there is a whole universe of people who aren't protected by plot armor whose desperate plays will likely get them killed, and since the stakes are real for those people their commitment to try in the face of that is IMO so much more compelling and impressive. --- "joe is attractive and quite the brilliant poster" - Seiichi Omori https://imgur.com/TheGsZ9 <cite>joe40001 posted [p:926943655] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>joe40001 posted...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>TheAnthraxBunny posted...</cite> <quote>Rogue One took everything bad about the franchise and cut it out </quote> They even cut out the character development.</quote> It had great character development, it just wasn't super in your face about it.</quote> It really didnt, but Id love to hear your case for it.</quote> Take Jyn, lots of people site how nothing she is in the first conference room as evidence for lack of character, but the fact that she is basically a passive nothing in the first coference room scene and then she's making a case for action in the second one was a pretty clear example for the audience of "hey this character is different now" It's like people wanted her to cartoonishly emote like rey does before they noticed her character. The characters are more realistic than lots of star wars characters and so because their expressiveness isn't turned up to 11 some people didn't see it, but basically every character goes from some sort of conformity or cynicism to rebellion and optimism. It's hope in the face of bad odds, and not the BS bad odds that the OT deals with where luck saves the day, no this time when the robot says There is a ninety-seven point six percent chance of failure." the percentages matter. Not everybody can be han solo and luke skywaker, there is a whole universe of people who aren't protected by plot armor whose desperate plays will likely get them killed, and since the stakes are real for those people their commitment to try in the face of that is IMO so much more compelling and impressive.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/04/19 5:04:37 AM #40:	You didnt give a single example of character development. Everyone ~~dying~~ at the end is not character development. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926944060] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>You didnt give a single example of character development. Everyone dying at the end is not character development.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
joe40001 09/04/19 5:13:57 AM #41:	au_gold posted... You didnt give a single example of character development. Everyone ~~dying~~ at the end is not character development. Did you read what I wrote? Jfc I can but it in dumb-dumb terms: Jyn was timid DEN SHE GOT BRAVE Cassian was cynic bad man DEN HE GOT HOPE AND GOOD HEART Baze didn't have faith DEN HE GOT SOME --- "joe is attractive and quite the brilliant poster" - Seiichi Omori https://imgur.com/TheGsZ9 <cite>joe40001 posted [p:926944205] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>You didnt give a single example of character development. Everyone dying at the end is not character development.</quote> Did you read what I wrote? Jfc I can but it in dumb-dumb terms: Jyn was timid DEN SHE GOT BRAVE Cassian was cynic bad man DEN HE GOT HOPE AND GOOD HEART Baze didn't have faith DEN HE GOT SOME</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/04/19 5:34:16 AM #42:	You act condescending, yet none of that was in your previous post. And thats preschool-level development at best. Besides, when was Jyn shown to be timid? From what I remember, she took charge almost immediately. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926944504] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>You act condescending, yet none of that was in your previous post. And thats preschool-level development at best. Besides, when was Jyn shown to be timid? From what I remember, she took charge almost immediately.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ALIEN_WORK2HOP 09/04/19 5:36:51 AM #43:	only thing that makes it good is it's similarities in designs and such to the OT. everything else is pretty lame --- If you have selfish, ignorant citizens, you're going to get selfish, ignorant leaders. <cite>ALIEN_WORK2HOP posted [p:926944536] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>only thing that makes it good is it's similarities in designs and such to the OT. everything else is pretty lame</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
joe40001 09/04/19 6:05:16 AM #44:	au_gold posted... You act condescending, yet none of that was in your previous post. And thats preschool-level development at best. Besides, when was Jyn shown to be timid? From what I remember, she took charge almost immediately. It was in my previous post. And there is nothing intellectually rigorous about you dismissing character development you didn't like and supporting the ones you did. Prove to me, using whatever apparent standards I am failing with in your metric, of Rey's character development. I pretty much guarantee that you can't construct evidence for her character arc in a way that is can't be just as easily shurgged off as "preschool level at best". When will people learn that flippant dismissiveness is not an argument? --- "joe is attractive and quite the brilliant poster" - Seiichi Omori https://imgur.com/TheGsZ9 <cite>joe40001 posted [p:926944880] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>You act condescending, yet none of that was in your previous post. And thats preschool-level development at best. Besides, when was Jyn shown to be timid? From what I remember, she took charge almost immediately.</quote> It was in my previous post. And there is nothing intellectually rigorous about you dismissing character development you didn't like and supporting the ones you did. Prove to me, using whatever apparent standards I am failing with in your metric, of Rey's character development. I pretty much guarantee that you can't construct evidence for her character arc in a way that is can't be just as easily shurgged off as "preschool level at best". When will people learn that flippant dismissiveness is not an argument?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/04/19 6:24:15 AM #45:	I never said Rey has character development. Straw man argument, etc. It sounds like youre making excuses for a movie you like. Which is fine, I like Rogue One too, but none of the characters are interesting and none of them have arcs. When the droid is more compelling than the human characters, you know theres a problem. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:926945161] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>I never said Rey has character development. Straw man argument, etc. It sounds like youre making excuses for a movie you like. Which is fine, I like Rogue One too, but none of the characters are interesting and none of them have arcs. When the droid is more compelling than the human characters, you know theres a problem.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Jiek_Fafn 09/04/19 6:30:32 AM #46:	It reminded me of a mcu movie with a different skin. Darth Vader in the hallway may be my favorite scene in the franchise though. --- PSN: Jiek <cite>Jiek_Fafn posted [p:926945270] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>It reminded me of a mcu movie with a different skin. Darth Vader in the hallway may be my favorite scene in the franchise though.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
joe40001 09/04/19 6:33:39 AM #47:	au_gold posted... I never said Rey has character development. Straw man argument, etc. It sounds like youre making excuses for a movie you like. Which is fine, I like Rogue One too, but none of the characters are interesting and none of them have arcs. When the droid is more compelling than the human characters, you know theres a problem. Straw manning is me making a bad and knowingly false characterization of your argument, since you were critical of Rogue one's character development it made seen for me to assume you thought the character development in at least some of the other modern star wars movies. So you don't think Rogue One has character development. But that's not much of a criticism if you don't think any modern star wars movie does. --- "joe is attractive and quite the brilliant poster" - Seiichi Omori https://imgur.com/TheGsZ9 <cite>joe40001 posted [p:926945320] in Rogue One ... [t:77985330]...</cite> <quote>au_gold posted...</cite> <quote>I never said Rey has character development. Straw man argument, etc. It sounds like youre making excuses for a movie you like. Which is fine, I like Rogue One too, but none of the characters are interesting and none of them have arcs. When the droid is more compelling than the human characters, you know theres a problem.</quote> Straw manning is me making a bad and knowingly false characterization of your argument, since you were critical of Rogue one's character development it made seen for me to assume you thought the character development in at least some of the other modern star wars movies. So you don't think Rogue One has character development. But that's not much of a criticism if you don't think any modern star wars movie does.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1

Current Events > Rogue One > all other Star War movies. (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > Rogue One > all other Star War movies.