LogFAQs > #933994171

Tsubomi: 6.5. It's a good attempt--I usually like these slow, emotional Japanese songs... I know it's not from a VN, but this feels a bit like "sad VN song" and those tend to do decently with me. I think. That one Clannad song did at any rate.

I think I just never really connected to the lyrics or choice of imagery, which limited it to a "several steps above average, but not like, a really large number of steps" level.

(I have nothing of value to say of the original.)



Amekigoe Zankyou: Somewhere between 4 & 6, and I can't narrow it down any further than that. I think it might be one of those songs where it's a bit too on point--I love rain, I like Kaf, I like the type of atmosphere the song is going for--but it never really works for me. Happens to a lot of songs that seem like things I'm supposed to love.

Part of me wants to give it a 4; if I didn't really like it, the score probably should be below average. But then it offers a lot for me to think about in terms of why I didn't like it and it's likely to be something I remember, so it should be slightly above average. So... somehow it's both? Which would make ranking it difficult, but this isn't actually a ranking, so I don't have to be overly concerned by it.

(The original again doesn't fare any notably better or worse.)



Kimi to...I forget the rest of the song title, but it's that cover by Else, you know the one: Between 5 & 6. I know it isn't, but it feels like the intro to some anime. Somehow it just reminds me of CLANNAD After Story's intro--try mashing them up:

https://tubedubber.com/?q=RateoYRQ6jQ:_x1Hx7Wfweg:0:100:0:7:1

...well not quite a perfect match, but this song makes me pictures like those in that intro. Which isn't bad (I can't remember anything about the show outside of the ending, but I watched the entire thing, so it probably wasn't bad), but "inspires vague flashbacks to the intro of an anime I watched once a long time ago" isn't exactly an earth-shattering ranking either.

Impression may be skewed by the first song got me thinking of SAD VN SONGS, which put me in a Clannad sort of mood anyway.



Stratostella: I think I'll go with a 5. A lot of other people managed to emotionally connect with it, but I don't really feel anything? To this or the Miku version. It's just kinda there.
---

A not very secret alt account for when Raetsel wants to be a pony