Case 5 > 4 > 2 > 1 > 3
Case 5 would be, like, mid-tier in AA and case 3 would be bottom 10.
Overall, they're OK, not great.
That said, that only takes the cases themselves into account. The character-building, especially around specifically Tyrion and Celeste, was SUPER good, and that's not included in my rankings. Their overall plot was fantastic, and is the main reason I'm still happy I went through this experience.
AND THEY KISSED AHHHHHHHHHHH