Definitely Remake.
About half of Rebirth is bad, lots of awful filler content. However, Rebirth does have some really, high highs that I loved a lot, the middle is really good.
At the end of the day I beat Remake 3 times, twice in a row, and did everything. I completely skipped almost all the side content in Rebirth for the back half of the game and I will never play it again. By the end of it it felt like I was fulfilling an obligation, that it was a game In had to beat just because.
https://i.ibb.co/Twbb1b6/20240223-211737.jpg
https://youtu.be/qj9p6IFSlnk?si=cZ5L4OPM0TjVjwCD