Isquen posted...
What is everyone's "I'm town and here's how" proof? I'm still relying heavily on Lopen vouching for me and the fact I am not a good secret keeper.
TBH I don't even think I should be given much "credit" for D1. I literally stated at the time that I didn't expect Peaf to actually break up with me because there wasn't much incentive as either alignment. If I get anything from D1, it's just a willingness to initiate a breakup when I was safe and had been the whole day, regardless of my partner. IMO, my town case is more from general play and D3 End of Day.
JC genuinely does look better from EoD D1. As multiple people like Red, FD, and Ulti have also corroborated, JC pretty much is only scum if literally all three of Peaf/Dumey/JC was the scum team. And I know I'm town. Basically the argument here from other perspectives is that you'd have to believe that all three of Peaf, JC, and I as scum willingly put ourselves at risk at end of day separately for that to happen. None of us were forced into it. It was all willing participation. It just doesn't make sense.
MZero and FD are PoE only. They've both been present and playing. They haven't done anything that would give them strong town or scum credit in either direction, unless you have a strong strong player read on one or the both of them. FD hasn't played scum in forever, so I'm not sure anyone could confidently player read him outside of general play. MZero I examined yesterday with his pressure on Sultan and Ulti, but pretty much everyone that interacted with it said, "meh looks okay/normal to me." If we were to lynch them today or tomorrow, it's purely out of paranoia that scum was sitting back and not being involved with the previous days' lynches.