EDumey posted...
My opinion hasn't changed that much from before. I think Kirby is probably like 95% town. But admittedly, Kirby has TWO end of day scenario's pointing against him.
D1. I know I'm town and Peaf left my date to hang himself up. Could have been a solo play by Peaf, or an attempt to save Kirby.
D2. I know I'm town and Ulti gave his life to me, and urged me to dump him to save Red, before Kirby took the Red date. There was a chance Kirby gets killed there. I talked about this with Lopen earlier, and I think there is a universe where exactly Ulti + Kirby explains motivation here. Otherwise Ulti is town.
So basically I think scum is exactly Ulti + Kirby, or both are probably town.
Corrik7 posted...
Is there any scenario where a town Kirby wouldn't do exactly the same?
I'm not sure I understand your question. Yeah, Town Kirby could have acted the same in both situations. Just explained by FAFO Peaf and Town Ulti.
I guess my argument is that in MY head, lynching Kirby kind of clears Ulti in my mind, so we can focus on the rest of the PoE. But other people may not agree that Ulti's EoD2 play requires a scum Kirby there.