Valentine's Day Mafia Topic 5: Better to have Loved and Died

Board 8

Page of 10
Board 8 » Valentine's Day Mafia Topic 5: Better to have Loved and Died
htaeD
02/29/2024
01:57 PM
#1
Player List:
  1. Enchantress (Lea)
  2. Mzero
  3. Lopen
  4. Chaeix (JC)
  5. Isquen
  6. FD
  7. Ulti
  8. Dumey
  9. Corrik
  10. Red
  11. Sultan
  12. Kirby
  13. Sir Chris


Updated Pairs (as of Topic 4, Post #430)

Paired
Red and FD

Open Offers
Ulti: Isquen, Mzero
Chris: Sultan
Lea: Kirby

Day 2 will end on Friday, 2/30 at 7pm Eastern.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
#2
Post #2 was unavailable or deleted.
EDumey
02/29/2024
02:20 PM
#3
So anyways, let's not lynch Kirby.
my links broke. :(
Chaeix
02/29/2024
02:21 PM
#4
Man I know that Im kind of coasting (its my last day on pot and nicotine before I try to cut them out so Im going to be fried all day) but that post from Chris just reads so badly.

Chris/Sultan date setting off all kinds of alarm bells.
we're all buds ~jc~
<DeathChicken> you are my hero for being the first person to cite National Geographic in Mercs
TheSultanOfSlam
02/29/2024
02:21 PM
#5
EDumey posted...
So anyways, let's not lynch Kirby.

Who do you suggest
YOU WILL BOW DOWN TO THE SULTAN
Hello Here is a pineapple
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:21 PM
#6
EDumey posted...
So anyways, let's not lynch Kirby.
Well good news you can make sure that doesn't happen
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:21 PM
#7
Chaeix posted...
Man I know that Im kind of coasting (its my last day on pot and nicotine before I try to cut them out so Im going to be fried all day) but that post from Chris just reads so badly.

Chris/Sultan date setting off all kinds of alarm bells.
And you are powerless to stop me. Mwhaha
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
Forceful_Dragon
02/29/2024
02:22 PM
#8
The irony is that if they both refuse to budge we're just stuck dealing with it until day 3 no matter what <_<
~C~ FD
http://i.imgur.com/dGDfxaw.png
Kirby321
02/29/2024
02:22 PM
#9
SirChris posted...
Tbh I'm just chilling because lopen was right day 1 so I am letting him cook to see what he has for us. I feel no need to think on the game further

Then why did you immediately go on the defensive and pair up with Sultan?

Red is absolutely right. You are the absolute last player I'd expect to go "no thoughts head empty" and follow Lopen of all people.

red13n posted...
When I say always disregard Lopen logic, I mean it. If theres a player wordy enough to make their atrocious logic sound plausible to a crowd of mostly average to less logic players, he probably sounds great. If you look at his logic track record...no. Just no.
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
EDumey
02/29/2024
02:22 PM
#10
TheSultanOfSlam posted...
Who do you suggest

One of MZero/Isquen/Corrik/Chris

I feel like I'm forgetting someone.
my links broke. :(
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:23 PM
#11
Kirby321 posted...
Then why did you immediately go on the defensive and pair up with Sultan?

Red is absolutely right. You are the absolute last player I'd expect to go "no thoughts head empty" and follow Lopen of all people.
Ok then lynch me

O wait
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:23 PM
#12
Mostly for fun on the sultan point

Secondly new year new Chris. I was very wrong day 1 so I am fine with looen doing his thing.
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:25 PM
#13
Although if me pairing with Sultan felt defensive your tone read of my intent is very far off. I said earlier I would date sultan and then you kirby said we didn't get a pass. The layup was right there
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
Lopen
02/29/2024
02:25 PM
#14
Kirby openly shading my play is the dawn of the first day of Kirby scum play
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
red13n
02/29/2024
02:26 PM
#15
I didn't change topics because I was replying from the previous page.
"First thing that crosses my mind: I didn't get any GameFAQs Karma yesterday." Math Murderer after getting his appendix removed.
Enchantress
02/29/2024
02:27 PM
#16
I offered to date Kirby already, but just like D1 his kink is edging, by which of course I mean getting as close to the edge of the lynch cliff as possible. Which is part of the reason I thought he was town D1. It would be sooooo incredibly easy for scum to not wind up the last slice of pizza everyone is afraid to take. I can't help but feel scum goijg to even numbers immediately has got to hurt their options.
Forceful_Dragon
02/29/2024
02:27 PM
#17
red13n posted...
I didn't change topics because I was replying from the previous page.

Thank you for answering my question.
~C~ FD
http://i.imgur.com/dGDfxaw.png
TheSultanOfSlam
02/29/2024
02:28 PM
#18
EDumey posted...
/Isquen/Corrik/

I'd be okay with these two isquen gets mislynched more than anyone though idk if I want to lynch Isquen atm though
YOU WILL BOW DOWN TO THE SULTAN
Hello Here is a pineapple
Lopen
02/29/2024
02:29 PM
#19
UltimaterializerX posted...
Lopen, if Lea gets killed today and flips scum, you can kill me tomorrow and use me for whatever bait you want. Deal?

Why not Kirby first
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
Enchantress
02/29/2024
02:30 PM
#20
Ulti wants to lynch all millers because that's just the kind of guy he is this week
Kirby321
02/29/2024
02:30 PM
#21
SirChris posted...
Although if me pairing with Sultan felt defensive your tone read of my intent is very far off. I said earlier I would date sultan and then you kirby said we didn't get a pass. The layup was right there

And yet the difference is that I haven't accepted nor initiated any dates yet. Because I don't fear dying. Why should I? I'm town.

So why are you cowering behind Sultan? Why do you have literally nothing to say about the events that transpired behind Day 1? What were you even wrong about?

Your behavior is not town-like. It's entirely motivated by self-preservation, and you aren't trying to develop the town thought process at all.
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
Lopen
02/29/2024
02:31 PM
#22
Why isn't Ulti pushing hard for a Kirby lynch today

Guy was hell murder on him yesterday

I've presented solid logic that points to him being scum of "let's assume that Peaf did not spontaneously go insane" and Ulti isn't biting. Why.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:31 PM
#23
Because I can. Look at me. All afraid of you. Scary dum pink blob Dante better anyway
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
Lopen
02/29/2024
02:31 PM
#24
Maybe the team is just Ulti + Kirby and I've betrayed Lea wrongly
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:33 PM
#25
But let me be clear the best way to self preserve would be to try. But I found your attempt at pressing me adorable so I decidedcto do what I did. I said most of yesterday I don't mind dying and that remains true today

The exception is when you try the tough guy act. Then I am going to roll my eyes and cower behind sultan.
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
EDumey
02/29/2024
02:33 PM
#26
Taking Advantage of Intended Game Mechanics:
*Isquen-Ulti
Sultan-Chris
Red-Someone

The Lopen Veto:
Lea-Kirby

Dumey
Lopen
MZero
FD
JC
Corrik

Red, if Lopen, FD, JC, and I all didn't want to play your game, would you look to Mzero or Corrik for shelter?

Sultan/Chris, do you like this current direction for town, or do we need a mulligan?

*I recognize that Isquen hasn't taken Ulti's date yet. Just assoomin that's a natural thing to happen.
my links broke. :(
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:34 PM
#27
I consider a scum death day 1 in a 12-3 non mountainous to be horribly brutal for scum. Massive leap forward for town tbh. If I wasn't fine with lopen leading I would say so
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
Chaeix
02/29/2024
02:34 PM
#28
SirChris posted...
And you are powerless to stop me. Mwhaha
until d3 when you guys cant partner up again

but thats when Ulti inexplicably throws you guys if youre all still alive
we're all buds ~jc~
<DeathChicken> you are my hero for being the first person to cite National Geographic in Mercs
red13n
02/29/2024
02:35 PM
#29
EDumey posted...
Red, if Lopen, FD, JC, and I all didn't want to play your game, would you look to Mzero or Corrik for shelter?

I would look to anyone for shelter if I had to.
"First thing that crosses my mind: I didn't get any GameFAQs Karma yesterday." Math Murderer after getting his appendix removed.
Kirby321
02/29/2024
02:35 PM
#30
I have to admit that this game enabling people to just sit back and not play the game is wearing thin on my patience.

If I were petty, I'd just take Lea's date and shut up for the rest of the day. But I'm not giving up just yet, even if my faith in town getting the victory here is dwindling by the second.
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:35 PM
#31
Chaeix posted...
until d3 when you guys cant partner up again

but thats when Ulti inexplicably throws you guys if youre all still alive
I am sure I can find love again day 3
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
Chaeix
02/29/2024
02:36 PM
#32
hey Chris can you just copy/paste everything death said into the topic btw, I feel like we should take advantage of this format
we're all buds ~jc~
<DeathChicken> you are my hero for being the first person to cite National Geographic in Mercs
EDumey
02/29/2024
02:36 PM
#33
red13n posted...
I would look to anyone for shelter if I had to.

that wasn't the question. opinion pls.
my links broke. :(
Lopen
02/29/2024
02:36 PM
#34
I know Kirby doesn't actually think I'm bad at the game

He's cracking
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:36 PM
#35
That's allowed?
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
Kirby321
02/29/2024
02:36 PM
#36
SirChris posted...
I am sure I can find love again day 3

Indeed. Right after you kill off the players who won't actively throw the game.
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
Kirby321
02/29/2024
02:37 PM
#37
SirChris posted...
That's allowed?

Yes.

changmas posted...
When Day 2 starts, your ability to post in these channels will be removed, but you will still be able to view that channel for the rest of the game. You are permitted to copy-paste from discord into the game, if you so choose. Do not screenshot, please.

Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
Enchantress
02/29/2024
02:37 PM
#38
Corrik chose to be in this game to the point of insisting on first come first served. We could have had Wallz, totally tubular. So if he's town, I really expect him to do something eventually. He doesn't know the 7 words that can make any Isquen fall in love with you

SirChris
02/29/2024
02:37 PM
#39
Kirby321 posted...
Indeed. Right after you kill off the players who won't actively throw the game.

*looks at the scum corpse*

Man we suck at throwing
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
EDumey
02/29/2024
02:37 PM
#40
SirChris posted...
That's allowed?

copy paste okay
screenshots not okay
my links broke. :(
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:38 PM
#41
Oh yeah I was so torn with grief I forgot. One sec
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
Lopen
02/29/2024
02:39 PM
#42
SirChris posted...
*looks at the scum corpse*

Man we suck at throwing

Right?

This is performance.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
Forceful_Dragon
02/29/2024
02:39 PM
#43
copy paste means it could potentially be altered, as opposed to a screen shot which would be much more difficult to fake.
~C~ FD
http://i.imgur.com/dGDfxaw.png
red13n
02/29/2024
02:39 PM
#44
SirChris posted...
That's allowed?

It shouldn't be but apparently is. I hate to be the rules stickler but we really should disallow chat posting in the future.
"First thing that crosses my mind: I didn't get any GameFAQs Karma yesterday." Math Murderer after getting his appendix removed.
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:39 PM
#45
Okay death posted a lot I will just post end of night conclusions mostly lol
Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
red13n
02/29/2024
02:40 PM
#46
EDumey posted...
that wasn't the question. opinion pls.

It actually was the question if you read it differently like I did. It was ambiguous. I'm assuming you meant, who would you shelter, mzero or corrik?
"First thing that crosses my mind: I didn't get any GameFAQs Karma yesterday." Math Murderer after getting his appendix removed.
Kirby321
02/29/2024
02:40 PM
#47
Lopen posted...
I know Kirby doesn't actually think I'm bad at the game

He's cracking

You're a good guy, Lopen.

But I don't believe your competence comes out until way later in the game. You forget that I was on the scum team for Yu-Gi-Oh mafia that actively kept you alive because we thought you were handicapping town super hard. I only took you as a legitimate threat on the final day when you were able to actually solve the game.

Unfortunately, that's just reinforced here. You're absolutely town, but you're not right. I'm sure if I give it a few hours, you'll switch to someone else being scum.
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
Lopen
02/29/2024
02:41 PM
#48
My flowchart is now

Kirby
->
Ulti

Then go from there.

Really just two scum could have existed in that madness. Kirby is the only one that had to be scum.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
SirChris
02/29/2024
02:42 PM
#49
Dumey makes it clear he wont date Peaf again and wants one of Lea, Lopen or JC. Lea also wants to snipe Peaf, which she made clear beforehand and chooses to dare Lopen who already had a date invite open for her. This already condemns Peaf to have to hope for JC to take him. But JC and Dumey quickly choose each other.
Basically its hard to see any Dumey, Lea, Lopen, JC as scum unless one of those pairs is full scum
In which case I trust JC and Dumey less than Lopen and Lea
Oh right I forgot about Isquen and Corrik, the worst pair
Man the boring answer here is to look at Mzero and Red mostly. But I am still not super convinced that Sultan is clean.
Well there's my top 4/5 scum. Cant say which of those is most paired with Peaf since none of them ever spoke about Peaf
Ulti tanking his good cred by believing Peafs claim, rofl
Doesnt make him scum tho
I dont suppose night actions already being due would mean that we should know by now if one of us is dead.
Though I would be surprised if you died before me. Lol
But I am done for today. Sorry I cant be there when day starts, I am sure town will understand.

Rip death

Can't we give ourselves one more chance?
Trying my best. If I fail, let me know.
#50
Post #50 was unavailable or deleted.
Board 8 » Valentine's Day Mafia Topic 5: Better to have Loved and Died
Page of 10