ChaosTonyV4 posted...
They explain it:
according to Tukkun beliefs, the fact that he attempted to kill/led everyone to kill is as good as killing.
Pretty sure this isn't true. I am pretty sure they thought he killed the other tulkuns. Like, Lo'ak after bonding wants to go to the chieftain and explain this and the daughter of the chieftain says her father will understand if he does, and he is not allowed to.
The whole thing was that he was wrongly outcast. In your scenario, he was appropriately outcast. Which doesn't line up with the movie. I'm not saying 100% you are wrong, but I think you are.