I actually agree with you at some level
I think where you and others underestimate me is that that conspiracy theory can shift around and that actually does make me a bit more flexible than you think. I'm always re-evaluating the pieces in my theories and eventually they make enough sense that it ends up being right.
For instance in this game I found Poppy and Kirby protecting BCT which means Poppy and Kirby and BCT fit into place as a scum team doing a lot of theatre day 1.
But then I re-evaluated and saw a scenario where just Poppy and Kirby were doing theatre to pocket BCT as being likely (which was correct-- despite playing around with the same pieces in the theory)
I also think you misread my outward conviction in a lynch as my actual scum read 100% when a lot of time I'm doing it because pressure creates content.
For as much as you guys say "oh Han did so well" I would argue Ulti's theory on what Han does is part of why all our lynch trains went with hardly any votes until 2 hours before before deadline speaks to that criticism potentially being at least somewhat correct.
Like if you or Chris are town and helping harness me we create a lot of chaos and can generally shake out scum. It has happened many times before. Han in my games being town with him actively works against trying to do that unless it makes his theory on the game fit-- which creates situations where a good lynch isn't solved until just before deadline because he's too afraid of being wrong on a scum unless there is a player who can generate that pressure for him (and isn't actively fighting against him). The easy solution is to just blame me for rattling him but I don't think that's truly evaluating what's happening correctly-- it's probably no coincidence that the only games I remember Han actually carrying for town are ones where he had power roles and that as vanilla I tend to remember him being right about a lot but the game being lost anyway.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!