Like basically the thing to realize is that no matter how much "evidence" you find, no matter how much gut your read has, if you've got like 5 or 6 players thinking one guy is scum, with some of them making decently reasonable arguments, they're probably more likely to be scum than the dude you had a scum lean on that you just came across in a reread.
Especially
if you were reading that one as possible scum too.
Especially
if someone previously thought to be town would likely be doubting you inherently because you're claiming their role.
Like you did it in day 1 too. Lots of arguments for hb, but you're like "nah, Blade, let's start a different train cause all these arguments can't possibly be as good as my rng town read on hb and Blade meowing and not caring"
It's less embarrassing with Blade cause you were (half-- hb was scum) right but like, yeah. That's where the team game comes in, willingness to humor arguments not put forth by yourself-- stupid ass fakeclaims to draw shots not as much.
Like you'll note I actually admitted I didn't even really buy the lynch on red at first in day 2-- this is 100% true by the way and I was just pushing for the lynch pressure because other people, a few of which I were confident were town, were suspicious of him. It was only after his reaction to pressure that I became convinced he was scum-- but yeah like, if I'm playing like you we probably don't even catch Red. I'm just bashing popcorn fairy into the wall all day and accomplishing nothing.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!