Wwe mafia Topic 2: The SOLE SURVIVOR

Players list

1. Pezlo
2. Tom
3. Ulti
4. Eaed
5. Corrik
6. Sbell
7. Scare
8. puns
9. IGCD
10. 5tar
11.Han
12. Panth
13. MZero
14. Death
15. Red

Day ends MONDAY 11EST

hello scums

I like pez's stance of relying on reads rather than power and claims

it's also funny seeing someone play with Corrik for the first time

MZero11 posted...

I like pez's stance of relying on reads rather than power and claims

it's also funny seeing someone play with Corrik for the first time

Enough of you are playing with me for the first time, that I'm honestly surprised I'm not being voted out the wazzoo. It's something that used to happen a lot. I had to rely heavily on Tom to translate for me.

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Scare, you got nothing on me?

I liked you, would put you above eh, bottom of town

What makes Tom townie?

Hey puns.

Whats got you in a tiz over Tom? You said fishy earlier.

I'm still low key waiting for @Lolo_Guru or @TheSultanOfSlam to confirm this as an official topic. But if enough discussion happens then meh I think it will be by default.

turbopuns3 posted...

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Scare, you got nothing on me?

I liked you, would put you above eh, bottom of town

What makes Tom townie?

I liked his interactions with pez to start the game

I WAS considering having fish for lunch but yeah I like having actual things to respond to

pezloco posted...

I'm still low key waiting for @Lolo_Guru or @TheSultanOfSlam to confirm this as an official topic. But if enough discussion happens then meh I think it will be by default.

Use this topic at post 470ish

Obellisk posted...

Hey puns.

Whats got you in a tiz over Tom? You said fishy earlier.

You might say it's the cut of his Gibb.

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Scare, you got nothing on me?

I liked you, would put you above eh, bottom of town

What makes Tom townie?

I liked his interactions with pez to start the game

I think Tom is at best a null tell right now.

pezloco posted...

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Scare, you got nothing on me?

I liked you, would put you above eh, bottom of town

What makes Tom townie?

I liked his interactions with pez to start the game

I think Tom is at best a null tell right now.

Has tom given the reverse yet?

Leafeon13N posted...

pezloco posted...

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

ScareChan posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Scare, you got nothing on me?

I liked you, would put you above eh, bottom of town

What makes Tom townie?

I liked his interactions with pez to start the game

I think Tom is at best a null tell right now.

Has tom given the reverse yet?

I don't believe so.

Kids are in bed and the Pirates just for done breaking my heart. I'll be catching up.

the ROOMMATE POWERS are not in full effect yet but gun to my head I'd say town

Votals
NoLynch(2): (Tom), Tom, Pez
Sbell(1): han, (scare)
Tom(1): Puns
Han(1): (Corrik), Sbell
Death(1): Corrik
mzero(0): (Tom) (Corrik)
Corrik(1):Ulti
5tar(1):Scare

Han

remember how we got Reg as scum right off the bat?

thats starscream this game

Hi I agree that starscream nbn is scum also ultinisnprobably town because I don't think he blows me after last ga.e

So, I've waited for awhile and been a little coy. I wanted to give Tom and Red some time to post.

For those of you who don't know, Tom and I used to be roommates. That's how I came to play mafia here. I mostly played on AIM, but I played here on the board a number of times too. Tom and I are typically very good at reading each other, beyond what most could believe. In fact when we lived long enough to get a read we've only been wrong once each I think (counting both AIM and board mafia). But my memory might be faulty there.

Why did I include Red in this? Well Red played with us a bunch on AIM and he's played in almost every board game I've played in too. He knows how good we are at reading each other.

I've dropped hints all day about distrusting Tom. I've made sure to mention it every so often. It should've come up in any skimming that Red did.

So, Red knows about the roommate powers as Tom and I call them. And I've been waiting to see if he would bite on any of those nibbles I've left about being suspicious of Tom. Red has a tendency to lurk. He let people know ahead of time he'd be at Disney and then when he showed up today he mentioned flying today (I hoped we might get through D1 before Disney was a problem for him).

Red didn't bite for most of the day. So, I've been leaning towards Red and Tom as both scum.

If Red is town then theoretically he sees me being suspicious of Tom and with knowledge of the roommate powers he would comment on that especially with all the recklessness going on elsewhere.

If Red is scum and Tom is town, then Red is ok with me being suspicious of Tom and maybe will use it in the future. Also, maybe he uses it at that moment to build momentum on a Tom lynch which he can then blame on em.

If Red and Tom are both scum, then Red will want to minimize my suspicion on Tom. Red will mostly do this by ignoring any obvious comments about it and probably not bring up Roommate Powers at all.

It's only D1 so all of this could be meaningless. But I think both are a better lynch than most of the current suspects. I'd rather we move away from the likes of Death and Corrik. I'd still be ok with SBell. Mostly because I don't have a good read on him. I think we've already moved away from Han, but we should definitely stay away.

##Unvote: NL
##Vote: Tom

This isn't roommate powers, so be ready to jump off of him if I tell you to. But for now better lynch than any other suspect.

FYI, what I was looking for from Tom when he came back was a wall of text. He used to give these huge walls of text after he'd be away. He's come back. No wall of text. He kind of explained that by saying that there's not much to respond to? I disagree. But maybe I just feel that way because I've been posting all day.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

ultinisnprobably town because I don't think he blows me after last ga.e

Why not?

pezloco posted...

So, I've waited for awhile and been a little coy. I wanted to give Tom and Red some time to post.

For those of you who don't know, Tom and I used to be roommates. That's how I came to play mafia here. I mostly played on AIM, but I played here on the board a number of times too. Tom and I are typically very good at reading each other, beyond what most could believe. In fact when we lived long enough to get a read we've only been wrong once each I think (counting both AIM and board mafia). But my memory might be faulty there.

Why did I include Red in this? Well Red played with us a bunch on AIM and he's played in almost every board game I've played in too. He knows how good we are at reading each other.

I've dropped hints all day about distrusting Tom. I've made sure to mention it every so often. It should've come up in any skimming that Red did.

So, Red knows about the roommate powers as Tom and I call them. And I've been waiting to see if he would bite on any of those nibbles I've left about being suspicious of Tom. Red has a tendency to lurk. He let people know ahead of time he'd be at Disney and then when he showed up today he mentioned flying today (I hoped we might get through D1 before Disney was a problem for him).

Red didn't bite for most of the day. So, I've been leaning towards Red and Tom as both scum.

If Red is town then theoretically he sees me being suspicious of Tom and with knowledge of the roommate powers he would comment on that especially with all the recklessness going on elsewhere.

If Red is scum and Tom is town, then Red is ok with me being suspicious of Tom and maybe will use it in the future. Also, maybe he uses it at that moment to build momentum on a Tom lynch which he can then blame on em.

If Red and Tom are both scum, then Red will want to minimize my suspicion on Tom. Red will mostly do this by ignoring any obvious comments about it and probably not bring up Roommate Powers at all.

It's only D1 so all of this could be meaningless. But I think both are a better lynch than most of the current suspects. I'd rather we move away from the likes of Death and Corrik. I'd still be ok with SBell. Mostly because I don't have a good read on him. I think we've already moved away from Han, but we should definitely stay away.

##Unvote: NL
##Vote: Tom

This isn't roommate powers, so be ready to jump off of him if I tell you to. But for now better lynch than any other suspect.

FYI, what I was looking for from Tom when he came back was a wall of text. He used to give these huge walls of text after he'd be away. He's come back. No wall of text. He kind of explained that by saying that there's not much to respond to? I disagree. But maybe I just feel that way because I've been posting all day.

Whoa hold on now. Ive not done a full read of the game. Been able to skim through for major events(miller claim) and been able to see recent posts when poking in but full read i have not.

my wall of text is waiting on a thing, although it won't be a huge wall

as for red I don't remember him being big into ROOMMATE POWERS~ but maybe I have him mixed up with chris

Leafeon13N posted...

pezloco posted...

So, I've waited for awhile and been a little coy. I wanted to give Tom and Red some time to post.

For those of you who don't know, Tom and I used to be roommates. That's how I came to play mafia here. I mostly played on AIM, but I played here on the board a number of times too. Tom and I are typically very good at reading each other, beyond what most could believe. In fact when we lived long enough to get a read we've only been wrong once each I think (counting both AIM and board mafia). But my memory might be faulty there.

Why did I include Red in this? Well Red played with us a bunch on AIM and he's played in almost every board game I've played in too. He knows how good we are at reading each other.

I've dropped hints all day about distrusting Tom. I've made sure to mention it every so often. It should've come up in any skimming that Red did.

So, Red knows about the roommate powers as Tom and I call them. And I've been waiting to see if he would bite on any of those nibbles I've left about being suspicious of Tom. Red has a tendency to lurk. He let people know ahead of time he'd be at Disney and then when he showed up today he mentioned flying today (I hoped we might get through D1 before Disney was a problem for him).

Red didn't bite for most of the day. So, I've been leaning towards Red and Tom as both scum.

If Red is town then theoretically he sees me being suspicious of Tom and with knowledge of the roommate powers he would comment on that especially with all the recklessness going on elsewhere.

If Red is scum and Tom is town, then Red is ok with me being suspicious of Tom and maybe will use it in the future. Also, maybe he uses it at that moment to build momentum on a Tom lynch which he can then blame on em.

If Red and Tom are both scum, then Red will want to minimize my suspicion on Tom. Red will mostly do this by ignoring any obvious comments about it and probably not bring up Roommate Powers at all.

It's only D1 so all of this could be meaningless. But I think both are a better lynch than most of the current suspects. I'd rather we move away from the likes of Death and Corrik. I'd still be ok with SBell. Mostly because I don't have a good read on him. I think we've already moved away from Han, but we should definitely stay away.

##Unvote: NL
##Vote: Tom

This isn't roommate powers, so be ready to jump off of him if I tell you to. But for now better lynch than any other suspect.

FYI, what I was looking for from Tom when he came back was a wall of text. He used to give these huge walls of text after he'd be away. He's come back. No wall of text. He kind of explained that by saying that there's not much to respond to? I disagree. But maybe I just feel that way because I've been posting all day.

Whoa hold on now. Ive not done a full read of the game. Been able to skim through for major events(miller claim) and been able to see recent posts when poking in but full read i have not.

Notice where my vote is. I understand it's D1 and what not. This post was to generate discussion as much as preserve my thoughts for future days.

Tom Bombadil posted...

my wall of text is waiting on a thing, although it won't be a huge wall

as for red I don't remember him being big into ROOMMATE POWERS~ but maybe I have him mixed up with chris

He has definitely cited us multiple times. Chris was always less enthused by it because he didn't think I could read you better than he could.

Your roommate powers are always at the front of my mind you should know this.

Leafeon13N posted...

Your roommate powers are always at the front of my mind you should know this.

Which is why when you didn't bite after multiple times I said I was suspicious of Tom, I got a lot of red flags.

##vote:Tom

dat bandwagon vote tho

pezloco posted...

Leafeon13N posted...

Your roommate powers are always at the front of my mind you should know this.

Which is why when you didn't bite after multiple times I said I was suspicious of Tom, I got a lot of red flags.

Ideally I would've waited until more of D1 had passed. But apparently I can't trust Corrik not to hijack the day with either absurd claims or actually using a day 1 power. So, if I want to preserve these thoughts like I said I did. I needed to pre-empt any more silliness from him.

If you dont like it give me someone else to vote

IfGodCouldDie posted...

If you dont like it give me someone else to vote

I mean it's kind of everyone's job to give suspects. Tom said he has a (small) wall of text incoming after a thing of some sort happens. Why don't you give some more content than a vote and a deflection?

I would say sbell or corrik or han

or no lynch~~~

Tom Bombadil posted...

I would say sbell or corrik or han

or no lynch~~~

How much of the day have you read?

all of it

Tom Bombadil posted...

all of it

What are your thoughts about why I think Corrik is town?

So Tom has this moved the needle on your pez read

pezloco posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

all of it

What are your thoughts about why I think Corrik is town?

I am not particularly convinced those couldn't be scum moves rather than misguided town ones. I am not sure I have played with Corrik but I do know he plays a whole lot these days, so I am willing to cut him a below average amount of slack on stuff like that.

turbopuns3 posted...

So Tom has this moved the needle on your pez read

slightly more town

UltimaterializerX posted...

Roommate powers? -_-

They aren't even actual roommates anymore if you are insinuating cheating with that face.

back in the aim days we would take bathroom breaks at weird times to throw each other off

I can't take anything that pezloco says about Tom or red seriously if he literally said to lynch a guy because he can't read him.

(that guy is me)

UltimaterializerX posted...

Leafeon13N posted...

UltimaterializerX posted...

Roommate powers? -_-

They aren't even actual roommates anymore if you are insinuating cheating with that face.

It's not that at all, more of "how the fuck am I supposed to contribute to a conversation this dumb?".

Thank you.

Also

@TheSultanOfSlam I unvoted

I literally can't remember the last time one of them claimed roommate powers and was wrong.

Obellisk posted...

I can't take anything that pezloco says about Tom or red seriously if he literally said to lynch a guy because he can't read him.

(that guy is me)

When did I say we should lynch you? I thought I said you were a better lynch than person X. Also, when did I say specifically I don't have a read on you? Again I thought I've been pointing at you as one of my suspects. It's D1 though so I probably said something along the lines of I don't have a strong read. Because no one really should have anything too strong on D1.

@ulti You can contribute based on how you think Red might respond. It's not all about Tom.

I will happily expand on my thoughts about Tom once he's posted his wall he said is coming. I'm not expecting anyone to counter roommate powers. I said multiple times that I'm trying to generate discussion and preserve thoughts. If Tom's wall does indeed come out I've encouraged him to contribute more and that's a win. Red already has contributed more, though he's also gone back to lurking it looks like.

The roommate powers are not meant to be anything more than hey I know this guy really well, therefore you should take my opinion with greater weight than player X who barely knows him. Our interpretations of each other should be weighed against your own reads. If you have a strong read a different direction that's great have at it.